Passat Diesel Engines
Author
Discussion

taxboy

Original Poster:

270 posts

229 months

Thursday 15th July 2010
quotequote all
The 2.0 comes with 140 & 170BHP versions. Has anyone driven both and care to comment e.g. are they equally as smooth running and does the 140 feel sluggish in normal driving compared to the 170

TIA

TDIfurby

1,997 posts

206 months

Thursday 15th July 2010
quotequote all
I can't claim experience on the passat, but Dad had a Golf 140 2.0 TDI a while back and now has a 170 2.0 TDI Audi TT. The Golf was fine to drive. No real lag, enough poke. Just a nippy diesel. The 170 engine feels a little more refined (It is a common rail, not PD though) and you can't really tell it has an extra 30hp most of the time. When pushing the engine the extra power is felt more at the top end, which lets face it, how often do you take a derv above 3000rpm? biggrin

And for the record, both are much slower than my own derv biggrin

taxboy

Original Poster:

270 posts

229 months

Friday 16th July 2010
quotequote all
TDIfurby said:
I can't claim experience on the passat, but Dad had a Golf 140 2.0 TDI a while back and now has a 170 2.0 TDI Audi TT. The Golf was fine to drive. No real lag, enough poke. Just a nippy diesel. The 170 engine feels a little more refined (It is a common rail, not PD though) and you can't really tell it has an extra 30hp most of the time. When pushing the engine the extra power is felt more at the top end, which lets face it, how often do you take a derv above 3000rpm? biggrin

And for the record, both are much slower than my own derv biggrin
Thanks for this & BTW what is your current engine of choice

TDIfurby

1,997 posts

206 months

Saturday 17th July 2010
quotequote all
I have a PD130 engine in my Skoda Fabia, only I've fettled with it so it's closer to 300bhp. biggrin

taxboy

Original Poster:

270 posts

229 months

Saturday 17th July 2010
quotequote all
TDIfurby said:
I have a PD130 engine in my Skoda Fabia, only I've fettled with it so it's closer to 300bhp. biggrin
That's some fettling

y2blade

56,322 posts

246 months

Saturday 17th July 2010
quotequote all
TDIfurby said:
I have a PD130 engine in my Skoda Fabia, only I've fettled with it so it's closer to 300bhp. biggrin
fantastic
smile diesel is the way to go that's for sure cool

I can't wait to join the club biggrin

icepop

1,181 posts

238 months

Wednesday 21st July 2010
quotequote all
I've driven both engines in the Golf model, not the Passat. The 140bhp, 16v engine, I found less willing to the 150bhp, 8v PD engine, in my Bora, just doesn't seem to have the same Oommph somehow. The 170 bhp, 16v engine, on the other hand, seemed as strong as the one in the Bora, but about 8 mpg down. There's just something about the way the engine urge relates to the accelerator push, (if that makes sense), in the 140/170 16v engines, thats not as linear to the 8v PD engines, more like the Ford TDCI engine, is it a common rail thing do you think ? I'm sure I'll end up with one of the 16v engines once my Bora comes to the end of it's life, but at present I'd still be tempted to stick to the 1.9 engine in the Audi/Seat.

ge0rge

3,053 posts

236 months

Wednesday 21st July 2010
quotequote all
Would love to hear more about the 130 going on 300 brake diesel, really fancy a high powered diesel golf or something - just not many tuners take diesel tuning seriously...?

y2blade

56,322 posts

246 months

Wednesday 21st July 2010
quotequote all
ge0rge said:
Would love to hear more about the 130 going on 300 brake diesel, really fancy a high powered diesel golf or something - just not many tuners take diesel tuning seriously...?
not many PHers do either frown

they'll learn wink

DSM2

3,624 posts

231 months

Friday 23rd July 2010
quotequote all
I've driven both and own a 170 Passat CC. 'Normal' driving the 140 is fine but the 170, obviously, is better when loaded up or pushing on.

