Golf Mark6 TSI Engine Failure - value of car?
Golf Mark6 TSI Engine Failure - value of car?
Author
Discussion

the-photographer

Original Poster:

5,209 posts

207 months

Wednesday 25th August 2010
quotequote all
Hello, couple of days ago my Golf GT160 lost power (EPC/engine warning lights) and sounded very rough just idling.

Called VW Assist, they came out and read the fault codes, tried a few things (coil packs) but ultimately no roadside fix.

The car was recovered to the dealership, yesterday they called and said "no compresion in cylinder one" more diagnostics required.

Today, the service receptionist stated a new engine would be fitted tomorrow (I can update this thread with details once I visited the dealership tomorrow).

My question, will this effect the value of the car?

1. Now, if I decide it's a lemon and get rid of it.
2. Later in life, say when it's 3/4/5 years old.

I had hope it would be a more simple fault, like the ones mentioned on this thread;

http://www.pistonheads.com/gassing/topic.asp?h=0&a...

(the car is 13 months old, with 22,000 miles)

FamilyDub

3,587 posts

196 months

Wednesday 25th August 2010
quotequote all
First off, get a second opinion...?!

Some of the chat I've heard from VW service departments is shocking, most recent being a guy looking for a Haldex oil change on his R32 was turned away because 'that doesn't have 4WD' redface

the-photographer

Original Poster:

5,209 posts

207 months

Wednesday 25th August 2010
quotequote all
OK, do you think it should be from another VW dealership or independant examiner?

And, won't VW UK look very carefully at the claim/dealership to make sure they're not 'pulling a fast'? As I'd expect a new engine is pretty expensive?

Dr G

16,007 posts

273 months

Wednesday 25th August 2010
quotequote all
Had an RS4 do that once, it was a broken valve collet.

Could be something relatively simple like that, could be a failed ring, could have leaned out and toasted a valve completely...

Will it devalue the car? No, when it comes to sale/part exchange time there is no need to mention it at all.

Tame Technician

2,467 posts

235 months

Wednesday 25th August 2010
quotequote all
IF the car needs a new engine, supplied and fitted by main dealer technicians and all for free thanks to VW warranty.

Cant see any cause for concern, no change to retail value of the car at all.

How could you posibly benefit from a second opinion, Would you not rather have a brand new engine built in VW's engine plant. Or the old one repaired in a dusty workshop.

Please if I've missed you point enlighten me.

the-photographer

Original Poster:

5,209 posts

207 months

Wednesday 25th August 2010
quotequote all
Tame Technician said:
IF the car needs a new engine, supplied and fitted by main dealer technicians and all for free thanks to VW warranty.

Cant see any cause for concern, no change to retail value of the car at all.

How could you posibly benefit from a second opinion, Would you not rather have a brand new engine built in VW's engine plant. Or the old one repaired in a dusty workshop.

Please if I've missed you point enlighten me.
Not at all, I was just responding to FamilyDub above.

My main point being would it effect the value of the car when I come to change it.

FamilyDub

3,587 posts

196 months

Thursday 26th August 2010
quotequote all
the-photographer said:
My main point being would it effect the value of the car when I come to change it.
^^^ Shouldn't think so, matey.

VW have the habit of being... well... thick, sometimes. Maybe just my dealer.

the-photographer

Original Poster:

5,209 posts

207 months

Friday 27th August 2010
quotequote all
Final diagnostics back from the dealership, cracked piston, broken piston rings, scored bore. Reason unknown, but getting complete engine minus ancillaries.

I've done my own research, *some* online information is pointing to a problem with the crankshaft bearings in the 1.4 TSI engines which then "de-centre" the piston(s) causing the failure.


http://www.motor-talk.de/forum/liste-aller-motorsc...

Edited by the-photographer on Friday 27th August 10:04

va1o

16,118 posts

238 months

Saturday 28th August 2010
quotequote all
Make sure it is actually a new engine, as we had a problems a few years ago with them putting in unreliable "reconditioned" engines when they told us it was going to be a new one. Said car was subsequently sold.

the-photographer

Original Poster:

5,209 posts

207 months

Saturday 28th August 2010
quotequote all
OK, thanks. I will double check when I collect the car.

Since installing the new engine, one of the fuel pumps has broken and I need to wait for another spare part.

the-photographer

Original Poster:

5,209 posts

207 months

Thursday 2nd September 2010
quotequote all
Got the car back, £2500 of repairs. Let's see how long this one lasts.

(VW service claim is was a brand new engine)