Quattro purchase dilemma...
Quattro purchase dilemma...
Author
Discussion

Caractacus

Original Poster:

2,622 posts

256 months

Sunday 25th July 2010
quotequote all
Hi all,

I'm going to be driving about 25000 miles per annum through the bottom two thirds of Wales each year. A lot of these will be on B roads.

I've decided upon a Quattro due to the added safety when encountering mud, slurry and gravel...darn farmers! smile

The dilemma comes from which to buy - an A3 Quattro 5 door 170 S Line (or Sport) or an A4 Quattro 170 Avant. Is there much between these two apart from boot space?

MPG is up there on the list of priorities, but I still find myself looking at the A4 3.0L Quattro Avant. The spec says up to 36MPG - Is this wishful thinking? My goal is 40mpg average.

This will be a 2nd hand purchase and the budget is circa £17K.

What are your thoughts?

Cheers,

C.

blueg33

46,943 posts

255 months

Sunday 25th July 2010
quotequote all
Caractacus said:
Hi all,

I'm going to be driving about 25000 miles per annum through the bottom two thirds of Wales each year. A lot of these will be on B roads.

I've decided upon a Quattro due to the added safety when encountering mud, slurry and gravel...darn farmers! smile

The dilemma comes from which to buy - an A3 Quattro 5 door 170 S Line (or Sport) or an A4 Quattro 170 Avant. Is there much between these two apart from boot space?

MPG is up there on the list of priorities, but I still find myself looking at the A4 3.0L Quattro Avant. The spec says up to 36MPG - Is this wishful thinking? My goal is 40mpg average.

This will be a 2nd hand purchase and the budget is circa £17K.

What are your thoughts?

Cheers,

C.
I have an A6 3.0tdi Tiptronic Quattro. Trip computer currently shows the average at 36.1 mpg. I do 60% on motorways. At 75 on mway the mpg is 40-41 with aircon on and 42-44 with aircon off

Caractacus

Original Poster:

2,622 posts

256 months

Sunday 25th July 2010
quotequote all
blueg33 said:
Caractacus said:
Hi all,

I'm going to be driving about 25000 miles per annum through the bottom two thirds of Wales each year. A lot of these will be on B roads.

I've decided upon a Quattro due to the added safety when encountering mud, slurry and gravel...darn farmers! smile

The dilemma comes from which to buy - an A3 Quattro 5 door 170 S Line (or Sport) or an A4 Quattro 170 Avant. Is there much between these two apart from boot space?

MPG is up there on the list of priorities, but I still find myself looking at the A4 3.0L Quattro Avant. The spec says up to 36MPG - Is this wishful thinking? My goal is 40mpg average.

This will be a 2nd hand purchase and the budget is circa £17K.

What are your thoughts?

Cheers,

C.
I have an A6 3.0tdi Tiptronic Quattro. Trip computer currently shows the average at 36.1 mpg. I do 60% on motorways. At 75 on mway the mpg is 40-41 with aircon on and 42-44 with aircon off
Thanks for the info - that's better mpg than I thought was possible for the 3.0L.

Cost Captain

3,920 posts

211 months

Monday 26th July 2010
quotequote all
I have an a3 3 door and personally I find the boot is enough for an average amount of stuff but becomes a bit tight when going on a trip, I find I can realistically fit 3 peoples luggage for a weekend away, not sure this would compare to a 5 door though.

If your looking to spend around £17k you're well within budget for an a4 avant which obviously be far more spacious, depends what you want it for though!

andy97

4,784 posts

253 months

Monday 26th July 2010
quotequote all
I have an 04 A4 quattro Avant 1.9 TDi (130) & really recommend it. Its used for my daily commute (c70miles each way, 75% motorway,25% urban crawl) and the trip computer reports 40-47 mpg, depending on how I'm driving it!

Caractacus

Original Poster:

2,622 posts

256 months

Monday 26th July 2010
quotequote all
Thanks for the info guys.

