Stalling
Author
Discussion

CarlosV8

Original Poster:

818 posts

203 months

Monday 9th August 2010
quotequote all
Morning all

I'm finally getting all the little jobs done on my 1996 Chim and at the weekend I planned to fit a new Steve Heath speedo sensor to fix the speedo. I first fitted his diagnostic box and when tested the speedo wouldnt work. Slightly annoyed I decided not to fit the new sensor as clearly it was the speedo head at fault, despite the previous owner sending it away to get fixed.

I then took the car out for a little drive and low and behold the speedo suddenly works perfectly. I assume there must have been a dodgy connection behind the dash.

I was feeling quite smug until a new problem presented itself. Now when you pull up to a junction and put your foot on the clutch the car stalls. It's never done this before, even when the speedo occasionaly worked. By making the speedo work could i have dislodged the ECU connection? Where abouts does the feed for this come from - i assume the speed sensor feed splits somewhere.

I'm gonna clean the stepper motor just in case it's a completely unrelated issue. But any advuce wouldbe useful as i'm going on a 1000 mile roadtrip on Friday so dont want the car stalling all the time!

In case it matters i have the BTR diff with the toothed wheel on the prop. The current sensor is still pretty new, but i will probably still change it for the Steve Heath version when i get chance.

Cheers
Carl

Chimpaholic

9,637 posts

210 months

Monday 9th August 2010
quotequote all
CarlosV8 said:
Morning all

I'm finally getting all the little jobs done on my 1996 Chim and at the weekend I planned to fit a new Steve Heath speedo sensor to fix the speedo. I first fitted his diagnostic box and when tested the speedo wouldnt work. Slightly annoyed I decided not to fit the new sensor as clearly it was the speedo head at fault, despite the previous owner sending it away to get fixed.

I then took the car out for a little drive and low and behold the speedo suddenly works perfectly. I assume there must have been a dodgy connection behind the dash.

I was feeling quite smug until a new problem presented itself. Now when you pull up to a junction and put your foot on the clutch the car stalls. It's never done this before, even when the speedo occasionaly worked. By making the speedo work could i have dislodged the ECU connection? Where abouts does the feed for this come from - i assume the speed sensor feed splits somewhere.

I'm gonna clean the stepper motor just in case it's a completely unrelated issue. But any advuce wouldbe useful as i'm going on a 1000 mile roadtrip on Friday so dont want the car stalling all the time!

In case it matters i have the BTR diff with the toothed wheel on the prop. The current sensor is still pretty new, but i will probably still change it for the Steve Heath version when i get chance.

Cheers
Carl
Hi Carl, I had the same problem and just disconnecting the speedo and re-connecting it solved the stalling problem.

Worth a try?

simonej

5,513 posts

211 months

Monday 9th August 2010
quotequote all
I had the same problem after fitting one of the SH speedo sensors. I tried all sorts of things to stop it stalling but nothing worked. In the end I stumped up for a standard one and it's been fine ever since.

My advice would be to remove the tester box and fit a standard sensor as it will save a lot of headaches.

MikeTVR

167 posts

314 months

Monday 9th August 2010
quotequote all
There is a module behind the dash that takes in the signal from the speedo sensor and modifies the pulse rate to the ECU. This module can erroneously output a pulse train even when the car is stationary due to electrical noise from the car electrics. The idle mechanism on the ECU sets the idle speed ONLY when the car appears to be stationary. Hence if the module is continuously pulsing the idle speeed does not auto set itself. Electronics knowledge is helpful in fixing this but a good starting point is checking and improving earthing connections.
Mike

CarlosV8

Original Poster:

818 posts

203 months

Monday 9th August 2010
quotequote all
The sensor is still the standard version. The SH diagnostic box is still connected, but I can't see how this would cause any problems.

Today I've cleaned the stepper motor (it was a bit gunked up), but all seems to work ok. Also reset the ECU as thought it couldn't do any harm.

Not had a chance to test drive the car but from Mike says I guess I maybe chasing an electrical fault, which unfortunately isn't going to happen before going away. Guess I better learn how to left foot brake wink

shpub

8,507 posts

303 months

Tuesday 10th August 2010
quotequote all
The first thing to say is that I always encourage customers to 'get in touch' if they have any questions whatsoever about fitting any of my products. If I offer suggestions and advice on things to check then hear nothing back I naturally assume the problem has been resolved.

The standard sensor is not designed to work with the tester/interface. The fact that it appears to is a bit of serendipity but it was never intended to. I suspect that it doesn't work at slow speeds and that as a result you may get some interesting effects as the ECU tries to adjust the idle because it thinks the car is stationary.

One of those interesting effects is stalling as the ECU tries to reduce the speed so that when you lift off, it has over compensated and the engine stalls.

This can be made worse if the base idle is not set up correctly as many cars have base idle which is wildly out of spec and the ECU/stepper motor spends most of its adjustment range compensating for this rather than fine tuning of the idle.

I would suggest fitting the SH sensor, resetting the ECU by unplugging it for 30 seconds and then see how it goes.

If you still have problems... please get back to me.

I don't bite.

Edited by shpub on Tuesday 10th August 09:41

spend

12,581 posts

282 months

Tuesday 10th August 2010
quotequote all
What gearbox do you have?

Does your sensor fit the on the crown type toothed trigger on the nose of the diff Steve?

Seems unusual to have the prop shaft sensor on the BTR diff, but there where some funny cross-over setups, hence why I ask about the box - if LT77 ecu will probably be taking speed sense from the box.

shpub

8,507 posts

303 months

Tuesday 10th August 2010
quotequote all
Yes it will fit on the crown wheel type.

CarlosV8

Original Poster:

818 posts

203 months

Tuesday 10th August 2010
quotequote all
I'd planned to fit your sensor anyway Steve, but the speedo playing silly buggers threw me a bit. When it suddenly started working i decided to leave it alone as at least the speedo was working for my trip away. Then this stalling issue started and has thrown a spanner in the works.

I'll take the car out for another test to see if the problem persists, if it does i'll remove the diagnostic box and save the fitting for another day.

I've got no problems with your sensor, it's an excellent kit. I'm just trying to work out the little quirks my car seems to have!

CarlosV8

Original Poster:

818 posts

203 months

Tuesday 10th August 2010
quotequote all
Oh, and its the T5 box. Bit of an oddity, but as you say it was on the cross over period so a mix of old and new parts