MK1 Octy VRS estate Vs hatch
MK1 Octy VRS estate Vs hatch
Author
Discussion

darren9

Original Poster:

986 posts

226 months

Wednesday 25th August 2010
quotequote all
Mrs Darren9 wants a dog ... a big dog.

Now, the petrol head in me sees this as a way to change cars and get something roomier.

I've had a think and I like the Octy VRS MK1 estate. I've driven the hatch version and found it a very capable car, fast and I enjoyed the drive.

Is the Estate version significantly different to drive?

kmm

1,781 posts

211 months

Wednesday 25th August 2010
quotequote all
You'll fit a big dog in the back of an Audi S4 avant. I looked at the VRS, but decided on the S4 B5.
It's great changing your car, you get to change your mind every 5 mins and spent hrs looking at loads of different cars on the net.
Good luck with what car you go for.

darren9

Original Poster:

986 posts

226 months

Thursday 26th August 2010
quotequote all
I can't afford an audi looking at a MK1 VRS because they are very cheap!

FamilyDub

3,587 posts

196 months

Thursday 26th August 2010
quotequote all

Personally, I think the vRS estates are better looking than the saloons/hatches.

MonkeyHanger

9,267 posts

273 months

Thursday 26th August 2010
quotequote all
darren9 said:
Is the Estate version significantly different to drive?
Unless you need the load space (for coffins etc) get the hatch.


darren9

Original Poster:

986 posts

226 months

Friday 27th August 2010
quotequote all
thinking I might need the space for a massive dog ... SWMBO wants a mastif type

wid77

50 posts

238 months

Friday 27th August 2010
quotequote all
I would say the mk1 Octavia VRS is a good choice. Just make sure you drive a few and choose a good one with FSH and cared for.

Witchfinder

6,388 posts

283 months

Friday 27th August 2010
quotequote all
Incidentally, I believe the estate was supplied with 16" wheels rather than the 17" wheels that were fitted to the hatchback. That might not bother you much, but I reckon it looks a hell of a lot better on 17s.

I'd get the estate if I were you, but upgrade the wheels. My hatch was a lot of fun to own and drive - I still miss that car. I'd had it chip tuned, and it was pretty damned quick! It had very heavy-handed ASR though, if you give it too much welly in 1st gear.

drgoatboy

2,035 posts

238 months

Wednesday 1st September 2010
quotequote all
Witchfinder said:
Incidentally, I believe the estate was supplied with 16" wheels rather than the 17" wheels that were fitted to the hatchback. That might not bother you much, but I reckon it looks a hell of a lot better on 17s.
Wow, I didn't know that! They certainly are the same design, seems strange to make them smaller for the estate...

I have an estate and its a cracking car, massive boot and loads and loads of space with the seats down. Not the tallest boot in the world though so not sure how comfy a very large dog would be.
Light grey seats can get mucky quickly too so definately not dog friendly in the back.
However handles great so such a big car and a joy to drive long distances. the 5 speed gearbox is perfectly geared for motorway work (so good it makes you wonder why so many companies now opt for 6 speed)

The vrs is not all that common and the estate even less so so you may not get a massive choice. be picky if you can as they can look a bit tatty if not well looked after.

It does get mistaken for an unmarked police car quite often which I find amusing! (surely they haven't used mk1 vrs for ages?)

darren9

Original Poster:

986 posts

226 months

Wednesday 1st September 2010
quotequote all
I thought early VRS' had the 16" and later ones were 17's?

MonkeyHanger

9,267 posts

273 months

Wednesday 1st September 2010
quotequote all
darren9 said:
I thought early VRS' had the 16" and later ones were 17's?
Estates came with 16's as did some early hatches and more importantly, a lot of imported cars (mainly from Ireland)

A lot of imports were also missing the Climatronic system and a few other bits & bobs.

