leven droplinks... grease or no grease?
leven droplinks... grease or no grease?
Author
Discussion

Pupp

Original Poster:

13,044 posts

303 months

Saturday 18th September 2010
quotequote all
Got a funky set of front droplnks turn up from Jules this morning. Q is that as they hve zerk fittings for greasing but also have tight rubber covers over the business ends, are they supposed to be greased or dry? One school of thought says grease attracts/retains crud and Im unsure whether the rubber will degrade if filled with grease...

Could wait until next week so I can ask Leven but fancy doing tomorrow if anyone knows the gen...

Nice product by the way; as well as being heavy stainless, have a extra twisting articulation on the heads that my existing (knackered) rose jointed ones don't have

hiltonig

3,153 posts

239 months

Sunday 19th September 2010
quotequote all
Could you post a pic after fitting please

Chimpaholic

9,637 posts

210 months

Sunday 19th September 2010
quotequote all
I am 100% sure the rose joints will be correctly lubricated when the come from Leven's supplier.

In fact when I fitted mine I remove the rubber boots to inspect the rose joints and they seem to have been lubricated with a clear light grease.

(Looks like petroleum jelly)

As you said the quality of these drop links is fantastic.

I looked at a few options including the standard part when choosing a replacement for my knackered drop links.

To me the difference was the Leven drop links look and feel race bred when the other options look like toy shop cast offs.

The Leven links are heavy duty beautifully engineered parts that have obviously been designed by someone who understands what they are doing and the loads they need to cope with.

Once all your bushes and top/bottom joints are sorted, in my opinion the Leven links are the best value for money suspension modification you can do.

The four links took me just over one hour to fit including jacking the car, removing and re-fitting the road wheels.

The handling benefits were immediate.

I must get some better snaps of mine to share with you all.

Pupp

Original Poster:

13,044 posts

303 months

Sunday 19th September 2010
quotequote all
Ok, going to correct something here, now I've had the covers off. They are conventional rose joints ( but good quality) and don't have any additional swivel as I first thought, was just a product of the way they are aligned relative to each other. Bigger joints than my existing ones...

chimaera1855

334 posts

199 months

Sunday 19th September 2010
quotequote all
how will u compare to Steve Heath's????

Pupp

Original Poster:

13,044 posts

303 months

Sunday 19th September 2010
quotequote all
In terms of design and structure, theyre essentially the same, although the Leven ones are loads beefier (bigger, stainless bars and fixings), plus weather protected.

I expect they will function as the SH did when new, ie well. I hope they last longer however but time will tell

shpub

8,507 posts

303 months

Sunday 19th September 2010
quotequote all
Pupp said:
In terms of design and structure, theyre essentially the same, although the Leven ones are loads beefier (bigger, stainless bars and fixings), plus weather protected.

I expect they will function as the SH did when new, ie well. I hope they last longer however but time will tell
Well if you are Gary from Kettering, you bought the drop links over 4 years ago which is a pretty good life. I can supply replacement rose joints if needed.

As for the designs: there are some important differences.

I don't use stainless as it is not recommended for use on suspension components or fixings as it is brittle. It's the same reason why I don't supply stainless suspension bolt kits.

The Leven rears still have the bush which twists the rear wishbone mounting plate.

The Leven weather protection is needed because the rose joints they have used require regular re-greasing as they have a metal to metal bearing that relies on constant regreasing to prevent wear. This is why they have the grease nipple. If they are not re-greased they will wear pretty quickly - a few hundred miles is not uncommon from some reports I've seen with this type of rose joint.

The normal grease used is a grease that will withstand high pressure and this stuff is normally teflon loaded to help lubricate it. It usually has to be injected in under pressure to get between the bearing surfaces. BTW having grease come out of the nipple does not indicate that the joint is lubricated but more that the nipple has siezed or that there is insufficient pressure to force the grease in. There is an old farmer's trick is to let the joint run dry so that it wears and makes a small gap and then repack with grease. This reduces the pressure needed to get the grease into the joint. However the downside is that the gap means that the grease squeezes out and needs regular re greasing. Not unusual for this to be only a 1000 miles or so.

