A6 lemans avant
Author
Discussion

andyscole

Original Poster:

205 posts

242 months

Saturday 17th July 2010
quotequote all
Just some advice please. I am currently looking for a bmw 530 or 535d Tourings but have seen a couple of very nice a6 avants, which with the right spec actually look a little smarter than the bm. Spending around 18k.

My only concern is I currently own bm 330d but previously had an a4 v6 quattro and the driving enjoyment steering feel etc was poor in the Audi. I have test driven and they feel better but not great.

So question is does anyone currently own one and their thoughts. Plus what are pro's and con's v's the 5 series?

Thanks

UVB

557 posts

224 months

Sunday 18th July 2010
quotequote all
I previously had an A4 3.0 petrol quattro before going to the A6 3.0 diesel quattro le mans avant. I tried various 5 series and also had one as a loan car for a couple of weeks before making the decision for the Audi.

The 5 series SE spec has the best suspension set up of all of them, but the steering rack is way too slow. The sport version has the best steering of all of them, but the suspension setup is way too hard. The A6 is a compromise between them all. It's really a little too firm on the suspension (the 19" wheels don't help here) and the steering is marginally too slow for my liking but overall it seems more rounded for my liking. Having 4wd does dull the steering feel a little but the benefits of 4wd outweigh the disadvantages imho.

The Le mans spec A6 is a very good looking car indeed....can't really say the same for the 5 series. It isn't ugly, but you'd definitely be buying it for its dynamic capabilities rather than appearance. The A6 is quite some way better than our old (B6 model) A4 in terms of feel and comfort. I can't stand the current model A4 due to the offset pedals/footwell intrusion and lesser quality (I suspect Audi may be making the mistake Mercedes did a few years back).

I personally think the interior of the A6 is massively better than the 5 series, but coming from an Audi in the first place would always make that more likely; you may feel less so if you're used to BMW's. When I say interior, I mean switchgear layout/ease of use as well as design/build quality.

From an ownership perspective I've been disappointed with the mpg, getting around 31-32mpg on average. There's been a recent thread on here suggesting that this could be down to diesel pump timing I think; I'm planning on getting that checked when I get round to it to see if it gets better. Some other owners do seem to report better mpg but most seem to be similar. I'm not entirely sure what the BMW's get but I believe it's higher. Our particular variant also falls into the top road tax bracket by one measly, annoying CO2. The manual version doesn't, but is harder to find and I have no idea what it's like to drive. There's been some niggles with phone connectivity but I can't be sure if that was the car or the phone. I bought the RSAP adaptor for it which proved excellent when it worked but it would sometimes drop out for no apparent reason soon after hooking up. It would then reconnect a couple of mins later and be fine. When working in RSAP mode it was fantastic, but you need your phone to support RSAP as well. I forgot that point when I recently changed phones and I'm kicking myself for it now. I had a Jag XF loan car recently and that exhibited similar symptoms on a standard bluetooth connection as well - but the 5 series loan car I had a year or so back worked flawlessly all the time (again on standard bluetooth).

When I was still contemplating the A6/5 series it was very apparent that my budget bought more in terms of spec/age/mileage with an A6 than a BMW. Came across a good spec one at a good price and snapped it up - have been very happy with it ever since. With what's currently in the market I'd definitely buy the same again, but I'd probably look at a manual as well next time round if only to satisfy my curiosity.