Which Octavia VRS - Petrol or Diesel?
Which Octavia VRS - Petrol or Diesel?
Author
Discussion

Woody

Original Poster:

2,189 posts

315 months

Tuesday 10th August 2010
quotequote all
Guys,
Looks like I've decided to get an Octavia VRS when I lose my company car at the end of the year.
Thing is I'm not sure whether to go for the petrol or diesel.
I currently have a MK5 Golf GT Sport TDI with the 170bhp engine, which I quite like.
But with the Octavia being a bigger car can't help thinking I should go for the more powerful petrol version.
The car will probably have to be about 3 years old when I get it.
Has to be an Octavia as will need a bigger car than my Golf as Woody Junior is due in November biggrin and need the extra boot space for kiddy stuff and my dive kit.

Any pros/cons of either the above anyone can come up with?

Also what's the 'drop-in' tuning chips like for both?

Also any thoughts on either the hatch or estate?

Cheers

Chris

blank

3,767 posts

219 months

Tuesday 10th August 2010
quotequote all
Petrol. clap


There's a company called Shark Performance who are very highly thought of for remaps and general VAG stuff. Petrol or diesel.


If you're happy going for an estate then go with that. The hatch has an annoying trait where you can end up tipping a load of water in the boot if you open it when it's really wet!!

Edited by blank on Tuesday 10th August 20:57

MrLou

879 posts

252 months

Tuesday 10th August 2010
quotequote all
Well, I'll cast a vote for the oil-burner.

Depending on how many miles you do, you might find that it's more cost-effective to buy a petrol one, but anything north of 15k a year and the diesel will probably be a better bet.

In real world driving I doubt you'll see the difference in performance but the extra 10/15 MPG won't hurt and it's at least 1 tax band lower too.

As an extra bonus, if you get an estate in blue or silver and drive it on the motorway in Hampshire you'll have the traffic melting out of your way as you'll look like an unmarked traffic car smile


Woody

Original Poster:

2,189 posts

315 months

Tuesday 10th August 2010
quotequote all
Thanks guys - hoping to test drive both in the very near future.
Fancy a bit of a change from diesel but love the torque, what's the petrol like? Not driven a petrol turbo before?

Chris

blank

3,767 posts

219 months

Tuesday 10th August 2010
quotequote all
The petrol is a pretty torquey engine. It really depends if you do the mileage to justify the diesel.

Woody

Original Poster:

2,189 posts

315 months

Wednesday 11th August 2010
quotequote all
At the moment not doing the 15k a year, and can't really see it going up much either.

As I'm going to be spending my own money I want something that'll be fun to drive.

Guess I ned to drive both and see how they compare.

Oh year might also take a trip to the 'Ring in it - anyone had one round there???

matchmaker

9,091 posts

231 months

Wednesday 11th August 2010
quotequote all
blank said:
The petrol is a pretty torquey engine. It really depends if you do the mileage to justify the diesel.
The petrol is also a lot easier to tune biggrinbiggrin

MonkeyHanger

9,267 posts

273 months

Wednesday 11th August 2010
quotequote all
Woody said:
At the moment not doing the 15k a year, and can't really see it going up much either.

As I'm going to be spending my own money I want something that'll be fun to drive.
In that case you need to try them both.


Then buy the Petrol biggrin

nottyash

4,671 posts

226 months

Thursday 19th August 2010
quotequote all
matchmaker said:
blank said:
The petrol is a pretty torquey engine. It really depends if you do the mileage to justify the diesel.
The petrol is also a lot easier to tune biggrinbiggrin
I nearly bought a new Diesel one but was told it has anti mapping software so cant be remapped. The earlier 2006-2008 models can get over 200bhp though.

2woody

919 posts

241 months

Friday 20th August 2010
quotequote all
a-ha - so you're the reason that I had to choose "2woody" as my forum name.

it's not so long since I had an Octavia vRS, too. Had a petrol with a 240BHP remap and to be fair, it was really too fast for most road conditions. the standard 180BHP version would have been better - still the missus bought it and she insisted on the extra horsepower.

our car was in really good condition considering the well over 100K mileage, I gave it a front suspension rebuild and discs, etc., but in reality it had lasted very well. so consider that a recommendation for the Octavia vRS as a whole.

I wouldn't recommend a diesel for, well, anything really, especially considering that the petrol version was capable of 40+mpg, even with the remap. There's just no point.

don't underestimate just how fast it'll be - I changed it in favour of a 400BHP Holden and reckon I'd be able to cover ground at the same pace in a vRS with 180 brake.

hope this helps