Camshaft Woes
Camshaft Woes
Author
Discussion

Pacman1972

Original Poster:

327 posts

293 months

Friday 10th September 2010
quotequote all
Oh what to do?
So my lil baby 500 chim which I've just had for a couple of weeks went in for a service today and I got told the camshaft needs replacing at a cost of around £2,500 eek

I've no doubt that it needs doing, the guys who have the car are legendry in these forums and are clearly one of the best in the business and will no doubt do an awesome job. I'm told I'll end up with a better tuned engine pumping out more horses than usual and who can complain at that cool

Obviously it needs to be done and I'm not looking for any shortcuts but do I really need to spend £2500 bearing in mind that I just use the car for burbling around on sunny afternoons? Should I just take the plunge and spend the 2.5K or shop around?

Anyone have good / bad experiences of having the chamshaf replaced?

Alexdaredevilz

5,697 posts

210 months

Friday 10th September 2010
quotequote all
Pacman1972 said:
Oh what to do?
So my lil baby 500 chim which I've just had for a couple of weeks went in for a service today and I got told the camshaft needs replacing at a cost of around £2,500 eek

I've no doubt that it needs doing, the guys who have the car are legendry in these forums and are clearly one of the best in the business and will no doubt do an awesome job. I'm told I'll end up with a better tuned engine pumping out more horses than usual and who can complain at that cool

Obviously it needs to be done and I'm not looking for any shortcuts but do I really need to spend £2500 bearing in mind that I just use the car for burbling around on sunny afternoons? Should I just take the plunge and spend the 2.5K or shop around?

Anyone have good / bad experiences of having the chamshaf replaced?
For that amount it would be cheaper to have a few evening college lessons and do it your self, its not really that hard


bigdods

7,175 posts

258 months

Friday 10th September 2010
quotequote all
I have learned never to trust anyone having had some less than happy experiences with some of the specialists everyone raves about.

Before you do anything ask them why they think it needs replacing and post the diagnosis up on here. Also call a few other places and get some comparative prices. There are many cam options and prices , you need to be sure that you are doing the right thing and that you arent spending more than necessary.

I have been using topcats for several years now and would recommend that you give warren there a call to at least talk about the diagnosis and options before you do anything.

Simon says

19,466 posts

252 months

Friday 10th September 2010
quotequote all
Quinny said:
Pacman1972 said:
Oh what to do?
So my lil baby 500 chim which I've just had for a couple of weeks went in for a service today and I got told the camshaft needs replacing at a cost of around £2,500 eek

I've no doubt that it needs doing, the guys who have the car are legendry
Well they certainly quote legendary prices thats for sure....

I'd be Speaking to Rob at V8 Developments...
eek definitely to expensive.

Pacman1972

Original Poster:

327 posts

293 months

Friday 10th September 2010
quotequote all
Alexdaredevilz said:
For that amount it would be cheaper to have a few evening college lessons and do it your self, its not really that hard
I like that idea idea I've not worked on an engine before, but I am technically minded and a bit of a perfectionist - I dont plan on using the car over the winter so could be an opportunity to have some fun and learn something.

Pacman1972

Original Poster:

327 posts

293 months

Friday 10th September 2010
quotequote all
bigdods said:
Before you do anything ask them why they think it needs replacing and post the diagnosis up on here. Also call a few other places and get some comparative prices. There are many cam options and prices , you need to be sure that you are doing the right thing and that you arent spending more than necessary.
Thanks for the tip! - I was told it sounds like its "running on 7.5 cylinders" - It's actually been driving fine recently although it did sound "a little bit" tappety/blowy but nothing too unusual. Oil pressure and Temp seem spot on smile
The only things I've noticed is once it did take a while for the all the cylinders to kick, it is a bit thirsty and it the idle jumped to 1800RPM a couple of times but settled back down to 800 after a few seconds. I've only had the car a couple of weeks so I'm still learning whats normal. Obviously something not quite right though frown

I'm wondering what sort of price should I be expecting for a camshaft replacement? Like you say I'll do some calling around.

winters

217 posts

222 months

Pacman1972

Original Poster:

327 posts

293 months

Friday 10th September 2010
quotequote all
winters said:
I paid 1300 for parts and fitting including:

Standard 500 high lift cam
16 Hydraulic lifters
Duplex timing chain
New valley gasket and seals
Front cover gasket
Front crank seal
Rocker cover gaskets
Oil + filter
New coolant

Posts I've read on here suggest this sort of money is pricey for a cam replacement.
Jeepers - Now that sounds more like it biggrin

bigdods

7,175 posts

258 months

Saturday 11th September 2010
quotequote all
Pacman1972 said:
bigdods said:
Before you do anything ask them why they think it needs replacing and post the diagnosis up on here. Also call a few other places and get some comparative prices. There are many cam options and prices , you need to be sure that you are doing the right thing and that you arent spending more than necessary.
Thanks for the tip! - I was told it sounds like its "running on 7.5 cylinders" - It's actually been driving fine recently although it did sound "a little bit" tappety/blowy but nothing too unusual. Oil pressure and Temp seem spot on smile
The only things I've noticed is once it did take a while for the all the cylinders to kick, it is a bit thirsty and it the idle jumped to 1800RPM a couple of times but settled back down to 800 after a few seconds. I've only had the car a couple of weeks so I'm still learning whats normal. Obviously something not quite right though frown

I'm wondering what sort of price should I be expecting for a camshaft replacement? Like you say I'll do some calling around.
I'd be checking the plug leads, extenders, coil & amp first. Oh and get a fault code reader on it it *might* show something up. Tapping can be as simple as a leaking exhaust gasket.

