Disc min thickness - is dealer taking the mick?
Poll: Disc min thickness - is dealer taking the mick?
Total Members Polled: 36
Discussion
Just had my A8 serviced, and was told it needed discs and pads all round. All pads 90% worn, and front discs down to 29.3mm, with wear limit at 28mm. I was quoted £1100.
It didn't take too much to discover the original width of the discs is 30mm, which makes the 29.3mm actually less than 50% worn - so not nearly as clapped as they were trying to suggest. They didn't quote a width for the rears, but some micrometer action on Sunday will tell me; I suspect, as they haven't said, there is probably negligible wear.
I was told not to replace the pads without changing the discs as well, as they would quickly wear out.
I'm not convinced. Replace items that are less than 50% of their way through their quoted life? I've checked, they aren't grooved or damaged, just normal wear and a slight wear lip. Seems like they are erring a bit much on the side of caution.
Obviously with a big quick car I'd not want to take risks with the brakes (especially, ahem, with the way I drive
) but this seems OTT. I'm thinking of just replacing the pads, and possibly using EBC Redstuff Ceramic pads to help the discs last a bit longer!
So, the poll - is the dealer trying to upsell unnecessary parts?
It didn't take too much to discover the original width of the discs is 30mm, which makes the 29.3mm actually less than 50% worn - so not nearly as clapped as they were trying to suggest. They didn't quote a width for the rears, but some micrometer action on Sunday will tell me; I suspect, as they haven't said, there is probably negligible wear.
I was told not to replace the pads without changing the discs as well, as they would quickly wear out.
I'm not convinced. Replace items that are less than 50% of their way through their quoted life? I've checked, they aren't grooved or damaged, just normal wear and a slight wear lip. Seems like they are erring a bit much on the side of caution.
Obviously with a big quick car I'd not want to take risks with the brakes (especially, ahem, with the way I drive
) but this seems OTT. I'm thinking of just replacing the pads, and possibly using EBC Redstuff Ceramic pads to help the discs last a bit longer!So, the poll - is the dealer trying to upsell unnecessary parts?
VictorMeldrew said:
No warnings lights on - but dealer took pains to point out that if I replace the pads myself I need to get original parts with warning sensor leads ... irony!
Pretty much yes otherwise the warning light will stay on which is kinda annoying.But oem pads should be roughly 80 quid no more and cheaper ones can be had with the sensors for less than audi price just shop around.
Be carefull you havnt just bought inferior parts. The same goes with my car:
Standard plain RS6 front discs are circa £500 a disc (drilled items are more expensive again). However VW Phaeton discs are the same size and also fit. They are also a lot cheaper. You'd think this would be a no brainer, but........ They have a much lower heat resistance and a different construction. The risk of cracking is enough to put me off this option and anything other than genuine OEM is just too risky.
Like i said, be carefull when purchasing brake products. They are pretty key to safety.
Standard plain RS6 front discs are circa £500 a disc (drilled items are more expensive again). However VW Phaeton discs are the same size and also fit. They are also a lot cheaper. You'd think this would be a no brainer, but........ They have a much lower heat resistance and a different construction. The risk of cracking is enough to put me off this option and anything other than genuine OEM is just too risky.
Like i said, be carefull when purchasing brake products. They are pretty key to safety.
ecain63 said:
Be carefull you havnt just bought inferior parts. The same goes with my car:
Standard plain RS6 front discs are circa £500 a disc (drilled items are more expensive again). However VW Phaeton discs are the same size and also fit. They are also a lot cheaper. You'd think this would be a no brainer, but........ They have a much lower heat resistance and a different construction. The risk of cracking is enough to put me off this option and anything other than genuine OEM is just too risky.
Like i said, be carefull when purchasing brake products. They are pretty key to safety.
As above really... Follow the link.Standard plain RS6 front discs are circa £500 a disc (drilled items are more expensive again). However VW Phaeton discs are the same size and also fit. They are also a lot cheaper. You'd think this would be a no brainer, but........ They have a much lower heat resistance and a different construction. The risk of cracking is enough to put me off this option and anything other than genuine OEM is just too risky.
Like i said, be carefull when purchasing brake products. They are pretty key to safety.
http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-northern-ireland-1084...
ecain63 said:
Be carefull you havnt just bought inferior parts. The same goes with my car:
Standard plain RS6 front discs are circa £500 a disc (drilled items are more expensive again). However VW Phaeton discs are the same size and also fit. They are also a lot cheaper. You'd think this would be a no brainer, but........ They have a much lower heat resistance and a different construction. The risk of cracking is enough to put me off this option and anything other than genuine OEM is just too risky.
Like i said, be carefull when purchasing brake products. They are pretty key to safety.
Indeed, but EBC have been a reputable manufacturer of brake components for quite a while - I remember using their pads on my bikes back in the 70's. I'd trust them as much as the likes of Brembo, AP, Girling, Mintex - possibly more so as the bulk of their manufacturing is in the UK and they don't outsource to dubious quality third world manufacturers.Standard plain RS6 front discs are circa £500 a disc (drilled items are more expensive again). However VW Phaeton discs are the same size and also fit. They are also a lot cheaper. You'd think this would be a no brainer, but........ They have a much lower heat resistance and a different construction. The risk of cracking is enough to put me off this option and anything other than genuine OEM is just too risky.