MonkeyHanger

9,267 posts

273 months

Wednesday 1st September 2010
quotequote all
drgoatboy said:
It does get mistaken for an unmarked police car quite often which I find amusing! (surely they haven't used mk1 vrs for ages?)
They were available up to early 2006 so some Plod cars still remain at large. Cleveland Police certainly have at least 1 MK1 still on the fleet.

drgoatboy

2,035 posts

238 months

Thursday 2nd September 2010
quotequote all
MonkeyHanger said:
drgoatboy said:
It does get mistaken for an unmarked police car quite often which I find amusing! (surely they haven't used mk1 vrs for ages?)
They were available up to early 2006 so some Plod cars still remain at large. Cleveland Police certainly have at least 1 MK1 still on the fleet.
Mines a 2005...
Its quite funny when people coming flying along, spot a silver vrs pootling along in the slow lane and slam their brakes on! Its very obvious on occasions, good job I'm not bib

MonkeyHanger

9,267 posts

273 months

Thursday 2nd September 2010
quotequote all
drgoatboy said:
Mines a 2005...
Its quite funny when people coming flying along, spot a silver vrs pootling along in the slow lane and slam their brakes on! Its very obvious on occasions, good job I'm not bib
Had the same effect with my MK1. Quite annoying at times to be honest.

It hasn't got any better with the new one rolleyes

davepen

1,483 posts

301 months

Thursday 2nd September 2010
quotequote all
darren9 said:
Now, the petrol head in me....Is the Estate version significantly different to drive?
First few times, turned round to reverse and wondered where all that car had come from. Especially if you drive two seaters. I do find the engine bogs down below 2k rpm, however the Mrs likes it. Not driven the hatch, although BiL has a Tdi Hatch; large and soggy. wink

Dr G

16,008 posts

273 months

Thursday 2nd September 2010
quotequote all
Used to have a silver TDI 170 VRS estate - fastest and easiest way to get across Buckinghamshire laugh

rb5230

11,657 posts

203 months

Thursday 2nd September 2010
quotequote all
Dr G said:
Used to have a silver TDI 170 VRS estate - fastest and easiest way to get across Buckinghamshire laugh
its not though really is it.

snowmuncher

786 posts

194 months

Friday 3rd September 2010
quotequote all
The mk.1 Octavia vRS estate is an excellent car

Cheap to buy. OK in OEM form. Easy and cheap(ish) to mod.
Once modded, is the most capable of the Golf Mk.4 front-wheel drive platforms.

The Octavia 4x4 Turbo is adequate in OEM form. But with a few mods will out-handle a R32 or TT.

The estate is the largest of the Golf mk.4 platform boots (apart from the golf people carrier type things).

You would easily have space for at least 1 mastif size hound & a decent amount other stuff (if you've got a dog, you end up carrying alot of "other stuff", which normally smells of wet dog ...)


rb5230

11,657 posts

203 months

Sunday 5th September 2010
quotequote all
snowmuncher said:
Once modded, is the most capable of the Golf Mk.4 front-wheel drive platforms.

The Octavia 4x4 Turbo is adequate in OEM form. But with a few mods will out-handle a R32 or TT.
i would say the leon cupra-r is the most cabable mk4 platform car.

and did they even do a mk1 4x4 octavia vrs? im pretty sure they didnt.

snowmuncher

786 posts

194 months

Sunday 5th September 2010
quotequote all
rb5230 said:
i would say the leon cupra-r is the most cabable mk4 platform car.

and did they even do a mk1 4x4 octavia vrs? im pretty sure they didnt.
The Octavia vRS and 4x4 Turbo (not a vRS 4x4) is an elongate stiffened R32 chassis, as oppose to the standard length wheel-base of the Leon Cupra-r. Thus the handling potential of the Octavia chassis is better.

From factory, completely OEM, The Leon Cupra-r is probably the most capable FWD Golf.4 platform. The TT 20v Turbo is the probably most capable of the 4x4 Golf.4 platforms from factory, again, completely OEM.

My basic point was, that in OEM form, the vRS is a good, and it is easy and cheap to mod.
Once fully modded, is more capable than an equally modded Leon-Cupra-R, due the longer chassis.