Inaccurate speedo
Inaccurate speedo
Author
Discussion

finestjammy

Original Poster:

741 posts

204 months

Sunday 1st August 2010
quotequote all
My speedo reads about 10mph over the actual speed at anything above 30mph. Whilst this doesn't bother me too much it concerns me that the odometer might be recording more miles than I've actually done. Is this the case or does the odo measure miles in some other way?

Cider Andy

1,889 posts

256 months

Sunday 1st August 2010
quotequote all
No, they're both driven by the same input. But that's not to say the speedo doesn't have an internal fault that's causing the indicated speed reading to be wrong whilst still recording the correct mileage covered. I'd take it over a measured distance to see what it's recording.

Comadis

1,731 posts

254 months

Sunday 1st August 2010
quotequote all
your question needs to be replied with a counter question:

do you run your Chim with original wheel and tyre size?

SILICONE KID

14,997 posts

262 months

Sunday 1st August 2010
quotequote all
These guys can Recalabrate your speedo


http://www.speedograph-richfield.com/


Edited by SILICONE KID on Sunday 1st August 23:10

finestjammy

Original Poster:

741 posts

204 months

Sunday 1st August 2010
quotequote all
Comadis said:
your question needs to be replied with a counter question:

do you run your Chim with original wheel and tyre size?
Thanks. It's a 93 4.0, 15 inch 50 profile on the front and 16 inch 45 profile on the rear. Not sure how that compares to standard without looking at the handbook though.

Red V8

873 posts

258 months

Monday 2nd August 2010
quotequote all
They all do that sir... or its a very common fault anyway... many people have tried to recalibrate but with mixed results.

Two benefits though

1. keeps you the right side of the law
2. improves your 0-60 time


Cider Andy

1,889 posts

256 months

Monday 2nd August 2010
quotequote all
Red V8 said:
They all do that sir... or its a very common fault anyway...
They don't all do it! If sat nav's owt to go by, I've never had a car with a more accurate speedo.

Comadis

1,731 posts

254 months

Monday 2nd August 2010
quotequote all
"It's a 93 4.0, 15 inch 50 profile on the front and 16 inch 45 profile on the rear."

these dimensions are useless without the width!!


pleae also post the TVR spec tyre size!!

225/50ZR15 (front) und 245/45ZR16 (rear) , according to my database from around 1996 onwards, cars with power steering

Edited by Comadis on Monday 2nd August 12:59

Red V8

873 posts

258 months

Monday 2nd August 2010
quotequote all
Cider Andy said:
Red V8 said:
They all do that sir... or its a very common fault anyway...
They don't all do it! If sat nav's owt to go by, I've never had a car with a more accurate speedo.
All, bar one then ... smile

finestjammy

Original Poster:

741 posts

204 months

Monday 2nd August 2010
quotequote all
Apologies, yes they are 225/50/15's and 245/45/16's. They are the estorils so are not original fitment, I promise to check the handbook when I can access it.

SMB

1,523 posts

297 months

Monday 2nd August 2010
quotequote all
finestjammy said:
Apologies, yes they are 225/50/15's and 245/45/16's. They are the estorils so are not original fitment, I promise to check the handbook when I can access it.
Originals for that car would have been 205/60/15 and 225/55/16. The rears count for the speedo, you have decreased the rolling radius by 4-5%. that makes the inherent speedo error worse.

jhfozzy

1,345 posts

221 months

Monday 2nd August 2010
quotequote all
Red V8 said:
They all do that sir... or its a very common fault anyway... many people have tried to recalibrate but with mixed results.

Two benefits though

1. keeps you the right side of the law
2. improves your 0-60 time
Nope, he's the wrong side of the law.

Contruction and use allows a 10% over-read and 0% under-read. If he's "about 10mph over the actual speed at anything above 30mph." then he's over-reading by between about 33% (at 30mph) and 10% (at 100mph) which is outside the C&U tolerances.

Speedos from the factory are built with an inbuilt over-read so you cannot (in normal use) have a speedo that under-reads. But, as said, he's got smaller tyres on which will make the speedo over-read even more.


Red V8

873 posts

258 months

Monday 2nd August 2010
quotequote all
jhfozzy said:
Red V8 said:
They all do that sir... or its a very common fault anyway... many people have tried to recalibrate but with mixed results.

Two benefits though

1. keeps you the right side of the law
2. improves your 0-60 time
Nope, he's the wrong side of the law.