As the grease comes out under the pressure from use and particularly when it gets hot, a boot is needed to prevent the grease from attracting dirt and crud which can find it's way into the joint and cause it to wear.

I have found a set of boots that will fit without reducing the joint movement which is the main problem I have come across with the rubber boots I have used previously. I can offer them as an option but this puts me into a bit of a dilemma in that I have seen a lot of evidence that adding boots actually accelerates wear as it traps moisture etc in the boot. Water can trickle round the thread into the boot in particular. The only way to stop this is to pack the joints with grease and then regularly check and repack as necessary. If this is not done, then the chances are that the boots can make the problem worse rather than better.




chimaera1855

334 posts

199 months

Sunday 19th September 2010
quotequote all
tks Steve to explain things so i can understand.i am really planning to get urs but i am doing other work and stuff on my car now.but it is on my list of must have things.cheers mate

Pupp

Original Poster:

13,044 posts

303 months

Monday 20th September 2010
quotequote all
shpub said:
Well if you are Gary from Kettering, you bought the drop links over 4 years ago which is a pretty good life. I can supply replacement rose joints if needed.
They've been on the car that long, true. However, it is also the case that they were 'noisy' within a year, had noticeable play in the second, and were an advisory for the last MOT (Nov 09). The car is used in all weathers and I did consider refurbing with new joints (we discussed this at the Growl) but feel weather protection is the way to go hence buying Leven this time around.

shpub said:
As for the designs: there are some important differences.

I don't use stainless as it is not recommended for use on suspension components or fixings as it is brittle. It's the same reason why I don't supply stainless suspension bolt kits.
Not sure what grade ally you use Steve and I'm not a metallurgist in any event but I think I know which my money would be on in any strength test that could be dreamt up just based on the comparative dimensions of the components, brittleness or not.

shpub said:
The Leven rears still have the bush which twists the rear wishbone mounting plate.
This may be so, I cannot say as I don't run a rear ARB and have no intention of doing so. My comments related to the fronts (only).

shpub said:
The Leven weather protection is needed because the rose joints they have used require regular re-greasing as they have a metal to metal bearing that relies on constant regreasing to prevent wear. This is why they have the grease nipple. If they are not re-greased they will wear pretty quickly - a few hundred miles is not uncommon from some reports I've seen with this type of rose joint.

The normal grease used is a grease that will withstand high pressure and this stuff is normally teflon loaded to help lubricate it. It usually has to be injected in under pressure to get between the bearing surfaces. BTW having grease come out of the nipple does not indicate that the joint is lubricated but more that the nipple has siezed or that there is insufficient pressure to force the grease in. There is an old farmer's trick is to let the joint run dry so that it wears and makes a small gap and then repack with grease. This reduces the pressure needed to get the grease into the joint. However the downside is that the gap means that the grease squeezes out and needs regular re greasing. Not unusual for this to be only a 1000 miles or so.

As the grease comes out under the pressure from use and particularly when it gets hot, a boot is needed to prevent the grease from attracting dirt and crud which can find it's way into the joint and cause it to wear.
The greasing issue is precisely why I posted this thread, based upon my experience described above. I'm not sure if the reports you mention are accessible on the net or whether they are privy only to the rose joint cognescentii but I have used joints with zerk fittings on many applications in the motorcycle world (perhaps cleaner environment given the nature of the bikes concerned) and have not noticed them wearing any more quickly than the dry sort on my SH links, or at all in fact now I come to think of it.

shpub said:
I have found a set of boots that will fit without reducing the joint movement which is the main problem I have come across with the rubber boots I have used previously. I can offer them as an option but this puts me into a bit of a dilemma in that I have seen a lot of evidence that adding boots actually accelerates wear as it traps moisture etc in the boot. Water can trickle round the thread into the boot in particular. The only way to stop this is to pack the joints with grease and then regularly check and repack as necessary. If this is not done, then the chances are that the boots can make the problem worse rather than better.
I remember discussing the boots restricting movement with you too; I was therefore pleasantly surprised to find no obvious restriction on the Leven ones when to hand. So much so, I did initially think the joint was mechanically different in some way hence the correction I added when I later popped the covers off and discovered this was not the case. It may be you are correct but I suspect the job is a better one for a barrier between the joint and road dirt (after all, suspension ball joints, track road ends, and CV joints all benefit from such shielding in a similar environment) and I view this purchase as a definite upgrade until it proves not to be.



shpub

8,507 posts

303 months

Monday 20th September 2010
quotequote all
Pupp said:
shpub said:
Well if you are Gary from Kettering, you bought the drop links over 4 years ago which is a pretty good life. I can supply replacement rose joints if needed.
They've been on the car that long, true. However, it is also the case that they were 'noisy' within a year, had noticeable play in the second, and were an advisory for the last MOT (Nov 09). The car is used in all weathers and I did consider refurbing with new joints (we discussed this at the Growl) but feel weather protection is the way to go hence buying Leven this time around.
To be honest, it could have simply be a case of nipping up the bolt as the bolt does not act as the pivot but as a clamp. If the bolt doesn't clamp correctly, the rose joint moves on the bolt and this feels exactly like play.

shpub said:
As for the designs: there are some important differences.

I don't use stainless as it is not recommended for use on suspension components or fixings as it is brittle. It's the same reason why I don't supply stainless suspension bolt kits.
Pupp said:
Not sure what grade ally you use Steve and I'm not a metallurgist in any event but I think I know which my money would be on in any strength test that could be dreamt up just based on the comparative dimensions of the components, brittleness or not.
Its not the strength but the properties when the material is deformed. I actually did some strength analysis on the ally yokes and they are not the weak point. The actual weak point are the rose joints and the attachements i.e the plates but not in the normal way you would think off. The rose joints in particular are about 20 times the load rating of the arb movement. The problem comes when the joints are locked out and there is stress on the joint and fixings. The fixings etc are all within spec but as soon as a deforming load is placed then you want a material that deforms rather than fractures. Stainless tends to fracture where steel will bend. I have fractured 3/4 inch rod ends with loads that were about 1/50th of the specified load because the load was applied in the wrong way and tried to deform the rod end. It doesn't take much load to break a joint if it is applied in a way that the joint is not designed for.

It was this brittleness I was referring to rather than overall tensile strength. There are other issues such as galling with stainless.


shpub said:
The Leven weather protection is needed because the rose joints they have used require regular re-greasing as they have a metal to metal bearing that relies on constant regreasing to prevent wear. This is why they have the grease nipple. If they are not re-greased they will wear pretty quickly - a few hundred miles is not uncommon from some reports I've seen with this type of rose joint.

The normal grease used is a grease that will withstand high pressure and this stuff is normally teflon loaded to help lubricate it. It usually has to be injected in under pressure to get between the bearing surfaces. BTW having grease come out of the nipple does not indicate that the joint is lubricated but more that the nipple has siezed or that there is insufficient pressure to force the grease in. There is an old farmer's trick is to let the joint run dry so that it wears and makes a small gap and then repack with grease. This reduces the pressure needed to get the grease into the joint. However the downside is that the gap means that the grease squeezes out and needs regular re greasing. Not unusual for this to be only a 1000 miles or so.

