Head gasket or cylinder liner crack?
Head gasket or cylinder liner crack?
Author
Discussion

lmagDM

Original Poster:

13 posts

194 months

Sunday 5th September 2010
quotequote all
I am trying to understand the cause of white smoke billowing from the tailpipes of my 1994 4L chim. Actually, I am convinced that I have a coolant leak, the problem is I don't know where! I thought is was head gaskets and when I opened the heads and found pitting corrosion in the tin gaskets as well as around the water jacket ports, I thought I had found the cause of my problem. After carefully refitting composite gaskets, and replacing freshly milled heads, I find that the engine is still smoking. The problem definitely involves the No. 8 cyl. I am about to start a teardown of the engine again. This time I will pressure test the the air intake manifold and I will redo a pressure test of the r.s. head. Has anyone experienced a coolant leak in the air plenum? If indeed the problem is in the cylinder itself, can anyone suggest a source for a block?

Colin RedGriff

2,541 posts

288 months

Sunday 5th September 2010
quotequote all
Not sure how far you have investigated your problem but here's an alternative thought

Check that your PAS pump is not dripping oil from that u-bend pipe. It drips onto the exhaust underneath right on the joint between the front and rear sections. The oil seeps through the joint and into the exhaust.

When it warms up it creates tons of white smoke out the back until it has burned off, which can take several miles of driving.....

I had this on my Griff once after it had been laid up for a day or two while I replaced rocker cover gaskets. Properly frightened me that I had cocked something up.eek

TVR Beaver

2,874 posts

211 months

Sunday 5th September 2010
quotequote all
Did you look at the liner?... the rear cylinders are prone to overheating (In RR's) and typicaly no 8 will leak / slip?... see if you can see if the liner has dropped any or if there is evidance of coolent between the liner and the casting... if so you could have a crack or pourus casting that's allowing water into the cylinder?.... (also make sure the cylinder itself is not cracked)
Top hat liners will sort it out... £600 ish to do...
Hope it's not ... have you pressurised your system also.. it may show this way and at least if the pressure drops you do know youve got a hole at some point....
driving

spend

12,581 posts

282 months

Sunday 5th September 2010
quotequote all
Get a kit or garage to test your coolant for hydro carbons, and a coolant pressure tester if you are actually losing coolant.

Sounds like you have been a bit heavy handed with your problem solving, but at least you have a good a good look at your lump hehe

White stuff at the back could even be your cats escaping rofl

haircutmike

22,511 posts

235 months

Sunday 5th September 2010
quotequote all
White smoke can also be caused by brake fluid leaking into the servo and then sucked up into the manifold up the vacum pipe.

lmagDM

Original Poster:

13 posts

194 months

Monday 6th September 2010
quotequote all
Thank you all. Unfortunately, given that I'm in Canada the time difference means that when I reply you are all likely to be asleep! Unless I try in the morning/ afternoon. Given that tomorrow is a national holiday here, I may just do that.
So...some very helpful tips for me too look into...well worth doing so if it means avoiding another tear down. The car feels quite a bit lumpy when it idles suggesting a misfire? not surprising if coolant is actually getting into the cylinder. I don't have an overheating problem and I have had it running for over 45 minutes. It gets to 90 and stays. I did not notice that the liner shift, nor did I see any sign of cracks, although I understand that they can be very difficult to detect. I don't see any sign of leaking fluids either (other than the usual stuff). I'll check the brake fluid oil level. One thing I found strange was that the smoke didn't smell sweet. In fact it was almost acidic, perhaps from the richness of the combustion if the O2 sensor was trying to compensate. BTW all the plugs 2,4,6 were black and smelled of fuel. Only 8 did not but had that caramel colour. I will be pressure testing the block, but first I will try the head again as well as the air intake manifolds.

spend

12,581 posts

282 months

Monday 6th September 2010
quotequote all
If the liner slips you get a rather noisy clanking, if the block cracks the liner will slip &/ it will start using coolant. Doesn't sound like you have either of those symptoms.

The inlet manifold and heads have plenty of metal surrounding the waterways (it's only the bigger valves & porting on larger valved heads that occasionally have problems) so unless you didn't get gaskets to seal should be unlikely.. Thats why folks are very careful to check decks / heads / manifold faces for flatness to ensure a good seal and use good quality gaskets.

I'd put some new plugs in, give it a run and then see what the plugs look like. Using a noid light to quickly check the injector wiring (particularly where you have a weak plug) might be worthwhile. You could also swap some of the injectors around to see if the plug pattern follows it. 8 is the closest port to the brake servo line BTW, you can pull the vac pipes off and give them a quick inspection / clean out easily enough.

rev-erend

21,624 posts

315 months

Monday 6th September 2010
quotequote all
I've had a Griff 500 where the porting was too extreme and water was escaping into the exhaust via a hairline crack. Not easy to detect or see.

lmagDM

Original Poster:

13 posts

194 months

Monday 6th September 2010
quotequote all
Spend, Thanks for the tips...I'll inspect those lines and injectors.

This is a basic 4L and it has not been ported unless the factory got carried away. In any event if at the end of the day it is the block, is anyone familiar with a breaker that I could source a used one from? or am I better off buying a new one?

haircutmike

22,511 posts

235 months

Monday 6th September 2010
quotequote all
There have been a few 5.0 engines for sale in the last few months.