I'm looking at A3 5 door quattros and A4 Quattro Avants this Friday smile

S2AVANT

217 posts

253 months

Monday 26th July 2010
quotequote all
A3 = Haldex
A4 = Quattro
Don't get them mixed up.

Caractacus

Original Poster:

2,622 posts

256 months

Monday 26th July 2010
quotequote all
S2AVANT said:
A3 = Haldex
A4 = Quattro
Don't get them mixed up.
Sorry - not familiar with the difference. Is Haldex like the 4Motion system whereby the rear diff only comes into play when the front slips?

S2AVANT

217 posts

253 months

Monday 26th July 2010
quotequote all
Caractacus said:
S2AVANT said:
A3 = Haldex
A4 = Quattro
Don't get them mixed up.
Sorry - not familiar with the difference. Is Haldex like the 4Motion system whereby the rear diff only comes into play when the front slips?
Yes, it would seem you do get it - If you are buying a Quattro, make sure you get one.

sleep envy

62,260 posts

280 months

Monday 26th July 2010
quotequote all
Make sure you try both the sport and s-line spec a3

as a daily driver I preferred the sport, especially having to do big miles either end of the day

MintyChris

848 posts

223 months

Tuesday 27th July 2010
quotequote all
S2AVANT said:
Caractacus said:
S2AVANT said:
A3 = Haldex
A4 = Quattro
Don't get them mixed up.
Sorry - not familiar with the difference. Is Haldex like the 4Motion system whereby the rear diff only comes into play when the front slips?
Yes, it would seem you do get it - If you are buying a Quattro, make sure you get one.
lol. For what hes after its not really going to make a difference whether the car uses a mechanical diff or an electronic one. Both awd and both do fine in slipery conditions.

I'd prefer the A4 avant though.

UVB

557 posts

224 months

Tuesday 27th July 2010
quotequote all
I'd go A4 over A3 for this too. However your budget should stretch to an A6 as well which I'm finding much better than the A4 - especially if you're doing big miles.

Best advice would be to go find one of each to take for a decent drive and see what you think.

FamilyDub

3,587 posts

196 months

Tuesday 27th July 2010
quotequote all
^^^ I second that UVB!

If you get an A4, just make sure you don't get the athsmatic 1.9 TDI.

We ran an A3 sportback and in reality, it's probably no bigger than a standard hatch's boot. A4 (or bigger) would be better if space is at a premium.

andy97

4,784 posts

253 months

Tuesday 27th July 2010
quotequote all
[quote=FamilyDub
If you get an A4, just make sure you don't get the athsmatic 1.9 TDI.
[/quote]

Must admit I don't find my 1.9 TDi (130) asthmatic at all. I'm fairly sure that it can be chipped to about 170 too.

The 1.9TDi (115) I had in my last A4 was Ok also. OK, they are not sports car engnes but in everyday driving they are fine & brisk enough fpr the real world.

Stuart J

1,301 posts

288 months

Tuesday 27th July 2010
quotequote all
Weve just bought a Skoda Octavia Scout, cracking car, great when driven enthusiastically & within your budget if you shop around brand new. Get a price off drive the deal & then find a dealer to match it. Our 4th Skoda & bomb proof, Just an Audi without the silly price after all

Caractacus

Original Poster:

2,622 posts

256 months

Tuesday 27th July 2010
quotequote all
FamilyDub said:
^^^ I second that UVB!

If you get an A4, just make sure you don't get the athsmatic 1.9 TDI.

We ran an A3 sportback and in reality, it's probably no bigger than a standard hatch's boot. A4 (or bigger) would be better if space is at a premium.
We are looking at the 170bhp Tdi - should be fine for nipping about the countryside I reckon.

fatboy b

9,666 posts

247 months

Tuesday 27th July 2010
quotequote all
Caractacus said:
blueg33 said:
Caractacus said:
Hi all,

I'm going to be driving about 25000 miles per annum through the bottom two thirds of Wales each year. A lot of these will be on B roads.

