Brake disc skimming........
Brake disc skimming........
Author
Discussion

davegreg

Original Poster:

1,099 posts

220 months

Friday 20th August 2010
quotequote all
I've just read on facebook that The Fish have just got one of those gizmos that can skim brake discs without having to remove them from the car. Thats good news for me since friction pads haven't totally cured my juddering! smile

007 VXR

64,187 posts

218 months

Friday 20th August 2010
quotequote all
just letf the fish
saw that new machine there smile

granada203028

1,500 posts

228 months

Friday 20th August 2010
quotequote all
Interesting. I have priced up a garage in Bristol to do mine, £30 per side. Guy new what a Monaro was, "arh that's a big old bird, will need to check it fits on the ramps". Asked if it was a 5.7 or 6 to.

Thinking of going EBC yellow or red stuff.

granada203028

1,500 posts

228 months

Friday 24th September 2010
quotequote all
I pondered having this done but after taking inconclusive run out measurements decided to stick with traditional off car refacing. Actually a grinding process. The inside faces of the disks particularly do show signs of picking up deposits from the pads. So I have had them done at £20 per side and fitted EBC "red stuff" pads. So far so good, no judder and bite is much as before.

Before refacing:



After grinding. Before thickness was approx 31.7mm. Now one is 31.24, other 31.25.



New and old pads compared. Not sure what the P clip is for, 2 of the 4 came with this and have to go on the inside (piston side). Old pads were more warn on the inside, approx down to 3.5mm material left, 5mm on the outside. New ones had approx 8mm. Car has done 55K, old parts all original.




New pads needed filing to fit. The backing plates are punched from sheet and this operation leaves the edges chamfered but the wrong way making them difficult to fit.



Another problem my first 21mm socket shattered trying to undo the caliper bolts. New Draper "expert" one jumped round on one bolt, but fortunately I had an imperial ring spanner which was a tight fit.





the_ferret82

25,627 posts

215 months

Saturday 25th September 2010
quotequote all
personally i would have fitted yellow stuff.

i did have them on my VXR Discs untill i needed new disks this month now have the fishes performance pads.

i must say the ebc's where good had loads of ware left when they came off and they had done over 12K

Welshbeef

49,633 posts

229 months

Saturday 25th September 2010
quotequote all
My grandad used to do that with a grinete disc in situ.
He was skintight though and from an era of make it last

Are you an environmentalist or just plain tight.

Tip toffee hammer round the edge does the job too saving more scotch money

L2VXR

1,014 posts

244 months

Saturday 25th September 2010
quotequote all
granada203028 said:

Not sure what the P clip is for, 2 of the 4 came with this and have to go on the inside


I have seen the p clips on other cars, they are "squealers" when the pads wear down to the point that the clip contacts the disc it squeals on the disc it makes you a aware that the pads need changing

Woody VT

1,890 posts

247 months

Saturday 25th September 2010
quotequote all
Welshbeef said:
My grandad used to do that with a grinete disc in situ.
He was skintight though and from an era of make it last

Are you an environmentalist or just plain tight.

Tip toffee hammer round the edge does the job too saving more scotch money
Why spend unnecessary cash? No need to shell out £700 in discs when a £100 skim will buy another year or two of safe motoring.

Not tight, just not a fool. If the discs are within limits, there is no issue with a skim.


stevieturbo

18,106 posts

278 months

Saturday 25th September 2010
quotequote all
Replacing discs is all good and well on cheap runabouts, as they are so cheap, its pointless skimming.

But a lot of bigger cars have very expensive discs. Skimming makes perfect sense.

On the car is a very good system. If doing it off the car, a local machine shop has a system whereby all 3 faces on the disc are machined at the same time to ensure perfect runout.

ie, 2 braking faces and the hub mounting face is also given a very very light skim.

If doing all the skimming operations seperate, I'd be very cautious about the end result.

raving

1,183 posts

221 months

Saturday 25th September 2010
quotequote all
stevieturbo said:
Replacing discs is all good and well on cheap runabouts, as they are so cheap, its pointless skimming.

But a lot of bigger cars have very expensive discs. Skimming makes perfect sense.

On the car is a very good system. If doing it off the car, a local machine shop has a system whereby all 3 faces on the disc are machined at the same time to ensure perfect runout.

ie, 2 braking faces and the hub mounting face is also given a very very light skim.

If doing all the skimming operations seperate, I'd be very cautious about the end result.



Skimming only makes sense if the discs are not under the manufacturers minimum thickness spec.
It would be very interesting to measure any of these skims discs afterwards

Magic919

14,591 posts

232 months

Saturday 25th September 2010
quotequote all
raving said:
It would be very interesting to measure any of these skims discs afterwards
Isn't that exactly what Granadaman did?

MyM8V8

9,468 posts

226 months

Saturday 25th September 2010
quotequote all
stevieturbo said:
Replacing discs is all good and well on cheap runabouts, as they are so cheap, its pointless skimming.

But a lot of bigger cars have very expensive discs. Skimming makes perfect sense.

On the car is a very good system. If doing it off the car, a local machine shop has a system whereby all 3 faces on the disc are machined at the same time to ensure perfect runout.

ie, 2 braking faces and the hub mounting face is also given a very very light skim.

If doing all the skimming operations seperate, I'd be very cautious about the end result.
You're right Stevie. I just had to shell out £18.00 for the new rear discs on the work Passat.

That's the pair!!! Makes you wonder about the prices we pay for our stuff!!!

Oh and the pads were £14.00 for the set.

Edited by MyM8V8 on Saturday 25th September 12:00

stevieturbo

18,106 posts

278 months

Saturday 25th September 2010
quotequote all
Any competent person skimming discs wouldnt do so leaving the discs thinner than specified.

Most discs do have a reasonable bit of life in them.

Bargain Bucket

295 posts

241 months

Saturday 25th September 2010
quotequote all
granada203028 - where did you get them re-ground for £20 per side? I can't find anyone locally who will do them for such a reasonable amount.

granada203028

1,500 posts

228 months

Saturday 25th September 2010
quotequote all
Bowden engineering, Patchway Bristol. Details come up if you google.

monkfish1

12,522 posts

255 months

Saturday 25th September 2010
quotequote all
stevieturbo said:
Any competent person skimming discs wouldnt do so leaving the discs thinner than specified.

Most discs do have a reasonable bit of life in them.


Indeed. Most of the discs in question are between 2-3 mm new to scrap.

Bargain Bucket

295 posts

241 months

Saturday 25th September 2010
quotequote all
granada203028 said:
Bowden engineering, Patchway Bristol. Details come up if you google.


Many thanks. I work that way from time to time so will bring some discs next time.

after_shock

8,751 posts

251 months

Saturday 25th September 2010
quotequote all
Whats the situation with skimming grooved discs?

north of watford

336 posts

214 months

Sunday 26th September 2010
quotequote all
No difference at all. Grooved or drilled discs can be skimmed in the same manner, as long as the minimum thickness of the disc is not exceeded.

build294

503 posts

215 months

Sunday 26th September 2010
quotequote all
had mine skimmed twice now and still didn't go down to the minium thickness but i wont have it done again. next time new discs