Also owned a Passat 130TDi 1.9 for a while and a 150bhp PD Golf. The 2.0 engine is much, much smoother and, even with an auto the CC has averaged 49mpg over 6000 miles. 55mpg taking it easy, 46 pushing on.

TDIfurby

1,997 posts

206 months

Friday 23rd July 2010
quotequote all
ge0rge said:
Would love to hear more about the 130 going on 300 brake diesel, really fancy a high powered diesel golf or something - just not many tuners take diesel tuning seriously...?
What do you want to know? Not many tuners get involved, bar perhaps Jabbasport, for the serious derv tuning. This is why I sourced many parts and the techniques personally and got my mate who runs a garage to do the majority of the hard work. The car has been 6 years in the making, so been very progressive from 100bhp up to nearly 300bhp (my car is originally a pd100 TDI but has been converted to pd130)

va1o

16,118 posts

238 months

Saturday 24th July 2010
quotequote all
Also worth pointing out the current shape Passat initially used the 2.0 TDI PD, and then it changed to Common Rail (CR) a couple of years ago. The latter is far smoother and quieter. Can't really offer any help on the 140 vs 170 front though, best advice would be try both if you can.

taxboy

Original Poster:

270 posts

229 months

Saturday 24th July 2010
quotequote all
DSM2 said:
I've driven both and own a 170 Passat CC. 'Normal' driving the 140 is fine but the 170, obviously, is better when loaded up or pushing on.

Also owned a Passat 130TDi 1.9 for a while and a 150bhp PD Golf. The 2.0 engine is much, much smoother and, even with an auto the CC has averaged 49mpg over 6000 miles. 55mpg taking it easy, 46 pushing on.
Thanks for that - are you pleased with the CC ? Care to list what you really like and any niggles it has please

DSM2

3,624 posts

231 months

Wednesday 28th July 2010
quotequote all
taxboy said:
DSM2 said:
I've driven both and own a 170 Passat CC. 'Normal' driving the 140 is fine but the 170, obviously, is better when loaded up or pushing on.

Also owned a Passat 130TDi 1.9 for a while and a 150bhp PD Golf. The 2.0 engine is much, much smoother and, even with an auto the CC has averaged 49mpg over 6000 miles. 55mpg taking it easy, 46 pushing on.
Thanks for that - are you pleased with the CC ? Care to list what you really like and any niggles it has please
I'm very pleased with it!! Got it mid March, have done 6500 faultless miles. It's pretty well specced and is very quiet and a good soft ride in comfort. Put it in sport and it corners and handles well for size of car and the steering weight alters to suit.

What do I really like? The long distance ability due to the ride, quietness and fuel consumption. The 'multi device interface' (!) which has an ipod permanently in there and gives full ipod interface on screen. The SatNav apart from only 4 digit postcodes. The on screen visual parking aid which is useful, given the size and shape of the car

Dislikes? Not much. The voice activation thing is not very practical and the air conned seats don't seem very effective, but there's not much to seriously dislike for me.

All in all suits me far better than my previous BMW 320D, which is probably the reason why I now appreciate the ride quality of the CC.


taxboy

Original Poster:

270 posts

229 months

Wednesday 28th July 2010
quotequote all
DSM2 said:
taxboy said:
DSM2 said:
I've driven both and own a 170 Passat CC. 'Normal' driving the 140 is fine but the 170, obviously, is better when loaded up or pushing on.

Also owned a Passat 130TDi 1.9 for a while and a 150bhp PD Golf. The 2.0 engine is much, much smoother and, even with an auto the CC has averaged 49mpg over 6000 miles. 55mpg taking it easy, 46 pushing on.
Thanks for that - are you pleased with the CC ? Care to list what you really like and any niggles it has please
I'm very pleased with it!! Got it mid March, have done 6500 faultless miles. It's pretty well specced and is very quiet and a good soft ride in comfort. Put it in sport and it corners and handles well for size of car and the steering weight alters to suit.