It may be the cams need replacing , but it may be something a lot simpler.

If I were you i'd get it down to a rolling road , for ~ £80 you'll get a graph showing power, torque and emissions , then at least you know where you are and can work up from that point. Be a bit of a bugger if you had new cams fitted and it didnt improve.

I am not an expert but IME always get a second opinion if you are going to spend more than a grand.

Pacman1972

Original Poster:

327 posts

293 months

Saturday 11th September 2010
quotequote all
Thanks for all the advice guys - I thought it sounded expensive but being new to the tvr scene I simply didnt know what the norms are.
Nice to be learning from such a passionate community. read

ray_von

3,067 posts

283 months

Saturday 11th September 2010
quotequote all
£2500 sounds a lot, but also beware of other firms that are 'legendry' on these forums wink

Edited by ray_von on Saturday 11th September 22:06

Podie

46,649 posts

306 months

Saturday 11th September 2010
quotequote all
Agreed - seems steep.

As for legendary... what metrics do people use for saying who is good and who isn't? Get several opinions and quotes and make your own judgement.

v8 racing

2,064 posts

282 months

Sunday 12th September 2010
quotequote all
well basing it on 6hrs labour time and taking in the costs of the parts that makes the labour £358 an hour!!

HiAsAKite

2,559 posts

278 months

Sunday 12th September 2010
quotequote all
Just add to the others, thats at least double the price I would expect for a cam from a TVR specialist who really knows what they'e doing, you sure they're just quoting to changing the cam?- that sort of quote for just a cam would be reputational suicide I would have thought...

Pacman1972

Original Poster:

327 posts

293 months

Sunday 12th September 2010
quotequote all
HiAsAKite said:
Just add to the others, thats at least double the price I would expect for a cam from a TVR specialist who really knows what they'e doing, you sure they're just quoting to changing the cam?- that sort of quote for just a cam would be reputational suicide I would have thought...
That's a good point - I'll get a list and find out exactly what's included. I was told they go above and beyond what is usually done to make it perfect. For me though its like a good bottle of Red - put it side by side with a cheap from tesco's and I'd be hard pressed to tell you the difference!! drunkbiggrin

Bodmin

596 posts

229 months

Sunday 12th September 2010
quotequote all
Pacman1972 said:
HiAsAKite said:
Just add to the others, thats at least double the price I would expect for a cam from a TVR specialist who really knows what they'e doing, you sure they're just quoting to changing the cam?- that sort of quote for just a cam would be reputational suicide I would have thought...
That's a good point - I'll get a list and find out exactly what's included. I was told they go above and beyond what is usually done to make it perfect. For me though its like a good bottle of Red - put it side by side with a cheap from tesco's and I'd be hard pressed to tell you the difference!! drunkbiggrin
I'll hazard a guess as to the extras;

Remove heads,recut valve seats/valves to 'special' three angle design, gasflow heads, renew valve springs,duplex & vernier timing gears, set up on rolling road....approx 16hrs scratchchin

If the quote is where I suspect it is from I wouldn't rely on any warranty....they can change their company name quicker than you can get a claim in laugh

Bodders

quattrophenia

1,103 posts

229 months

Sunday 12th September 2010
quotequote all
Pacman1972 said:
Alexdaredevilz said:
For that amount it would be cheaper to have a few evening college lessons and do it your self, its not really that hard
I like that idea idea I've not worked on an engine before, but I am technically minded and a bit of a perfectionist - I dont plan on using the car over the winter so could be an opportunity to have some fun and learn something.
I am starting my car course at my local college on Wednesday. How else can you learn such skills unless you do an apprentiship etc. Most garages wouldn't allow you into their workshops even if you did express a genuine interest in learning how things worked.
I have been warned to expect to get dirty which really sold the course to me
eek !!

topsparks

1,202 posts

278 months

Sunday 12th September 2010
quotequote all
Buy an old engine from ebay and have a go stripping it yourself ,I,m taking a p38 lump that i pulled out of a skip at a LR dealers with a slipped liner to air cadets tomorrow night to teach them propulsion as its a damn site more interesting than watching a power point for hours!and they would rather be getting their hands dirty.

roysum

961 posts

220 months

Sunday 12th September 2010
quotequote all
Steve (OP), if the car is not your daily driver, you can take your time, ask the experts (there's plenty on here)and actually enjoy doing it. There's a lot of satisfaction when you have done something like that yourself, and know it's done properly. You may even get carried away like I did and start opening up ports and tweaking here and there.
I don't know where you are in the 'South East' but If you are stuck for tools, dial guages etc I'm sure I could help mate !

Roy

WokingWedger

1,030 posts

236 months

Monday 13th September 2010
quotequote all
Just a little warning, replacing the cam may not be that difficult, but you should check the cam brgs as well. Mine were just starting to break up, and that meant the engine had to come out, which meant I could not carry on, and had to have the car taken away to a garage with suitable equipment and space (which I dont have)