Gears crunching
Discussion
I seem to have recently been "catching gears" when changing up. To begin with I thought it was just me, but seems strange that I never used to have a problem, and would expect as experience with the car grows you find the perfect clutch position to make gear changes.
I now suspect something is up with the clutch or gearbox. The clutch master cylinder has a minor leak - which I discovered when the clutch wasn't disengaging properly, and found the reservoir empty. This has now been topped up and bled, but the gear problem is still there.
It doesn't crunch on every gear change, but mainly on changing up from 4th to 5th - even when the clutch is pressed right to the floor.
Can anyone advise on potential causes? Could it be a gearbox problem, or does this sound more clutch related.
Thanks.
I now suspect something is up with the clutch or gearbox. The clutch master cylinder has a minor leak - which I discovered when the clutch wasn't disengaging properly, and found the reservoir empty. This has now been topped up and bled, but the gear problem is still there.
It doesn't crunch on every gear change, but mainly on changing up from 4th to 5th - even when the clutch is pressed right to the floor.
Can anyone advise on potential causes? Could it be a gearbox problem, or does this sound more clutch related.
Thanks.
Hi Teetertank, I found a slight leak on my master cylinder actuating rod and a low level in the reservoir. I've pressure bled the system and the system seems OK, for now! However the fact that fluid is leaking across the master cylinder piston or the slave must mean that you're not getting full clutch movement hence no smooth gear engagement. I guess the only solution is to replace the seals or cylinder assemble. Good luck John042
Hi Teetertank, I found a slight leak on my master cylinder actuating rod and a low level in the reservoir. I've pressure bled the system and the system seems OK, for now! However the fact that fluid is leaking across the master cylinder piston or the slave must mean that you're not getting full clutch movement hence no smooth gear engagement. I guess the only solution is to replace the seals or cylinder assemble. Good luck John042
Thanks for the reply John.
The fluid leakage is so small that I can’t believe it is having a significant effect on the clutch movement. i.e. the level in the master reservoir has gone down by about 1cm in a month – that must be a fraction of a ml per day or even week, and I can’t believe that would cause a problem. But yes, the seals or cylinder should be replaces anyway.
The fluid leakage is so small that I can’t believe it is having a significant effect on the clutch movement. i.e. the level in the master reservoir has gone down by about 1cm in a month – that must be a fraction of a ml per day or even week, and I can’t believe that would cause a problem. But yes, the seals or cylinder should be replaces anyway.
I agree Teetertank mine also doesn't lose a significant amount over a period of time but my theory is, if there is fluid leaking across the piston seal each time the clutch pedal is pressed you have less pressure activating the slave piston. My theory only but we both know a leaking master cylinder can't be right? Cheers John042
You could also check you slave cylinder if the seals on the master are going then the seals in the slave won't be far behind. I would replace them anyway they are obviously at the near the end of their life and then you can at least rule them out as a cause.
Easier than a clutch change and cheaper than a gearbox!
Easier than a clutch change and cheaper than a gearbox!
This link has been suggested in previous links for clutch and brake kits.
I woiuld have thought that if it was the gear box crunching would likely be on a single change
4th to 5th 2nd to 3rd. If clutch it would be more likely to be more than one change.
It could also be a sticky clutch plate
http://www.powertrackbrakes.co.uk/
Good Luck
Trev
I woiuld have thought that if it was the gear box crunching would likely be on a single change
4th to 5th 2nd to 3rd. If clutch it would be more likely to be more than one change.
It could also be a sticky clutch plate
http://www.powertrackbrakes.co.uk/
Good Luck
Trev
Nice link - thanks.
I investigated this issue on another forum yesterday and some said it comes down to the oil you use. There seem to be two schools of thought on the best oil to use for the T5 box. Some say ATF, others gear oil. I have synthetic ATF in at the moment. Some have said that the synchro mechanism needs a little bit of friction to work properly, and therefore gear oil is recommended. I have always used ATF since I've had the car, and it's only recently that I've been getting problems.
Can anyone comment on this?
I investigated this issue on another forum yesterday and some said it comes down to the oil you use. There seem to be two schools of thought on the best oil to use for the T5 box. Some say ATF, others gear oil. I have synthetic ATF in at the moment. Some have said that the synchro mechanism needs a little bit of friction to work properly, and therefore gear oil is recommended. I have always used ATF since I've had the car, and it's only recently that I've been getting problems.
Can anyone comment on this?
Master cylinder repair kit (SP2102) at £3.75 on page 2 of this website.
Cider Andy said:
Master cylinder repair kit (SP2102) at £3.75 on page 2 of this website.
Even better link - thanks.The master cyclinder is listed for a Cortina II, does this mean the slave cylinder kit would be for the Cortina II, i.e. SP2085 kit (£3, Page 3) Or is the slave cylinder off something else?
Cheers
It doesnt take much fluid, so a little leak can be a big issue. Mine ended up jamming in reverse, and I couldnt stop the car, as the brakes were rubbish the opposite way, very scary.
I got a replacement cycling for 30 quid from Merlin. You need to tap out the outlet though, as it seems TVR did it to the standard parts.
I got a replacement cycling for 30 quid from Merlin. You need to tap out the outlet though, as it seems TVR did it to the standard parts.
I have the same problem, It started about 500 miles back . Under 4k revs will go from 4th to 5th smoothly and quietly but the higher the revs the worse the crunching is and at 6k + virtually impossible to engage 5th ( very embarrasing overtaking a civic type R up a long incline ) even doubling the clutch,
peter
peter
Exact same problem as teetertank, revs and all. This started about a year ago and sometimes makes engaging reverse difficult too (via 5th of course) Mine is fine as long as its a slow change at that speed. The problem is 5th syncromesh starting to fail so gearbox rebuild is only answer. 4th to 5th on the T5 is known to be a 'slow change', so too many quick changes might cause wear.
I will live with it for now though!
I will live with it for now though!
Gassing Station | Chimaera | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


