S4 or S6
Author
Discussion

Pvapour

Original Poster:

8,981 posts

284 months

Wednesday 4th August 2010
quotequote all
looking at both guises as space is not that important, S6 is aluminum so weight differences are not that great & corrosion would be better in long term.

Been out in the S4 today and it seemed quite small and nimble, not driven the S6 yet.....

what other advantages / disadvantages can you see between the two?

istoo

2,365 posts

233 months

Wednesday 4th August 2010
quotequote all
hmmm i thought it was justy the S8 which was aluminium. DrG?

heightswitch

6,322 posts

281 months

Wednesday 4th August 2010
quotequote all
Pvapour said:
looking at both guises as space is not that important, S6 is aluminum so weight differences are not that great & corrosion would be better in long term.

Been out in the S4 today and it seemed quite small and nimble, not driven the S6 yet.....

what other advantages / disadvantages can you see between the two?
Aluminium corrodes? especially when you get it close to steel!!

Pvapour

Original Poster:

8,981 posts

284 months

Thursday 5th August 2010
quotequote all
seems just bonnet and wings are ally and not chassis as i was told scratchchin

Dr G

16,007 posts

273 months

Thursday 5th August 2010
quotequote all
istoo said:
hmmm i thought it was justy the S8 which was aluminium. DrG?
A8 is almost all ally, most of the rest of the range use bits and pieces.

Pvapour

Original Poster:

8,981 posts

284 months

Friday 6th August 2010
quotequote all
plumped for S4 in the end.

not homologated for towing apparently, but, would a std A4 retractable still fit? or would there be chassis / exhaust differences to hinder?

Pvapour

Original Poster:

8,981 posts

284 months

Saturday 7th August 2010
quotequote all
as an update, std retractable a4 tow bar fits with just a small unseen cutout.

HTH

drybeer

962 posts

256 months

Sunday 8th August 2010
quotequote all
Pvapour said:
looking at both guises as space is not that important, S6 is aluminum so weight differences are not that great & corrosion would be better in long term.

Been out in the S4 today and it seemed quite small and nimble, not driven the S6 yet.....

what other advantages / disadvantages can you see between the two?
S6 was only available as tiptronic auto in the UK.

S4 you could get as manual, and frankly there are more of them about in the UK compared to S6s.

The S4 feels the tighter package between the two, but if you're looking at an Avant because you need space then the S4 is likely too small for you.

The S6 was only aluminium from the bulkhead forward, like all roads and the RS6. Speaking of which this is another car to consider so long as you can stomach the higher running costs. Economy not much different, just the S6 doesn't have DRC or the same appetite for gearboxes hence is a bit of a sleeper in this company, if you can find a nice one.

Pvapour

Original Poster:

8,981 posts

284 months

Monday 16th August 2010
quotequote all
went the S4 route in the end as interior space was not as important plus the drive was (as you said) much tighter, it'll be a better drive on the twisties and it wont eat parts as quickly (bit ironic considering its first failure 300 miles down the road rolleyes) hey ho....

just did a 600 mile journey in it towing some big weight and it was incredibly smooth, not a quick car but lovely to drive and relaxing, MPG was 15 towing the trailer at 70 which may sound bad but is still twice the MPG of the SRT10 hehe

drybeer

962 posts

256 months

Monday 16th August 2010
quotequote all
Glad you like.

Neil.D

2,878 posts

237 months

Tuesday 17th August 2010
quotequote all
Let us know if the S4 lives up to expectations.
I'm looking at one to replace my M5 in the near future.



You got the B6 right?

Pvapour

Original Poster:

8,981 posts

284 months

Wednesday 18th August 2010
quotequote all
yep, it's weird you mention your car as it started me thinking about the one I used to own as a comparison.

It is in fact very similar in many ways but like a smaller estate version, brakes are better, feels lighter and more agile than the M5 and feels about the same kick in the back from the power (not much smile) but has a nice build to the top of the rev range just like the M5.

Steering is heavier and not so much feel (guessing the quattro system is responsible for this) manual box is precise but a bit notchy very much like the one I had, nice noise, same firm ride as M5 but just right on motorways.

Early days but I quite like it, it was bought as I work horse really so the Avant guise helps its case for me, through practicality.

As a saloon it would be a little disappointing as I'd want more of an occasion from the interior and more exhilaration from the power.

HTH

drybeer

962 posts

256 months

Friday 20th August 2010
quotequote all
It's amazing how we become USED to power. Remember when Top Gear tested the B6 S4 it was faster around the track than a contemporary M3, yet people tell us the M3 is more thrilling...

Admittedly there are much faster cars out there, but I think the S4 V8 is just very refined and therefore it disguises the speed well.

