Checking For Cam Wear
Checking For Cam Wear
Author
Discussion

Chimpaholic

Original Poster:

9,637 posts

210 months

Thursday 26th August 2010
quotequote all
Hi all,

Following a recent disappointing rolling road session and as part of a series of other checks I need to accurately establish the condition of my cam.

With every other push rod engine I have worked on its a case of rocker covers off and use a DTI to measure the lift on each rocker arm?

Is this a legitimate method with hydraulic lifters?

If I am on track here can someone confirm the lift figures for a healthy cam.

Thanks.

Simon says

19,466 posts

252 months

Thursday 26th August 2010
quotequote all
You can also get a real gauge of cam condition just by dropping the sump IMO especially if you have resealing the sump on your list of things to do,pitting lobes,lobes looking more egg shaped etc smile and you get a chance to nip up those vital oil pick-up pipe cap screws/bolts hehe piece of piss if tied up with an oil & filter change too as you get to check for nasties/accumulated sludge etc.

Edited by Simon says on Thursday 26th August 20:25

spend

12,581 posts

282 months

Thursday 26th August 2010
quotequote all
It's going to be pretty much the same across your rockers, just try measuring the lift at the rocker arm heel with your dial gauge. They don't wear evenly so it should at least give you an idea whether it is worth stripping further to investigate.

Loads of folks can assume the cam is worn because of the strange ways the followers are encouraged to rotate - those markings are not necessarily indicative of excessive wear. DTI on a locked follower repeated across the cam is the surest way - if it looks crappy but they all lift the same it is odds on the cam will be fine IYSWIM.

roysum

961 posts

220 months

Thursday 26th August 2010
quotequote all
Simon says said:
You can also get a real gauge of cam condition just by dropping the sump IMO especially if you have resealing the sump on your list of things to do,pitting lobes,lobes looking more egg shaped etc smile and you get a chance to nip up those vital oil pick-up pipe cap screws/bolts hehe piece of piss if tied up with an oil & filter change too as you get to check for nasties/accumulated sludge etc.

Edited by Simon says on Thursday 26th August 20:25
Sorry Simon, can't get to grips with that. How can you tell cam condition from dropping the sump ?

Roy


Ant.

5,254 posts

312 months

Thursday 26th August 2010
quotequote all
Because , with the sump off , you can see upto the camshaft.... but the best way is to pull the cam and followers.

roysum

961 posts

220 months

Thursday 26th August 2010
quotequote all
Ant. said:
Because , with the sump off , you can see upto the camshaft.... but the best way is to pull the cam and followers.
Ok, but to verify wear ?

Chimpaholic

Original Poster:

9,637 posts

210 months

Thursday 26th August 2010
quotequote all
spend said:
It's going to be pretty much the same across your rockers, just try measuring the lift at the rocker arm heel with your dial gauge. They don't wear evenly so it should at least give you an idea whether it is worth stripping further to investigate.

Loads of folks can assume the cam is worn because of the strange ways the followers are encouraged to rotate - those markings are not necessarily indicative of excessive wear. DTI on a locked follower repeated across the cam is the surest way - if it looks crappy but they all lift the same it is odds on the cam will be fine IYSWIM.
Thanks Spend so the variance of lift between rockers is more of an indicator of than the lift itself.

Makes sense.

I do have a small sump leak, has anyone got a photo of what is visible looking up the crankcase from below?

TJC46

2,199 posts

237 months

Thursday 26th August 2010
quotequote all
Im sure your aware of this already, but if you strip the plenum and the inlet manifold off and remove the valley gasket, you can clearly see the cam lobes, but wether you could identify wear this way i dont know. You do get a very clear view of them , a much closer view than dropping the sump. As you have to remove the fuel rail and injectors, its an ideal chance to renew the 2 no. rubber fuel pipes, and fit new injector sealing rings, both jobs inexpensive but vital.