Like i said, be carefull when purchasing brake products. They are pretty key to safety.
Back in the day the watercooled RD440 Yamaha I built (featured in Bike magazine) used a Spondon 13" floating disc, Lockheed caliper, Goodridge hoses and EBC pads, so I'm not exactly new to EBC's products!

In fact, given the above article, I think I feel safer buying reputable aftermarket upgrades than taking a risk on "OEM" parts. Caveat emptor indeed!
Edited by VictorMeldrew on Saturday 21st August 09:40
phumy said:
If you have a wear limit of 28mm, why not just wait until you get there then change them, no need to do them too early, same as tyre really...
Not the same as a tyre really. There is a video where 5th gear tested two sets of tyres. One barely legal and one with about 1mm or two more tread and the difference was amazing.Tallbut Buxomly said:
phumy said:
If you have a wear limit of 28mm, why not just wait until you get there then change them, no need to do them too early, same as tyre really...
Not the same as a tyre really. There is a video where 5th gear tested two sets of tyres. One barely legal and one with about 1mm or two more tread and the difference was amazing.phumy said:
Tallbut Buxomly said:
phumy said:
If you have a wear limit of 28mm, why not just wait until you get there then change them, no need to do them too early, same as tyre really...
Not the same as a tyre really. There is a video where 5th gear tested two sets of tyres. One barely legal and one with about 1mm or two more tread and the difference was amazing.He's not moaning about it per se hes just a bit concerned that the dealer is trying it on which i dont think is unreasonable.
Isimmo said:
ecain63 said:
Be carefull you havnt just bought inferior parts. The same goes with my car:
Standard plain RS6 front discs are circa £500 a disc (drilled items are more expensive again). However VW Phaeton discs are the same size and also fit. They are also a lot cheaper. You'd think this would be a no brainer, but........ They have a much lower heat resistance and a different construction. The risk of cracking is enough to put me off this option and anything other than genuine OEM is just too risky.
Like i said, be carefull when purchasing brake products. They are pretty key to safety.
As above really... Follow the link.Standard plain RS6 front discs are circa £500 a disc (drilled items are more expensive again). However VW Phaeton discs are the same size and also fit. They are also a lot cheaper. You'd think this would be a no brainer, but........ They have a much lower heat resistance and a different construction. The risk of cracking is enough to put me off this option and anything other than genuine OEM is just too risky.
Like i said, be carefull when purchasing brake products. They are pretty key to safety.
http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-northern-ireland-1084...
otolith said:
I've had the same spiel years ago from a fast fit place, with the discs halfway between new and minimum.
Oh -they all try it on -even the MOT wallahs - mine ,last year ,advisory "pads low" - I'd checked them before going ,and knew what they were .SO no surprise that this year ,I changed them( after approx 15k use) ( worst was 2mm) just before Mot ,to get another advisory "Discs worn) - well suppose they are - Haynes ( quoting maker ) says -new 22mm, change 19 mm.Surprise -mine =20.5 . Sort of took wind out of his sails when I said I'd miked them when I changed pads the week before .One of these days ,I'll feel brave enough to let someone like Quack fut change them and ask for a report on disc thickness ,wrt makers standards ,and ask MOT man if he'd like to change the advisory ,or have me request make a complaint .Did find one of my breakdown blokes doing nothing one day and asked him for advice .He reckoned that bloke had seen the outside edge ( missed by pad) and misjudged the problem .Cure - knock off the bit mossed by pads with toffee hammer Tame Technician said:
I followed that link from TT to the other thread - some good advice there. I can understand the "disks will be worn out by the time new pads reach the limit" argument, and indeed that makes sense if your disks are close to or beyond 50% worn, and Audi disks are indeed that soft that they only last 2 sets of pads. Fair argument in favour of the dealer.But when your discs are only at 35% worn I'd say there's a good chance of them making it through a second set, and being borderline on a third.
My Audi is on a service plan, and I can't help wondering at the significance of the following statement:
Service Plan Provider said:
Welcome to Service Plan
Service Plan is the easy way for your customers to budget for their servicing needs. By pre-paying for servicing, customers don't have to worry about large service costs each year.
What's more, customers are guaranteed to return to your dealership for service work, increasing your opportunities for resell and upsell.
Say no more.Service Plan is the easy way for your customers to budget for their servicing needs. By pre-paying for servicing, customers don't have to worry about large service costs each year.
What's more, customers are guaranteed to return to your dealership for service work, increasing your opportunities for resell and upsell.
Anyway, I am fitting Red Stuff Ceramic pads specifically because they reduce disk wear, so I'm happy that my disks will be fine for a couple of years yet. I'll check the wear rate myself every couple of months just be sure.
Edited by VictorMeldrew on Saturday 21st August 22:17
Gassing Station | Audi, Seat, Skoda & VW | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff





