Oh no, it’s another what car
Oh no, it’s another what car
Author
Discussion

farrendahl

Original Poster:

1,248 posts

203 months

Thursday 19th August 2010
quotequote all
Okay with the latest in a long line of issues with the Pug having come up (antipollution fault accompanied by Kanagarooing at anything above 50 and anything below 40, general lumpy drive and noisier than a Massey Ferguson tractor.) it’s time for it to go (once serviced and repaired in order to get a decent price for it in the first place). So it’s time to replace it and get a new supplement vehicle to the other Halfs A Class, requirements are as follows:

Cheap to Insure – I have 0 no claims discount accrued so cheap is the name of the game

Cheap to run – I’m part Scots and thus refuse to part with my cash if it can be avoided

Fun – IE not a like for like replacement for the 206

Budget – 1200 – 1600 at a push

Practicality is not a huge issue as the A class can handle pretty much everything day to day we throw at it. The biggest overriding issue is the car needs to be able to carry my 6ft 4 mid set frame without making me look stupid or causing me to drive with my neck at a 90 degree angle.

So folks, what say you….I eagerly await the first suggestion of MX-5

farrendahl

Original Poster:

1,248 posts

203 months

Thursday 19th August 2010
quotequote all
I know it's not the worlds most glamourous brief but somebody has to have an idea?

300bhp/ton

41,030 posts

219 months

Thursday 19th August 2010
quotequote all
farrendahl said:
Okay with the latest in a long line of issues with the Pug having come up (antipollution fault accompanied by Kanagarooing at anything above 50 and anything below 40, general lumpy drive and noisier than a Massey Ferguson tractor.) it’s time for it to go (once serviced and repaired in order to get a decent price for it in the first place). So it’s time to replace it and get a new supplement vehicle to the other Halfs A Class, requirements are as follows:

Cheap to Insure – I have 0 no claims discount accrued so cheap is the name of the game

Cheap to run – I’m part Scots and thus refuse to part with my cash if it can be avoided

Fun – IE not a like for like replacement for the 206

Budget – 1200 – 1600 at a push

Practicality is not a huge issue as the A class can handle pretty much everything day to day we throw at it. The biggest overriding issue is the car needs to be able to carry my 6ft 4 mid set frame without making me look stupid or causing me to drive with my neck at a 90 degree angle.

So folks, what say you….I eagerly await the first suggestion of MX-5
In all seriousness how about a classic?

Apart from kit cars they are probably the cheapest thing to insure.

Can be cheap to buy and even better cheap to maintain. Ok they may like a little TLC and tinkering, but probably no more than your Pug has.

And they can be huge fun.

Slightly biased view because I own one (or at least others will say its biased even if it isn't, lol) But how about a TR7?

Seriously, it's not so different to an MX-5 in ethos or abiilty, It has a big cabin and loads of leg room, so I suspect even at 6'4" you should fit. Big boot and are easy to live with and work on.

Being a classic should make it cheap to insure. The 2.0 litre is peppy and offer up ok'ish performance in stock trim. But it's RWD and fun. A few simply mods and it can handle a lot better and also be at least warm hatch fast.

24-28mpg ability, good heater and loads of cheap parts. Also well within your price range.


Failing that, there are still loads of good cars for this money, but I have no idea how suitable for a tall person. And insurance on newer stuff will be more money.

eltax91

10,757 posts

235 months

Thursday 19th August 2010
quotequote all
Ovtavia TDi, cheap to insure, frugal, reliable. Fails on the "fun" bit otherwise perfect. Mine has done 80k in just over 2 years (had 75k when I bought it). It just will not break down, however much I want to justify a swap!!

garethj

624 posts

226 months

Thursday 19th August 2010
quotequote all
300bhp/ton said:
In all seriousness how about a classic?

Apart from kit cars they are probably the cheapest thing to insure.
What he said. Or both - my 1987 Ginetta fits me, but I'm a dwarf-like 6'2". New front discs were about £60 a pair, 6000 mile service stuff is £30 and easily done yourself in an afternoon even if you're a mechanical numpty. Obviously depreciation doesn't happen as long as it still goes and has an MoT (fibreglass body and galvanised chassis so no rust)

It's also a laugh to drive, just look at that 195x14 rear tyre peeling off the rim wink

Turbocharger

137 posts

228 months

Thursday 19th August 2010
quotequote all
My Mrs is 6ft1 and she fits surprisingly well in my MGF - they're pennies these days, 40mpg and sensible to insure, especially the older ones. They're only 200kg heavier than an Elise, and if you swap the spare tyre for a can of silly string then you can fit a /surprising/ amount of stuff in them.

TotalControl

8,307 posts

227 months

Thursday 19th August 2010
quotequote all
328?