What do I really like? The long distance ability due to the ride, quietness and fuel consumption. The 'multi device interface' (!) which has an ipod permanently in there and gives full ipod interface on screen. The SatNav apart from only 4 digit postcodes. The on screen visual parking aid which is useful, given the size and shape of the car

Dislikes? Not much. The voice activation thing is not very practical and the air conned seats don't seem very effective, but there's not much to seriously dislike for me.

All in all suits me far better than my previous BMW 320D, which is probably the reason why I now appreciate the ride quality of the CC.
Thanks for taking the time to post your comments -it's interesting you prefer it to a 320D. I was considering a 320 as well as the Passat moving from my E39

taxboy

Original Poster:

270 posts

229 months

Wednesday 28th July 2010
quotequote all
DSM2 said:
taxboy said:
DSM2 said:
I've driven both and own a 170 Passat CC. 'Normal' driving the 140 is fine but the 170, obviously, is better when loaded up or pushing on.

Also owned a Passat 130TDi 1.9 for a while and a 150bhp PD Golf. The 2.0 engine is much, much smoother and, even with an auto the CC has averaged 49mpg over 6000 miles. 55mpg taking it easy, 46 pushing on.
Thanks for that - are you pleased with the CC ? Care to list what you really like and any niggles it has please
I'm very pleased with it!! Got it mid March, have done 6500 faultless miles. It's pretty well specced and is very quiet and a good soft ride in comfort. Put it in sport and it corners and handles well for size of car and the steering weight alters to suit.

What do I really like? The long distance ability due to the ride, quietness and fuel consumption. The 'multi device interface' (!) which has an ipod permanently in there and gives full ipod interface on screen. The SatNav apart from only 4 digit postcodes. The on screen visual parking aid which is useful, given the size and shape of the car

Dislikes? Not much. The voice activation thing is not very practical and the air conned seats don't seem very effective, but there's not much to seriously dislike for me.

All in all suits me far better than my previous BMW 320D, which is probably the reason why I now appreciate the ride quality of the CC.
Thanks for taking the time to post your comments -it's interesting you prefer it to a 320D. I was considering a 320 as well as the Passat moving from my E39

DSM2

3,624 posts

231 months

Thursday 29th July 2010
quotequote all
taxboy said:
DSM2 said:
taxboy said:
DSM2 said:
I've driven both and own a 170 Passat CC. 'Normal' driving the 140 is fine but the 170, obviously, is better when loaded up or pushing on.

Also owned a Passat 130TDi 1.9 for a while and a 150bhp PD Golf. The 2.0 engine is much, much smoother and, even with an auto the CC has averaged 49mpg over 6000 miles. 55mpg taking it easy, 46 pushing on.
Thanks for that - are you pleased with the CC ? Care to list what you really like and any niggles it has please
I'm very pleased with it!! Got it mid March, have done 6500 faultless miles. It's pretty well specced and is very quiet and a good soft ride in comfort. Put it in sport and it corners and handles well for size of car and the steering weight alters to suit.

What do I really like? The long distance ability due to the ride, quietness and fuel consumption. The 'multi device interface' (!) which has an ipod permanently in there and gives full ipod interface on screen. The SatNav apart from only 4 digit postcodes. The on screen visual parking aid which is useful, given the size and shape of the car

Dislikes? Not much. The voice activation thing is not very practical and the air conned seats don't seem very effective, but there's not much to seriously dislike for me.

All in all suits me far better than my previous BMW 320D, which is probably the reason why I now appreciate the ride quality of the CC.
Thanks for taking the time to post your comments -it's interesting you prefer it to a 320D. I was considering a 320 as well as the Passat moving from my E39
The 320 I had from new in 05 until the end of 09, 80K miles. All round a good car but the ride was awful with RFTs, odd with normal tyres and I find it difficult to justify maybe another £6K to get close to the VW spec.