Air filter location : Bulkhead or Intercooler ?
Air filter location : Bulkhead or Intercooler ?
Author
Discussion

alastairb

Original Poster:

763 posts

201 months

Thursday 26th August 2010
quotequote all
Hi,
I was chatting with Pete @ Noble motorsport today and as part of their Noble tuning they move the airfilters to the bulkhead location a la 2.5 GTO. He cited the fact the engine is pulling in 250 litres of air a second at 6K rpm which doesnt leave much for the intercooler.

Just wandered what opinions are on this ? Adrian / Phil - your running big power, where are your filters ?

Mike Tuckwood

1,261 posts

228 months

Thursday 26th August 2010
quotequote all
That is the worst possible position for them, they are massively affected (detrimentally) in that location as they are effectively pulling gallons of hot air in from the engine bay.

If you are going to fit them there, you will be well advised to completely shroud them from the engine bay. We have tried this while mapping one with bulkhead monted air filters a while ago, we made some shrouding just using carefully sculpted thick cardboard, the difference was substantial.


Mike.

alastairb

Original Poster:

763 posts

201 months

Thursday 26th August 2010
quotequote all
Thats what I thought Mike - Probably leave them where they are !

ajg31

1,455 posts

236 months

Thursday 26th August 2010
quotequote all
Power aside i think the sound is terrible with the ala 2.5 mounting position. Just my 2p worth

SimonJW

779 posts

266 months

Friday 27th August 2010
quotequote all
ajg31 said:
Power aside i think the sound is terrible with the ala 2.5 mounting position. Just my 2p worth
I would have to strongly disagree. Some of the sounds made by the air filters are truly 'out of this world' in my 2.5.

Si

ThatPhilBrettGuy

11,810 posts

269 months

Friday 27th August 2010
quotequote all
Mike Tuckwood said:
That is the worst possible position for them, they are massively affected (detrimentally) in that location as they are effectively pulling gallons of hot air in from the engine bay.
yes Those side openings don't scoop up much air at all. Adrian and I have them in the usual place in front of the intercooler. Works well and the intake temps are fine there.

SimonJW

779 posts

266 months

Friday 27th August 2010
quotequote all
Mike Tuckwood said:
That is the worst possible position for them, they are massively affected (detrimentally) in that location as they are effectively pulling gallons of hot air in from the engine bay.

If you are going to fit them there, you will be well advised to completely shroud them from the engine bay. We have tried this while mapping one with bulkhead monted air filters a while ago, we made some shrouding just using carefully sculpted thick cardboard, the difference was substantial.


Mike.
I'm intrigued. What differences in intake temp are you witnessing, Mike/Phil? This could be a worthy 'mod' although I would miss the soundz....

Cheers

Si

alastairb

Original Poster:

763 posts

201 months

Friday 27th August 2010
quotequote all
SimonJW said:
ajg31 said:
Power aside i think the sound is terrible with the ala 2.5 mounting position. Just my 2p worth
I would have to strongly disagree. Some of the sounds made by the air filters are truly 'out of this world' in my 2.5.

Si
Clarksons infamous trip over to darkside when testing the M12GTO was a 2.5 wasnt it ? I've also read the 3's woosh / flutter is a little quieter due to the relocating aft of the engine bay ?

I guess I'd prefer lower charge temps to more noise. Points taken - thanks guys
Al

Adrian W

15,450 posts

257 months

Friday 27th August 2010
quotequote all
Mike Tuckwood said:
That is the worst possible position for them, they are massively affected (detrimentally) in that location as they are effectively pulling gallons of hot air in from the engine bay.

If you are going to fit them there, you will be well advised to completely shroud them from the engine bay. We have tried this while mapping one with bulkhead monted air filters a while ago, we made some shrouding just using carefully sculpted thick cardboard, the difference was substantial.


Mike.
I can't argue with any of thatsmile the best place would be, Front one by the fuel pump and rear next to the turbo with some heat shielding

2.5bluenob

1,620 posts

205 months

Friday 27th August 2010
quotequote all
I cant belive that noble motorsport would get it so wrong

mgbond

6,749 posts

261 months

Friday 27th August 2010
quotequote all
ajg31 said:
Power aside i think the sound is terrible with the ala 2.5 mounting position. Just my 2p worth
Your kidding me, thats the best noise ever. This noise is what makes me smile every time I drive it.

If you want to go a little faster then loose some weight(not pointing fingers at anyone smile) and keep the filters at the bulk head smile

Bondy

Edited by mgbond on Friday 27th August 18:46

2.5bluenob

1,620 posts

205 months

Friday 27th August 2010
quotequote all
mgbond said:
ajg31 said:
Power aside i think the sound is terrible with the ala 2.5 mounting position. Just my 2p worth
Your kidding me, thats the best noise i ever. This noise is what makes me smile every time I drive it.

If you want to go a little faster then loose some weight(not pointing fingers at anyone smile) and keep the filters at the bulk head smile

Bondy
+ 1
dont think ive been in a car that sounds beter!

TrackPredator

31 posts

205 months

Friday 27th August 2010
quotequote all
+1 on the sound for sure.

During my build of the Noble out here in the US, we measured air temps in both locations on two nobles and there wasn't any noticeable difference in ambient air temps. So I elected to mount to the bulk head and will heat shield them later this month for added benefit.


Blu3R

2,380 posts

228 months

Friday 27th August 2010
quotequote all
Adrian W said:
the best place would be, Front one by the fuel pump...

Interesting. I assume there's enough air flow by the pump because of the M400 side pod or do you think this would still be the case for cars without them?



Adrian W said:
...and rear next to the turbo with some heat shielding
i.e. directly mounted on the turbo? Or close to? Where do you mean by that exactly?

simonx50

818 posts

189 months

Tuesday 8th February 2011
quotequote all
Hi Guys does any one have some pics of how to mount the air filters on the bulkhead?
Simon

5paulmv

1,250 posts

200 months

Tuesday 8th February 2011
quotequote all
hi simon hope you can work out how to mount air filters from this picture

5paulmv

1,250 posts

200 months

Tuesday 8th February 2011
quotequote all
found another pic may be more helpful simon

david.mt

1,173 posts

212 months

Tuesday 8th February 2011
quotequote all
5paulmv said:
found another pic may be more helpful simon
What no ass wink

5paulmv

1,250 posts

200 months

Tuesday 8th February 2011
quotequote all
sorry david not this time dont wanna get into bother again will have to photo latest mod at some point gonna fit a detatchable tow bar to take trailer tent to isle of man for the tt maybe just wondering iff anyone fitted one b4 or iff i will be the first??

Mike Tuckwood

1,261 posts

228 months

Wednesday 9th February 2011
quotequote all
5paulmv said:
sorry david not this time dont wanna get into bother again will have to photo latest mod at some point gonna fit a detatchable tow bar to take trailer tent to isle of man for the tt maybe just wondering iff anyone fitted one b4 or iff i will be the first??
Hi paul.

You may want to look into the legality of that; I'm not entirely certain, but while I was researching some tacho and drivers reg's stuff recently, I'm sure I saw some legislation saying if the car is not plated by the manufacturer on the vin plate with permissable towing weights, that you can't tow with it or fit a tow bar at all?


Mike.