GTi MkV, are prices likely to drop anytime soon?
GTi MkV, are prices likely to drop anytime soon?
Author
Discussion

matts4

Original Poster:

2,117 posts

222 months

Sunday 22nd August 2010
quotequote all
Currently trying to source for my wife, an 05 plate GTi with less than 60k miles, must be 5dr and must be manual.

However, one quick check of Autorader seems to bring very few private sales under £10k. (I always prefer to buy privatley as opposed to dealership so that I can get a feel for how the last owner may have treated it etc)

Budget is between 8 and 10k but I cant help thinking these cars are driving very high prices, for what in effect was probably 22-24k new, 5-6 years down the line, I'd have expected to see loads knocking around, especially in my price range.

So far, I can find 4 or 5 cars within 150 mile radius of where we live (North Norfolk), so hardly spoilt for choice! Of which 3 are red, and she'd much prefer silver or blue

Now, I understand that no mainstream car is really deprciation proof, so are these sellers in cuckoo land, or are these prices what I can expect to pay?

As a 2nd choice, she'd be happy with an 8P A3, maybe an S line of some description, 2.0 litre petrol or TD, but again, these are few and far between.

Maybe i'm expecting too much?

SMB

1,523 posts

297 months

Monday 23rd August 2010
quotequote all
I can see no reason why they should drastically drop in the near future, the new model is out and has been for some time, but is not about to be replaced. The Mk5 is a good blend of performance and practicality, so it's in demand, thats drives the street price.

FamilyDub

3,587 posts

196 months

Monday 23rd August 2010
quotequote all
Most 'enthusiastic' MKV GTI owners - esp Edition 30 - do seem to be over-estimating their cars' worth at the moment. In light of the MKVI being around, I would think it should be coming down a bit.

In saying that, I have an '06 plate, silver, manual, 5-dr that's done 41k and I think somewhere between £9-10k would be a fair price for mine...?

Keep looking, or you might have to consider extending your search range? wink

matts4

Original Poster:

2,117 posts

222 months

Monday 23rd August 2010
quotequote all
That would seem to be a realistic price, but I'm thinking most private owners(not enthusiast's) are p/x against newer vehicles, and not facing the hassle of a private sale.

Whilst I could extend my colour search, Black is a no no, as it will always be filthy, whilst Red looks like it could fade horrendously.

I'd probably be happy to travel up to 300 miles for the right car, but it would have to be good, and some peoples definition of very good condition is nowhere near mine, which is a waste of time and money for me.

I guess I could look at upcoming trade auctions around London/South East to see if I can drop onto something there from a larger non VW franchise, just looking to trade it out of forecourt stock.



swamp

1,014 posts

220 months

Monday 23rd August 2010
quotequote all
Unless people start buying the MkVI in numbers, then no.

The MkV is also still very much a 'current' car. Variants of its engine are being used across the latest VAG range, and it still looks up-to-date. The MkVI is not much more than a minor facelift, and a very expensive one at that, so there is not much incentive to upgrade.

Targarama

14,792 posts

314 months

Monday 23rd August 2010
quotequote all
I think one of the biggest issues is that most owners are not chopping them in for MKVI models. The new R models are very expensive for what they are (just like the Audi S3). I see what I think are a lot of ex-fleet cars, and most seem to have 60k+ on the clock.

We have a 56 plate 5 door manual with 25k on the clock, with xenons, cloth, winter pack. Perfect car for what we need it for and we have no plans to change for years.

So you're going to have to 1. wait 2. pay more or 3. go for higher miles.

P.S. I see you're after a manual - I wonder how reliable DSG will prove in a few years, esp if owners skip the £150 40k DSG service.

blank

3,767 posts

219 months

Monday 23rd August 2010
quotequote all
I was waiting for them to come down too.

Got bored and bought the Skoda version instead!

Although I did find the equivalent A3 seemed cheaper than the Golf.

bga

8,134 posts

282 months

Monday 23rd August 2010
quotequote all
matts4 said:
That would seem to be a realistic price, but I'm thinking most private owners(not enthusiast's) are p/x against newer vehicles, and not facing the hassle of a private sale.
I was offered £10k p/x for mine (MY05, 5 door, silver, manual, 45k) the other day against an S4 Avant. If there are more indie dealers are offering that (not had any others to compare) then I can see why they are being valued quite highly for private sale or just going the PX route.

matts4

Original Poster:

2,117 posts

222 months

Monday 23rd August 2010
quotequote all
I'm assuming that was against a list S4? (supposedly taking a grand out of the S4 price) then I guess they'd look to stock it/write it down for near £9k if they're gonna trade it so they can retail it at near £10.5 - 11k

At least thats promising, should mean If I hold out a touch longer, then up to 10k isn't impossible.

And yep, I'll deffo go manual, I wouldn't fancy a DSG out of warranty.

And I know what you mean about holding onto them, its replacing a Mk4 Gti which is now 11 years old, albeit she is the 2nd owner having had it for the last 6 years. Golf GTi's seem to be the sort of cars which don't date that quickly, although the Mk4 handles like a trawler compared to the MkV

Best I keep looking and put a few more feelers out to a few friends in the trade up this way

Edited by matts4 on Monday 23 August 20:02

bga

8,134 posts

282 months

Monday 23rd August 2010
quotequote all
It was an S4 up at £16k - I spotted on passing and stopped off for a look. We didn't do any negotiating as I told him I wasn't serious. He let us have a look over it and came back a bit later and said he would give £10k for the Golf on Px. Maybe he wanted shot of the Avant or it was priced a bit over? Either way I can't afford to change at the moment!

Good luck with the search

matts4

Original Poster:

2,117 posts

222 months

Monday 23rd August 2010
quotequote all
Thanks bga, hopefully one will pop up soon.

I love my S4, so hopefully I'll have the best of both worlds when she gets one. The performance is great in the s4, but the fuel bill aint so much fun!

TDIfurby

1,997 posts

206 months

Monday 23rd August 2010
quotequote all
Not sure if things have changed but Dad recently privately sold his '56 mkV GTI (totally stock) and really struggled. Started at 12,995 and within 3 months of getting no joy he ended up selling for £10.5k. I thought this was REAL low for a 56 plate on 60k miles, as it was less than 3 years old! (Was a Jan '06 car sold about December '09)

matts4

Original Poster:

2,117 posts

222 months

Tuesday 24th August 2010
quotequote all
I guess you meant to say nearly 4 years old, not 3 years old? Jan 06 - Dec 09 is 47 months (I think?)

And that was now 9 months ago, so £10k wouldn't seem a mile out. Just need to find them I guess...