Is this the famous Hot Start Problem?
Is this the famous Hot Start Problem?
Author
Discussion

stumpage

Original Poster:

2,215 posts

257 months

Monday 16th August 2010
quotequote all
When the engine is hot I turn the ignition. The Fuel pump primes and all the dash lights come on as normal but nothing. It doesn't even try to turn the starter motor. Leave it 15 mins and it fires up first go.

Is this it or is the starter motor on the way out?

Mr Goat

8 posts

198 months

Monday 16th August 2010
quotequote all
Does sound a bit like it to me, although when hot mine tends to turn over very slowly then eventually kick in after 5-10 seconds. Have you also checked that the immobiliser has definitely been deactivated? I've been caught out by that before!!

nikman

878 posts

236 months

Monday 16th August 2010
quotequote all
Quinny said:
stumpage said:
When the engine is hot I turn the ignition. The Fuel pump primes and all the dash lights come on as normal but nothing. It doesn't even try to turn the starter motor. Leave it 15 mins and it fires up first go.

Is this it or is the starter motor on the way out?
Classic symptoms matefrown

Just buy the kit, and even if the satrter is knackard and you end up replacing it, its still a worthwhile upgrade....Especially for such a small outlaysmile


X 2. Yep - that's what it is. Couldn't have described the symptoms of the 'hot-start' problem better myself!!


Simon says

19,466 posts

252 months

Monday 16th August 2010
quotequote all
Quinny said:
stumpage said:
When the engine is hot I turn the ignition. The Fuel pump primes and all the dash lights come on as normal but nothing. It doesn't even try to turn the starter motor. Leave it 15 mins and it fires up first go.

Is this it or is the starter motor on the way out?
Classic symptoms matefrown

Just buy the kit, and even if the satrter is knackard and you end up replacing it, its still a worthwhile upgrade....Especially for such a small outlaysmile
with the added bonus that you will prolong the life of the starter circuit break immobiser relay too.

GJR

827 posts

311 months

Tuesday 17th August 2010
quotequote all
stumpage said:
Is this it or is the starter motor on the way out?
I agree with the others that the hot-start kit is worth getting anyway, but it could just be the starter. It was for me, with the exact same symptoms as you.

nikman

878 posts

236 months

Wednesday 18th August 2010
quotequote all
The heart of the 'hot-start' (or hot-not-start) problem is the starter motor itself. It gets gunged up and has poorer contacts on the windings. Then there's the solenoid. Without going into chapter and verse about how a solenoid works, very basically one contact is electro-magneticaly drawn, or 'thrown' along a shaft towards another one and when they hit the current is supplied in that instant to the starter motor itself.

Over time, the solenoid, and specifically that shaft, becomes 'sticky' and requires an ever stronger current to operate it properly. When everything is very hot and expanded the issue is made worse.

This is why the so-called hot start problem was not evident when these cars were new. But with age and heat the starter motor itself, or at least its piggy-backed solenoid, degraded. The upshot was that there was not a sufficient voltage at the end of the original circuit to 'throw' the solenoid.

So, when the car was new, the standard wiring was adequate to supply the load required to operate a new and clean starter motor. But as that demand grew with the aging of the starter motor, various areas of weakness in the wiring were cited.

Some said the connector to the Vauxhall ignition switch was poor, so there's potential for voltage drop there. Others believed that as the current passed through the immobiliser, there can be another voltage drop there. Very likely both assumptions are correct.

Broadly it is often summed up by saying one of the wires in the chain isn't quite up to the job so in hot conditions the resistance in the wire builds to the point where insufficient power gets to the starter motor.

Land Rover fitted a relay in the circuit to carry a healthier supply via this relay. All the 'hot start kit' does is simply replaces this 'missing' relay with the added advantage that it also bypasses the ignition switch wiring and immobiliser. In effect it just uses the 'weak' wiring to operate a relay which in turn provides a healthy voltage to the starter motor solenoid.

Fitting the 'hot-start kit' should prolong the useful life of the starter motor. But ultimately the starter motor will need replacing.


Nick.

Simon says

19,466 posts

252 months

Wednesday 18th August 2010
quotequote all
nikman said:
The heart of the 'hot-start' (or hot-not-start) problem is the starter motor itself. It gets gunged up and has poorer contacts on the windings. Then there's the solenoid. Without going into chapter and verse about how a solenoid works, very basically one contact is electro-magneticaly drawn, or 'thrown' along a shaft towards another one and when they hit the current is supplied in that instant to the starter motor itself.

Over time, the solenoid, and specifically that shaft, becomes 'sticky' and requires an ever stronger current to operate it properly. When everything is very hot and expanded the issue is made worse.

This is why the so-called hot start problem was not evident when these cars were new. But with age and heat the starter motor itself, or at least its piggy-backed solenoid, degraded. The upshot was that there was not a sufficient voltage at the end of the original circuit to 'throw' the solenoid.

So, when the car was new, the standard wiring was adequate to supply the load required to operate a new and clean starter motor. But as that demand grew with the aging of the starter motor, various areas of weakness in the wiring were cited.

Some said the connector to the Vauxhall ignition switch was poor, so there's potential for voltage drop there. Others believed that as the current passed through the immobiliser, there can be another voltage drop there. Very likely both assumptions are correct.

Broadly it is often summed up by saying one of the wires in the chain isn't quite up to the job so in hot conditions the resistance in the wire builds to the point where insufficient power gets to the starter motor.

Land Rover fitted a relay in the circuit to carry a healthier supply via this relay. All the 'hot start kit' does is simply replaces this 'missing' relay with the added advantage that it also bypasses the ignition switch wiring and immobiliser. In effect it just uses the 'weak' wiring to operate a relay which in turn provides a healthy voltage to the starter motor solenoid.

Fitting the 'hot-start kit' should prolong the useful life of the starter motor. But ultimately the starter motor will need replacing.


Nick.
Agree with the above but scratchchin it should not bypass the immobiliser wiring as you are still using the immobiliser break feed from the ign switch to fire the relay,not a criticism just a small correction wink

stumpage

Original Poster:

2,215 posts

257 months

Wednesday 18th August 2010
quotequote all
Well I have the hot start kit on the way and will fit it in due course. With regards to the starter motor I will get it looked at as that is covered by the warranty I got with the car. (However as it is cover with third party warranty company I won't hold my breath!) I may just give it a clean up anyway.

Thanks for the help I'll let you know how it goes.

Edited by stumpage on Wednesday 18th August 16:57

spend

12,581 posts

282 months

Wednesday 18th August 2010
quotequote all
If the mechanical throw on the starter solenoid is jamming tight, sticking more power down to it is the last thing I'd like to do.

I've still goosed starters with relay (to unload immobilizer) - but you have to get your cars really hot Andy tongue outwink

Phase 3 using heat shield does seem to have worked so far, even though I was initially skeptical that it would only encapsulate conducted heat.. Still as far as I can deduce if you cooked the starter, magical claims of quick fixes are in Slick 50 hair restorer land hehe

Overhere

382 posts

254 months

Friday 20th August 2010
quotequote all
Been having same problem, I wrapped the starter with heat insulation, may have helped a bit but still a problem. where do you get this hot start kit?

stumpage

Original Poster:

2,215 posts

257 months

Friday 20th August 2010
quotequote all
I got the kit from here.

http://www.clarion-service.co.uk/cs/Mod-Wise.html

I will get round to fitting it at the weekend and see if it solves my problem.

Overhere

382 posts

254 months

Friday 20th August 2010
quotequote all
Excellent, Thanks, I think I'll do this too.

Cheers

stumpage

Original Poster:

2,215 posts

257 months

Sunday 22nd August 2010
quotequote all
Fitted the kit in all of 15 minutes. Really easy to do and the problem seems to be sorted.