Contruction and use allows a 10% over-read and 0% under-read. If he's "about 10mph over the actual speed at anything above 30mph." then he's over-reading by between about 33% (at 30mph) and 10% (at 100mph) which is outside the C&U tolerances.

Speedos from the factory are built with an inbuilt over-read so you cannot (in normal use) have a speedo that under-reads. But, as said, he's got smaller tyres on which will make the speedo over-read even more.
Maybe some confusion over the meanings here... I assume over read it as showing 70 on the speedo when he was actually doing 60, and hence he was worried about it showing a higher mileage on the odometer... so this keeps you the right side of the law...

finestjammy

Original Poster:

741 posts

204 months

Monday 2nd August 2010
quotequote all
Correct. The speedo pretty consistently over reads at 40, 50, 60 and 70mph. The amount of over read seems to be 10mph throughout the normal road speeds, according to my sat nav.

Ubernoober

534 posts

241 months

Monday 2nd August 2010
quotequote all
Ok, as I understand it, with your 10mph-over-the-real-speed speedo you are most unlikely to be pulled by the BiB for speeding - so, yes, right side of the law.

However..... Construction and Use regs only permit for a 10% over read (0% under-read) so, at 10 mph over, your speedo does not align with these regs and so, I believe, would be an MoT fail.

And talking of speed limits, the speed limit is the speed limit is the law, if you go over it, you are breaking the law - any talk of a 10% allowance' + xmph is entirely at the discretion of the Force in question. It is not a 'right'. You can be 'done' for doing 31mph!

finestjammy

Original Poster:

741 posts

204 months

Monday 2nd August 2010
quotequote all
It passed the MOT a couple of weeks ago with the same wheels and tyres it has now, so not sure exactly what the testers look for. So I'm guessing the options for correcting the problem is either changing the tyres or getting the speedo recalibrated.

dmjw01

4,473 posts

196 months

Tuesday 3rd August 2010
quotequote all
The speedometer is not checked in any way during an MOT test. It could be reading anything at all, or just showing zero all the time, and your car wouldn't fail for that.

You'd be amazed what doesn't get checked!

Edited by dmjw01 on Tuesday 3rd August 06:57

jhfozzy

1,345 posts

221 months

Tuesday 3rd August 2010
quotequote all
Red V8 said:
jhfozzy said:
Red V8 said:
They all do that sir... or its a very common fault anyway... many people have tried to recalibrate but with mixed results.

Two benefits though

1. keeps you the right side of the law
2. improves your 0-60 time
Nope, he's the wrong side of the law.

Contruction and use allows a 10% over-read and 0% under-read. If he's "about 10mph over the actual speed at anything above 30mph." then he's over-reading by between about 33% (at 30mph) and 10% (at 100mph) which is outside the C&U tolerances.

Speedos from the factory are built with an inbuilt over-read so you cannot (in normal use) have a speedo that under-reads. But, as said, he's got smaller tyres on which will make the speedo over-read even more.
Maybe some confusion over the meanings here... I assume over read it as showing 70 on the speedo when he was actually doing 60, and hence he was worried about it showing a higher mileage on the odometer... so this keeps you the right side of the law...
No, just confusion over the amounts, he said it was over-reading over the whole range by about 10mph. At 30mph, this is a 33% over-read, at 40, this is a 25% over-read etc. This is outside the tolerance of 10% over-read allowed by C&U.

As mentioned above, the speedo is not an MOT'able item, you don't even need one to pass an MOT as my brothers kit car proves (he uses his tomtom out and about), we asked the tester and he said the speedo wasn't on the list of checked items, BUT, you need one working and within tolerances for C&U purposes.

finestjammy

Original Poster:

741 posts

204 months

Wednesday 4th August 2010
quotequote all
To clarify, at an actual 30mph it reads about 34mph on the speedo. It's from speeds over this that there seems to be a consistent 10mph over read.

jhfozzy

1,345 posts

221 months

Wednesday 4th August 2010
quotequote all
finestjammy said:
To clarify, at an actual 30mph it reads about 34mph on the speedo. It's from speeds over this that there seems to be a consistent 10mph over read.
13% over-reading then, still over the 10% limit. But it's immaterial now as you know what's causing it. Say for example you've done 40,000 actual miles in the car since you changed the tyre size, if you went everywhere at 30 (13% error), your odometer will have recorded 45,200 miles, adding an "extra" 5,200 miles onto the cars history. At the other end of the scale, your top speeds will look a lot better and you'll be "safer" going through "safety" cameras.

At the end of the day, it's up to you as you'd have to be very, very unlucky to be caught out for this.