Simon says

19,466 posts

252 months

Thursday 26th August 2010
quotequote all
roysum said:
Ant. said:
Because , with the sump off , you can see upto the camshaft.... but the best way is to pull the cam and followers.
Ok, but to verify wear ?
Because pitting is usually a good indicator of cam lobe/cam follower failure even at it's earlier stages + you get a peek at the shape of the cam lobe profile(with a small mirror)but wear would have to be quite advanced to notice using this method,measuring lift at the rocker arms with a solid lifter as already suggested is far more accurate smile and as AJC46 as said i used one of these and a bright torch to get an indicator i was only changing a leaking sump gasket and getting a peek at the cam gear was just a bonus as i intend to change the cam gear this autumn as i have some slack in my duplex timing gear frown



Edited by Simon says on Thursday 26th August 22:02

spend

12,581 posts

282 months

Thursday 26th August 2010
quotequote all
Chimpaholic said:
so the variance of lift between rockers is more of an indicator of than the lift itself.
Pretty much so IMHO.. Absolute lift is a bit irrelevant unless you know exactly what the cam is & hence the lift it should have, it may not be original and taking it out to see the stamping on the rear bearing is as much work as just buying a new one..

I can't recall hearing of one that had worn evenly, and it is normally the lobes that differ, but you can check the ramps at set points by installing a degree wheel if you want. It is a bit of added QA to do on a new cam anyway, if its a bad grind your suppliers will only be too happy to fix it with the grinders I'm sure.

Pupp

13,044 posts

303 months

Thursday 26th August 2010
quotequote all
Having done the sump off routine to try and inspect cams for wear, I'd suggest it's a waste of time (for that purpose). The view is very obstructed by the crank and rods, almost inaccessible for certain lobes by the crankcase webs, and I doubt it would be easy to measure meaningfully. Much easier in the rocker boxes with a DTI

TBH, when they wear, they go real quick and you will find big differences between individual lobes... so much so, it would be obvious just from inspection without measuring if the valley was opened up. Nothing like as easy from below however unless its one of the more exposed lobes that has rounded.

Chimpaholic

Original Poster:

9,637 posts

210 months

Thursday 26th August 2010
quotequote all
Ok so its back to my original idea of a DTI on the rockers.

I just wasn't sure if the tappets bleed down at rest at different rates giving me false readings.

Perhaps they stay pumped up much longer than I thought.

I guess it should be fine if I do the checks after running the engine up to temperature.

As you can probably tell I'm an old school solid tappet man, not had much to do with these hydraulic jobbies.

Edited by Chimpaholic on Thursday 26th August 23:13

spend

12,581 posts

282 months

Friday 27th August 2010
quotequote all
The spring inside the wooshy followers is strong enough for the DTI if you remove the rocker shafts (releasing the valve spring pressure). It's just tricky to set the measurement perpendicular and continually centred on the oil hole, but those minor geometric differences will be nothing compared to the whole mm your lobes can be ground off.

It's probably only really when you are timing a new cam that you want the absolute accuracy of a solid/fixed follower and the DTI as close/parallel to it as possible?

Chimpaholic

Original Poster:

9,637 posts

210 months

Friday 27th August 2010
quotequote all
spend said:
The spring inside the wooshy followers is strong enough for the DTI if you remove the rocker shafts (releasing the valve spring pressure). It's just tricky to set the measurement perpendicular and continually centred on the oil hole, but those minor geometric differences will be nothing compared to the whole mm your lobes can be ground off.

It's probably only really when you are timing a new cam that you want the absolute accuracy of a solid/fixed follower and the DTI as close/parallel to it as possible?
Thanks again Spend, guess what I'm doing this weekend smash

rev-erend

21,624 posts

315 months

Friday 27th August 2010
quotequote all
Personally I would not use a dial guage .. as set-up on an alloy block is trouble sum.

Just use a vernier on the spring at full lift and conpare the values.

I'm guessing here - most TVR will have a max lift of approx 11~12mm multiplied by the rocker ratio of 1.55. So approx 18mm.

Normally wear happens on one or two only .. where they wear thru the metal - so most should read the same ,, with one or two being lower and the culprits.

Chimpaholic

Original Poster:

9,637 posts

210 months

Friday 27th August 2010
quotequote all
rev-erend said:
Personally I would not use a dial guage .. as set-up on an alloy block is trouble sum.

Just use a vernier on the spring at full lift and conpare the values.

I'm guessing here - most TVR will have a max lift of approx 11~12mm multiplied by the rocker ratio of 1.55. So approx 18mm.

Normally wear happens on one or two only .. where they wear thru the metal - so most should read the same ,, with one or two being lower and the culprits.
Spot on, I had completely neglected to consider the magnetic qualities of aluminium hehe.