Pvapour

Original Poster:

8,981 posts

284 months

Friday 20th August 2010
quotequote all
think your right, but then I'm not saying it IS slow, it just feels it.

I have followed it in our SL55 and the TVR and been quite surprised how hard you need to push to keep up, the e39 M5 was the same for me, never felt quick but everything following just used to disappear when you nailed it.

I have a Lancia Integrale EvoII it only has 215bhp but it feels silly quick when the turbos kick in (its not) in a straight line you wouldn't even know it was flat out if you were in the SL55.

My preference is the Lancias way of applying itself, grin at slow speeds.

Dracoro

9,038 posts

276 months

Friday 20th August 2010
quotequote all
drybeer said:
It's amazing how we become USED to power. Remember when Top Gear tested the B6 S4 it was faster around the track than a contemporary M3, yet people tell us the M3 is more thrilling...
Odd statement. Maybe because it IS more thrilling. "Thrilling" isn't soley measured by performance figures.

jith

2,752 posts

246 months

Friday 20th August 2010
quotequote all
drybeer said:
It's amazing how we become USED to power. Remember when Top Gear tested the B6 S4 it was faster around the track than a contemporary M3, yet people tell us the M3 is more thrilling...

Admittedly there are much faster cars out there, but I think the S4 V8 is just very refined and therefore it disguises the speed well.
Very pertinent points drybeer, but another issue that most miss, and especially the testers who always pick nice sunny days for their tests, is that of the British weather, particularly in Bonny Scotland. There isn't a BMW made that can come anywhere near the Audis on a soaking wet day over the Rannoch Moor. Or better still, the type of winter we just had.

The Quattros are built for it.

Pvapour

Original Poster:

8,981 posts

284 months

Friday 20th August 2010
quotequote all
jith said:
drybeer said:
It's amazing how we become USED to power. Remember when Top Gear tested the B6 S4 it was faster around the track than a contemporary M3, yet people tell us the M3 is more thrilling...

Admittedly there are much faster cars out there, but I think the S4 V8 is just very refined and therefore it disguises the speed well.
Very pertinent points drybeer, but another issue that most miss, and especially the testers who always pick nice sunny days for their tests, is that of the British weather, particularly in Bonny Scotland. There isn't a BMW made that can come anywhere near the Audis on a soaking wet day over the Rannoch Moor. Or better still, the type of winter we just had.

The Quattros are built for it.
not had a chance in the wet yet, but pretty sure i'd want to be in the Audi for quick progress with a loved one, TVR for more fun though wink be interesting to see the Lancia against it in the wet scratchchin

drybeer

962 posts

256 months

Friday 20th August 2010
quotequote all
jith said:
drybeer said:
It's amazing how we become USED to power. Remember when Top Gear tested the B6 S4 it was faster around the track than a contemporary M3, yet people tell us the M3 is more thrilling...

Admittedly there are much faster cars out there, but I think the S4 V8 is just very refined and therefore it disguises the speed well.
Very pertinent points drybeer, but another issue that most miss, and especially the testers who always pick nice sunny days for their tests, is that of the British weather, particularly in Bonny Scotland. There isn't a BMW made that can come anywhere near the Audis on a soaking wet day over the Rannoch Moor. Or better still, the type of winter we just had.

The Quattros are built for it.
Totally agree.

Sorry for thread hijacking PVapour!

I have an RS6 now and recently took an M5 V10 as a p/ex from a customer. This supposedly much more thrilling car would not have seen which way my car went on most UK roads. Quattro (or 4x4 at least) holds the road car advantage.

As for the M(x) being actually more thrilling - not many folk want that "thrill" of sphincter twitching with the family in the car on the road. I for one have no time for track days, 100% of my driving is on the road, and I'm still satisfied by the Top Gear test.

Edited by drybeer on Friday 20th August 23:25

Jim S

3 posts

269 months

Saturday 28th August 2010
quotequote all
Pvapour said:
plumped for S4 in the end.

not homologated for towing apparently, but, would a std A4 retractable still fit? or would there be chassis / exhaust differences to hinder?
You are correct in the fact the B6/B7 have never been type approved for towing but although you can fit a towbar from another A4 model I'm afraid to say you won't be insured and if the police check your car they will no doubt take great delight in charging you.

If they could tow I would have had one on my drive last summer but I'm just going to keep my S2 till I can gather the money for a B8 S4 Avant.

Jim

Edited by Jim S on Saturday 28th August 07:07

Pvapour

Original Poster:

8,981 posts

284 months

Saturday 28th August 2010
quotequote all
put car on French plates, fitted a std retractable, declared to axa France and they insured it no probs, job done

always a way smile