Might be worth biting the bullet if is serious!

lmagDM

Original Poster:

13 posts

194 months

Monday 6th September 2010
quotequote all
Will I need to change the gearbox? I suppose a T5 would make more sense, but will it fit?

Ant.

5,254 posts

312 months

Monday 6th September 2010
quotequote all
spend said:
If the liner slips you get a rather noisy clanking
RATHER NOISY ????

lmagDM

Original Poster:

13 posts

194 months

Friday 24th September 2010
quotequote all
Well here's an update...I began the teardown on my 4L chim again. Its going a lot quicker the second time. frown I even managed to get the RS exhaust manifold off without jacking the car! (at this stage I need to celebrate the small victories!) That meant slidng my now very bruised hand between the pipes and the block and working with my finger tips to crack loose the manifold bolts for cyl 6&8. Fortunatley since they were recently put on they probably were not as tight as they ought to have been. Anyway, upon removal of the manifold I noticed that ports for cyl 4 & 6 were dripping wet, no. 6 especially. I've come to find that the injector for this cyl is out of spec in term of resistance. The liquid is very soot filled and slippery and does not smell like fuel. I think its oil. The heads were machined and pressure tested (I was told) and should be fine. There are nuts in the head that is just above these two ports. I checked them and they were tight. I guess this means there is a crack in the head where the oil is getting past the valve. Here are a couple of pics to show what I mean: Next I will pressure test the block to look for leaks. I would be glad to switch to a 5L but that would mean new gearbox too right? or will the SDi bell housing fit on the 5L? ECU of too of course.


spend

12,581 posts

282 months

Friday 24th September 2010
quotequote all
Can't see much clearly from your pics TBH. Oil sat in the heads under the rocker cover is perfectly normal. Oil getting into the ports can be shagged valve stem seals or work guides but you need to strip the heads to inspect, failing that shagged bores/rings allowing oil up into the combustion chamber. Either would generally show clues from compression testing.

The oilways up into the head are only a small drilling and both are pretty well surrounded by material, absolute minimal chance of a crack in those areas. You may be confusing the problem bigger valved engines have where the water passages are VERY close to the valve seat and occasionally crack.

lmagDM

Original Poster:

13 posts

194 months

Saturday 25th September 2010
quotequote all
Thank you Spend. Tomorrow morning I'm going to remove the head and get it pressure checked again. I'll also rig something up to pressurise the block to see what happens. I'm almost hoping for a leak in cyl. 8. but now I need to sort out where this oil is coming from as well. It's never ending!!! Maybe I should just buy a 4.6 coscast short engine and be done with it. But before I get it here I'll be in it for close to 4 grand, almost enough to buy another Chimaera.

SILICONE KID

14,997 posts

262 months

Saturday 25th September 2010
quotequote all
I was told to keep away from those coscast blocks..

slideways

4,101 posts

252 months

Saturday 25th September 2010
quotequote all
lmagDM said:
Thank you Spend. Tomorrow morning I'm going to remove the head and get it pressure checked again. I'll also rig something up to pressurise the block to see what happens. I'm almost hoping for a leak in cyl. 8. but now I need to sort out where this oil is coming from as well. It's never ending!!! Maybe I should just buy a 4.6 coscast short engine and be done with it. But before I get it here I'll be in it for close to 4 grand, almost enough to buy another Chimaera.
If you find it is a liner problem why not get it top hat linered its about £1400 ish then no more block problems

SILICONE KID

14,997 posts

262 months

Saturday 25th September 2010
quotequote all

Those coscast blocks are ccensoredp
..don`t RPI sell themrolleyes




Edited by SILICONE KID on Sunday 26th September 00:21

V8TVR1978

895 posts

221 months

Saturday 25th September 2010
quotequote all
Leo: Thanks to you and the crew in "Toronta" for treating the Spousal Unit and myself so well last weekend. We really enjoyed ourselves. (I now know why Bob thinks so much of you and Mike.) Pics and videos will follow when I get some free time (not looking like soon though). If your looking for a new block, I know where there is a 5.0 litre in Burlington and that is real close to you. Taking Sherry's and the girls cars to our local end of the season car show tomorrow. Mine can't go as the flywheel is hitting the starter when I crank on it so we now have to figure out why. Hopefully it is not internal and is just a flywheel that is not true. Talk to you later and thanks again.

Edited by V8TVR1978 on Saturday 25th September 23:33

lmagDM

Original Poster:

13 posts

194 months

Sunday 26th September 2010
quotequote all
Well the head is off. No obvious signs of a slipped liner at least to these untrained eyes. the liner is flush with the block. There definitely was oil in cyl 6 and 4 (new problem). I will have head pressure tested and I'll pressure test the block myself.
I'm surprised about the comments on coscast...I thought they were the be all and end all substitute for these rV8. RPI sells and they also seem to be promoted by TVR Power??? I thought that a new short engine would be more economical, because I figured that I would need more than just the block. Could I refit the cam, crank, pistons, etc. from the old engine?
Wayne: great to see you too. It was a blast. Look forward to the video. Remember to let me know next time you're in Town.
For all of you helping me with this engine problem, THANK YOU!
My goal is to have it running asap, but at least for our next British Car Show next September. Its the largest gathering of British cars in North America. There are usually over 1000 cars that driven, hauled, draged and pushed in to the park! If anyone plans a visit to Toronto next year at this time, be sure to take it in.