dyno pub talk
dyno pub talk
Author
Discussion

Meatball

Original Poster:

1,638 posts

241 months

Sunday 5th September 2010
quotequote all
Does anyone roughly know what the percentage drivetrain loss is ( average ) between crank bhp to at the wheels bhp
Ive seen a few quoting as high as 25%

phillpot

17,524 posts

214 months

Sunday 5th September 2010
quotequote all
Figures I have for my cars work out at around 18 - 20%

Measurements are done in Fourth gear to minimise loss through gearbox but presume dyno then "calculates" or "best guesses" flywheel figure ?

bigdods

7,175 posts

258 months

Sunday 5th September 2010
quotequote all
I have quite a few under my belt, the highest being 26%. I only take interest now in the at the wheels figure. On my 450 this has come out within 1bhp on 3 different rolling roads so I think its got to be accurate. The calculated figures based on the same at the wheels figure run from 240 to 270....

Edited by bigdods on Sunday 5th September 20:51


Edited by bigdods on Sunday 5th September 20:52

scruggs

419 posts

197 months

Monday 6th September 2010
quotequote all
My Chim 500 was last tested about 6 yeas ago when it was 5 years old. The figures were 257 at the flywheel and 216 at the road wheels, so thats a 16% drop me thinks.

kenny.R400

1,212 posts

271 months

Monday 6th September 2010
quotequote all
How any people ever have a proper dyno run on here?. I've only ever had one in my life at Minister racing engines..............i.e. engine out,plumbed in on bench,flywheel braking etc.


spend

12,581 posts

282 months

Monday 6th September 2010
quotequote all
Possibly quite a few? IIRC V8D run in their engines on the dyno, quite a valuable pre-delivery service which little seems to mentioned of?

Meatball

Original Poster:

1,638 posts

241 months

Tuesday 7th September 2010
quotequote all
I think V8d work on 15% drive train loss on the RV8 IIRC

JR

14,332 posts

289 months

Tuesday 7th September 2010
quotequote all
spend said:
Possibly quite a few? IIRC V8D run in their engines on the dyno, quite a valuable pre-delivery service which little seems to mentioned of?
That's interesting. I wonder whether a few owners could post the readings to allow some real figures to be seen for once.

Jonny_uk

305 posts

236 months

Tuesday 7th September 2010
quotequote all
Normall 15 - 20 % loss through drivetrain,

It calculates this loss on run down by measureing relative friction without engine enagaged, e.g. in neutral,


If you want to get technical ;

Overview:

There are two types of chassis dynamometer, the wheel fixed type and the rolling road type. With the wheel fixed type, the road wheels are removed from the car, and the driven hubs are bolted to the dynamometer unit. This can provide very accurate results because there is a direct drive between the engine and the dynamometer. The rolling road type involves positioning the vehicles driven wheels on rollers, so the rollers are driven through the friction between the roller surface and the vehicle tyres.

The following focuses on the rolling road type chassis dynamometer, though the test procedures are the same for both types.

Due to the rolling road being dependant on the grip between the tyre and the roller, there are two important considerations if accurate results are to be obtained. Firstly, the surface of the roller must be able to offer sufficient grip for the tyre to drive it with minimal slippage (or wheel spin on the roller), and secondly, the roller diameter is also important. This is because the larger the diameter of the roller, the less curved its surface is, giving a surface more like a flat road. The curvature of the surface will affect the size and shape of the contact patch, and therefore the grip between the tyre and roller.

Once the car is positioned with the driven wheels on the rollers, it needs to be strapped down. This is for two reasons. The car needs to stay on the rollers during the test, so the straps serve to anchor it in place. Also, the straps provide extra down force so that grip will be increased between the tyre and the roller. However, strapping the car down too tightly can produce excessive down force which could lead to the tyres being damaged during the test, to the extent where they may suffer complete failure. This could prove both dangerous and costly, so certainly isn’t desirable.

The rolling road chassis dynamometer measures the torque produced at the wheels of the vehicle. To do this it measures the speed that the roller is turning at, and thus its angular acceleration can be calculated. The torque at the wheels is given by the following equation:

Tw = I x á

Where:

Tw = the torque at the wheels of the vehicle
I= the mass moment of inertia of the roller, which is known for the given rolling road
á= the angular acceleration of the roller.

The software that is used with the rolling road performs all of these calculations.

Next the torque at the crankshaft is calculated, using the following equation:

Tw = G x Tc

Where:

G = overall gear ratio, which the software calculates by comparing roller speed with engine speed
Tc = Torque produced at the crankshaft

Finally the power output of the engine can be calculated. The following equation is used:

P = Tc x ù

Where:

P = power output of engine, measured at the crankshaft
ù = angular velocity of the engine

For the purpose of these calculations, torque is measured in Nm, angular velocity in rad/s, and power in W or kW.

Test Procedure:

Dynamic Mode

1.The car is positioned on the rollers, and strapped down
2.It is then run through to the selected gear, usually top minus one, i.e. 4th in a 5 speed car
3.Warm up conditions are checked to ensure that the engine is at its correct operating temperature so that the test can be conducted safely
4.Cooling fans are checked to ensure airflow is maintained to the cars cooling system
5.Software controls are checked to ensure that all inputs are functioning correctly
6.Engine speed is reduced to minimum recording value
7.The test sequence is started on the software
8.The throttle is opened fully
9.The throttle is held in wide open position until maximum engine speed is reached
10.End of test sequence

The computer then produces a graph that plots the torque and power output at the crankshaft against engine speed, or what is known as a torque curve and a power curve.

Static Mode

Steps 1 to 5 are followed as for a dynamic mode test.

6.Fix the target engine speed at which you wish to conduct the test
7.Run at desired throttle position
8.The computer gives a signal indicating the finish of the test, and the throttle is closed
9.End of test sequence

After the test has been completed, whether it be in static or dynamic mode, the engine should be allowed to run at idle for around a minute to allow cooling. The cooling fans in the test cell should be left running after the engine is shut down to allow further cooling.

spend

12,581 posts

282 months

Tuesday 7th September 2010
quotequote all
JR said:
spend said:
Possibly quite a few? IIRC V8D run in their engines on the dyno, quite a valuable pre-delivery service which little seems to mentioned of?
That's interesting. I wonder whether a few owners could post the readings to allow some real figures to be seen for once.
... but isn't that what creates the confusion with TVR figures... Accepted standards for engine dyno testing allow removal of ancils, external water pumping/cooling, funky exhausts... Can rather add to the can of worms since folks want to compare one car against another tested on different rigs / measurements / conditions...

..yet everyone seems to accept the figures are OK when quoted for yank motors wink

Unfortunately most folks seem to be wanting figures to justify their opinions, rather than forming opinions based on the figures hehe

Meatball

Original Poster:

1,638 posts

241 months

Tuesday 7th September 2010
quotequote all
That makes interesting reading, my last dyno was 288.5 at the wheels which was converted to 313 at the flywheel? which is approx 8% drivetrain loss..
Not that it matters hehe

JR

14,332 posts

289 months

Tuesday 7th September 2010
quotequote all
Jonny_uk said:
It calculates this loss on run down by measureing relative friction without engine enagaged, e.g. in neutral,
So how do you know what the frictinal loss is at the engine speed at which you measured the torque?

JR

14,332 posts

289 months

Tuesday 7th September 2010
quotequote all
spend said:
JR said:
spend said:
Possibly quite a few? IIRC V8D run in their engines on the dyno, quite a valuable pre-delivery service which little seems to mentioned of?
That's interesting. I wonder whether a few owners could post the readings to allow some real figures to be seen for once.
... but isn't that what creates the confusion with TVR figures... Accepted standards for engine dyno testing allow removal of ancils, external water pumping/cooling, funky exhausts...
If people with V8D posted some figures explaining what they were this would give a good bench mark to put the other figures into context.

spend said:
Can rather add to the can of worms since folks want to compare one car against another tested on different rigs / measurements / conditions...

..yet everyone seems to accept the figures are OK when quoted for yank motors wink

Unfortunately most folks seem to be wanting figures to justify their opinions, rather than forming opinions based on the figures hehe
Whilst not forgetting that the real use of a RR is to try to maximise the performance of a particular engine the comparison of bench figures to RR figures does have a passing interest to car fanatics, of which I believe there are a few left on PH.

spend

12,581 posts

282 months

Tuesday 7th September 2010
quotequote all
Don't disagree at all, it's just that this is one of those internet things where the noise makes the tune inaudible hehe

At the end of the day I still prefer an accelerometer on the road as a final measurement to evaluate mods, even though I luckily have access to a couple of RR's that allow a bit more scope than just power runs & mapping wink Selecting how / when / where you evaluate specific engine mods is harder than thinking them up in the first place if you really want to avoid being a placebo rofl I suspect few are worried about these things, and just want to prove they are 'swimming in the shoal' which is when all the different measurement methods just create confusion and argument?

steinhold

42 posts

197 months

Tuesday 7th September 2010
quotequote all
Hi,

An interesting topic, I am not much good at Physics but I am wondering if changing the diamiter of the tyre's from 16 inch to 18 inch could change the bhp readings obtained on a rolling road test ?

Chimpaholic

9,637 posts

210 months

Tuesday 7th September 2010
quotequote all
steinhold said:
Hi,

An interesting topic, I am not much good at Physics but I am wondering if changing the diamiter of the tyre's from 16 inch to 18 inch could change the bhp readings obtained on a rolling road test ?
Correct me if I'm wrong, but isn't the dyno just measuring the car's ability to overcome the dyno's own predetermined resistance?

Surely changing the wheel size will have no effect at all.

However fitting 10" Mini wheels will give you massive on road acceleration up to a maximum top speed of 48 mph laugh

WARNING: Cornering and looks may also be adversely affected with this mod

Edited by Chimpaholic on Tuesday 7th September 14:56

CHGRIFF

326 posts

283 months

Tuesday 7th September 2010
quotequote all
When testing engine performance we have found good correlation between Rolling Road, Engine Dyno and Road appraisal. For TVR V8 we use 21.8%, this being added to the "At wheel figure" for Flywheel calculation. If calculating in reverse, with determined Flywheel figure, this should be reduced by 17.9% to get the "At wheel figure".
Variables such as ambient temperature, humidity and altitude have a significant bearing on outright performance. Many dyno’s do not consider altitude, however if on a Rolling Road day, all cars are assessed using the same criterion.
21.8% is the power needed to overcome drive train losses from the cylinder to the road surface, not engine power loss. It may be of interest to know the single component contributing the highest loss are the tyres. Pump them up and save money, but you might hit a wall if doing so.

spend

12,581 posts

282 months

Tuesday 7th September 2010
quotequote all
Getting a dyno to produce 2 runs back to back that are exactly the same seems to be problematical??, I do get a tiny bit skeptical when told the roll down works, they automatically calibrate to their weather stations... wink Not to say they are not accurate just that it is harder to make 2+2=4 than appears at face value IYSWIM.