As the grease comes out under the pressure from use and particularly when it gets hot, a boot is needed to prevent the grease from attracting dirt and crud which can find it's way into the joint and cause it to wear.
Pupp said:
The greasing issue is precisely why I posted this thread, based upon my experience described above. I'm not sure if the reports you mention are accessible on the net or whether they are privy only to the rose joint cognescentii but I have used joints with zerk fittings on many applications in the motorcycle world (perhaps cleaner environment given the nature of the bikes concerned) and have not noticed them wearing any more quickly than the dry sort on my SH links, or at all in fact now I come to think of it.
No, there are plenty of reports on web - google heim joints greasing. One particular report from a guy that builds and races desert 4x4s found that with boots the joints failed within 250 miles and without they didn't. What happened was the sand got through the boots and trapped it in place. Running without meant that he didn't have any problems. Equally someone found that running zerk joints without the boots caused problems with joints lasting only a few months. He reckons that the only way forward is to fit disc shields inside the boots to provide a double layer.

Certainly one major factor is how clean the environment is and how accessible the joints are to grease them as but
the general consensus from the stuff I've seen is that boots are not the universal fix in every case and joints with zerks need regularly greasing and levels of protection that the teflon lined joints do not .

shpub said:
I have found a set of boots that will fit without reducing the joint movement which is the main problem I have come across with the rubber boots I have used previously. I can offer them as an option but this puts me into a bit of a dilemma in that I have seen a lot of evidence that adding boots actually accelerates wear as it traps moisture etc in the boot. Water can trickle round the thread into the boot in particular. The only way to stop this is to pack the joints with grease and then regularly check and repack as necessary. If this is not done, then the chances are that the boots can make the problem worse rather than better.
Pupp said:
I remember discussing the boots restricting movement with you too; I was therefore pleasantly surprised to find no obvious restriction on the Leven ones when to hand. So much so, I did initially think the joint was mechanically different in some way hence the correction I added when I later popped the covers off and discovered this was not the case. It may be you are correct but I suspect the job is a better one for a barrier between the joint and road dirt (after all, suspension ball joints, track road ends, and CV joints all benefit from such shielding in a similar environment) and I view this purchase as a definite upgrade until it proves not to be.
One type of boot that I have looked at uses a special collar and a larger size rose joint to help with the articulation. The collar allows the right size bolt to be fitted into the oversize rose joint. The leven product looks very similar to these. However not all rose joints have the same amount of articulation. Some can have as little as 7 or 11 degrees and these joints tend not to suffer with this type of boot. Other joints with greater articulation are restricted. This doesn't seem much but the articulation angles are important because of the variation of the wishbone and ARB mounting plates. I found that I needed a greater level of articulation to provide enough margin to cope with the TVR "tolerances". This is why I have struggled with finding suitable protection as everything I have tried so far compromises the design.
One other issue is the width of the assembly which causes greater offset and more articulation to compensate. The problem is that this is very much car dependent and on how the units are fitted.

As I said I have now found some suitable boots that do not affect the articulation so I will be offering them as a option if people want them. The problem is and this is the dilemma I am in, I am not totally convinced that they are the universal fix that first impressions or what ever gives. I know that ball joints etc all have shielding but equally I have come across joints that have corroded despite the rubber protection. Certainly if the boot gets damaged then the joints seem to wear extremely quickly. Modern joints also use teflon or nylon liner for lubrication

To be honest I am just wary of selling something as a solution without being 100% confident that it is the solution. Having seen reports of boots holding water/crud, I did a simple test last night.

I took an assembly and held it under the tap in a gentle stream of water for 30 seconds. When I stripped the assembly down There was water inside the boot. I suspect it got in through the thread as these are virtually impossible to seal off. This really worries me because the last thing I want is water and crud staying in the boot or to give the impression that using a boot will provide a complete seal. Based on this simple test and other reports, my conclusion is while it may reduce the amount of water and crud that the joint sees, it will retain any that gets through and this will accumulate so that the joint eventually runs in its own bath.

The only way around this I can see is to pack the boot with grease which does mean that the assembly needs to be checked regularly.

The only way I can resolve this is to have boots as an option, with a detailed description of the pros and cons along with my recommendations of the best way to look after the droplinks and let the buyer decide which way they want to go.
sorted out the quoting

Edited by shpub on Monday 20th September 21:23