I've decided upon a Quattro due to the added safety when encountering mud, slurry and gravel...darn farmers! smile

The dilemma comes from which to buy - an A3 Quattro 5 door 170 S Line (or Sport) or an A4 Quattro 170 Avant. Is there much between these two apart from boot space?

MPG is up there on the list of priorities, but I still find myself looking at the A4 3.0L Quattro Avant. The spec says up to 36MPG - Is this wishful thinking? My goal is 40mpg average.

This will be a 2nd hand purchase and the budget is circa £17K.

What are your thoughts?

Cheers,

C.
I have an A6 3.0tdi Tiptronic Quattro. Trip computer currently shows the average at 36.1 mpg. I do 60% on motorways. At 75 on mway the mpg is 40-41 with aircon on and 42-44 with aircon off
Thanks for the info - that's better mpg than I thought was possible for the 3.0L.
A5 3.0 is also good. Mine's showing 39.2 overall, but 45+ to and from work & 44 on fast motorway journeys. Bloody fantastic engine if you can stretch to one.


Edited by fatboy b on Tuesday 27th July 21:01

Caractacus

Original Poster:

2,622 posts

256 months

Tuesday 27th July 2010
quotequote all
fatboy b said:
Caractacus said:
blueg33 said:
Caractacus said:
Hi all,

I'm going to be driving about 25000 miles per annum through the bottom two thirds of Wales each year. A lot of these will be on B roads.

I've decided upon a Quattro due to the added safety when encountering mud, slurry and gravel...darn farmers! smile

The dilemma comes from which to buy - an A3 Quattro 5 door 170 S Line (or Sport) or an A4 Quattro 170 Avant. Is there much between these two apart from boot space?

MPG is up there on the list of priorities, but I still find myself looking at the A4 3.0L Quattro Avant. The spec says up to 36MPG - Is this wishful thinking? My goal is 40mpg average.

This will be a 2nd hand purchase and the budget is circa £17K.

What are your thoughts?

Cheers,

C.
I have an A6 3.0tdi Tiptronic Quattro. Trip computer currently shows the average at 36.1 mpg. I do 60% on motorways. At 75 on mway the mpg is 40-41 with aircon on and 42-44 with aircon off
Thanks for the info - that's better mpg than I thought was possible for the 3.0L.
A5 3.0 gets even better. Mine's showing 39.2. Bloody fantastic engine if you can stretch to one.
I need five doors so an Avant it has to be. smile

heightswitch

6,322 posts

281 months

Wednesday 28th July 2010
quotequote all
Caractacus said:
fatboy b said:
Caractacus said:
blueg33 said:
Caractacus said:
Hi all,

I'm going to be driving about 25000 miles per annum through the bottom two thirds of Wales each year. A lot of these will be on B roads.

I've decided upon a Quattro due to the added safety when encountering mud, slurry and gravel...darn farmers! smile

The dilemma comes from which to buy - an A3 Quattro 5 door 170 S Line (or Sport) or an A4 Quattro 170 Avant. Is there much between these two apart from boot space?

MPG is up there on the list of priorities, but I still find myself looking at the A4 3.0L Quattro Avant. The spec says up to 36MPG - Is this wishful thinking? My goal is 40mpg average.

This will be a 2nd hand purchase and the budget is circa £17K.

What are your thoughts?

Cheers,

C.
I have an A6 3.0tdi Tiptronic Quattro. Trip computer currently shows the average at 36.1 mpg. I do 60% on motorways. At 75 on mway the mpg is 40-41 with aircon on and 42-44 with aircon off
Thanks for the info - that's better mpg than I thought was possible for the 3.0L.
A5 3.0 gets even better. Mine's showing 39.2. Bloody fantastic engine if you can stretch to one.
I need five doors so an Avant it has to be. smile
I am this weekend trading an A3 quattro Sport and moving back to an A4 but this time a 2.0T FSi Quattro.

The A4 is a much more refined, quieter, less harsh and more liveable package than the A3. on paper you would think them very similar but they are leagues apart in terms of comfort and fit / finish

N.