A6 Gearbox Electrics
Discussion
Mate has a petrol 2005 A6 Estate Auto and the gearbox is really playing up. Sometimes when he selects reverse the car will not move and indicates that it is still in park even though the lever has moved. It also intermittently jumps into the next gear rather than smoothly changes.
He took it to an Audi dealer here in Germany who quoted him over a €1,000 to sort out the gearbox management system. When he was back in UK last week an Audi dealer there quoted him over £5,000 and that it should be done here and now even though he had just completed nearly 1,500 miles driving that week. He then took it to a roadside garage who said they were unable to help and it would need to go to an official Audi garage.
So my questions are these: should and independent garage be able to do the work? Is the UK Audi garage trying to rip him off? and finally does the thousand+ Euro seem about right for the repair? Any help gratefully received.
Sorry for the edit but after reading back the thread it really seems pretty obvious that the UK garage are taking the piss.
He took it to an Audi dealer here in Germany who quoted him over a €1,000 to sort out the gearbox management system. When he was back in UK last week an Audi dealer there quoted him over £5,000 and that it should be done here and now even though he had just completed nearly 1,500 miles driving that week. He then took it to a roadside garage who said they were unable to help and it would need to go to an official Audi garage.
So my questions are these: should and independent garage be able to do the work? Is the UK Audi garage trying to rip him off? and finally does the thousand+ Euro seem about right for the repair? Any help gratefully received.
Sorry for the edit but after reading back the thread it really seems pretty obvious that the UK garage are taking the piss.
Edited by tony wright on Tuesday 10th August 12:10
It is almost certainly the gearbox controller as ze germans have said. See this thread... http://www.pistonheads.com/gassing/topic.asp?h=0&a...
£5k is for a new gearbox, £1000-£1500 is for a new gearbox ecu.
Depending on how the car is, it can be very difficult for any garage (including the main Audi centres) to identify if its just the ECU or the entire gearbox that needs replacing.
How pleased would you be, if they said, it will be £1500, and then it turned out to need a box at £5k. You'd be well pissed and expect them to pay for the box as they misdiagnosed it.
So sometime they are a bit over keen to fail the box, as it comes will a new ECU in it, it will definatly fix the fault.
We always take a sample of oil when testing multi tronic box's and have been told if there is metal in it, it needs a box. But as upwards of 80,000 miles, there is sometimes a bit of metal in it even though the box os actually ok this can lead to box's being condemmed even though they might be ok.
Depending on how the car is, it can be very difficult for any garage (including the main Audi centres) to identify if its just the ECU or the entire gearbox that needs replacing.
How pleased would you be, if they said, it will be £1500, and then it turned out to need a box at £5k. You'd be well pissed and expect them to pay for the box as they misdiagnosed it.
So sometime they are a bit over keen to fail the box, as it comes will a new ECU in it, it will definatly fix the fault.
We always take a sample of oil when testing multi tronic box's and have been told if there is metal in it, it needs a box. But as upwards of 80,000 miles, there is sometimes a bit of metal in it even though the box os actually ok this can lead to box's being condemmed even though they might be ok.
Gassing Station | Audi, Seat, Skoda & VW | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


