Bought the wrong car
Bought the wrong car
Author
Discussion

ewan221

Original Poster:

1,219 posts

217 months

Sunday 19th September 2010
quotequote all
After about 6 months of looking for a Chimaera (or possibly XK8) ended up buying a Boxster S. Having had it now for a few months now regretting not going for my original choice.

So plan is probally look to sell the boxster after xmas and look for a Chimaera after that.

I remember a while ago someone on here was selling his Chimaera and looking for a boxster - anyone know if he get sorted ?

If anyone thinking baout selling up early next year let me know please

S7Paul

2,103 posts

265 months

Sunday 19th September 2010
quotequote all
Just out of interest, apart from finding it hard to tell which end is which, what was wrong with the Boxster? A few years ago I had a similar dilemma (Chim v Boxster S v S2000). Luckily I went for the V8. Hope you find a good one.

ewan221

Original Poster:

1,219 posts

217 months

Sunday 19th September 2010
quotequote all
S7Paul said:
Just out of interest, apart from finding it hard to tell which end is which, what was wrong with the Boxster? A few years ago I had a similar dilemma (Chim v Boxster S v S2000). Luckily I went for the V8. Hope you find a good one.
TBH not that much wrong with it really, The front end looks great but not so sure about the back, very good drive but most of the power delivery is 4000 revs so you have to work the gearbox but feels very very solid for a convertible. It is though quite common, was sitting in a row of 3 at a roundabout yesterday

Its really more down to fact that I still spend time looking at the classified telling me I didnt but right car

Mikeoupe

303 posts

252 months

Sunday 19th September 2010
quotequote all
Similarly a few years ago I bought a 996 which I lost interest in very quickly and traded it in after just 10 months, it was a brilliant but utterly soulless car. Six months into Chim ownership and I still peak into the garage to make sure it's still there, I absolutely love it! and don't plan to change it for anything other than another TVR.

Jasandjules

72,694 posts

260 months

Sunday 19th September 2010
quotequote all
S7Paul said:
what was wrong with the Boxster?
It ain't a TVR Chimaera.........

The TVR is faster, looks sexier and gives awesome aural sex too........

AlexanderV8

1,498 posts

234 months

Sunday 19th September 2010
quotequote all
ewan221 said:
I remember a while ago someone on here was selling his Chimaera and looking for a boxster - anyone know if he get sorted ?
I think it was T_Pot you must have remembered. He got himself sorted I'm sorry to say hehe. There was a thread where we tried to advise him not to do it & gave him 6 months max smile

mikey76

20 posts

195 months

Monday 20th September 2010
quotequote all
Im thinking of selling my Chimaera for a boxster, but would have to be as good as my car though.

justyr

337 posts

243 months

Monday 20th September 2010
quotequote all
My 2 euros worth would be this:

Walking up street on Saturday eve, spotted a couple of yoofs out in Mummy's Boxster waiting for the traffic light drag race. So, I waited to see what it had to offer. The answer was not alot I am afraid.

My mate's 450 Chimaera could practically wrinkle tarmac - used to make me giggle uncontrollably. Now _that's_ a car - I'd go get one and learn it, at least you can say you had a TVR once!

Just IMO
J

Jasandjules

72,694 posts

260 months

Monday 20th September 2010
quotequote all
mikey76 said:
Im thinking of selling my Chimaera for a boxster, but would have to be as good as my car though.
Impossible.......

Stiggly

33 posts

195 months

Monday 20th September 2010
quotequote all
DON'T DO IT! I had a Boxster 3.2 S and spent the whole time wondering about what to get next. It was just 'unloveable' in complete contrast to ALL the British sports cars I've owned. Anyway, a Porsche should be air cooled shouldn't it?

Markh

2,781 posts

306 months

Tuesday 21st September 2010
quotequote all
mikey76 said:
Im thinking of selling my Chimaera for a boxster, but would have to be as good as my car though.
Just done excactly the same, i had two Chimaera's over the past 11 years, the olny Boxster drawbacks are , lack of speed,too many of them on the roads and snob value. from A to B on undulating back road the Boxster gives me much more confidence, is a much better bet.

I do miss the the TVR and may buy another one day

jdl1981

299 posts

214 months

Wednesday 22nd September 2010
quotequote all
Chimaera's are good cars, boxsters are good cars. With the Porsche you get very solid build quality, the complete opposite on the TVR. With the TVR you get a great soundtrack, the porsche quite a nice one! Not alot of difference in performance between 3.2s and 400/450, maybe a bit of a noticable difference side by side with a 500. You may or may not not get on with build quality of the TVR coming from the Porsche but if it's a weekend car who cares.

The boxster will get a bashing on this forum, if it doesn't have a TVR badge on it then it will get ripped to shreds - no matter how much of a more quality product it is!!

The TVR is an experience - what kind of experience depends on how well you buy. the porsche may be seen by some as the safer, boring bet but it's not a bad sports car is it?! It's a matter of taste, both have pros and cons,both are great cars they just give their thrills in a different way

ewan221

Original Poster:

1,219 posts

217 months

Wednesday 22nd September 2010
quotequote all
I have had the boxster now for 3 months and while Im looking to get rid of fo a chimaera I would in no way say its a bad car and to be honest its not exactly a slow car.

It does lack a bit of character and is very common on the roads but all in all its a good roadster.

I still want a V8 though :-)

saxmund

364 posts

266 months

Wednesday 22nd September 2010
quotequote all
I test drove a Boxster 3.2S. I thought it was a sensible idea, get something more practical for everyday driving and a bit easier to handle for someone who stacked a 400 in 2008 and hadn't quite got his fast car confidence back.

I can't say I hated it, but it underwhelmed me. It seemed to be fairly fast, we got up to 60 quite easily but you didn't know it was doing it. If you got up to 4000 rpm you got a sort of OK noise from the engine, but not before then. The interior seemed plasticky and built to a price - and that was the 3.2 which is supposed to have a higher level of trim. No feel from the steering and no nice snick when you changed gear. And I disliked the driving position - I am quite short and it wasn't really adjustable enough.

The Boxster salesman reckoned TVR drivers just get them for the sound they make. Well, it's a point of view I suppose. In the end I got a 450, it makes a magnificent sound, and after 4 months I can say it is f***ing fast. And although I have to stretch slightly for the pedals in my work shoes (I'm OK in anything with a slightly thicker sole) I think it is the most comfortable, most ergonomically designed car cockpit I have ever sat in.

All I can say is - it does what I want from a car. At least until I can afford that mythical Mark 1 Tuscan with the Speed Six "issues" fixed.

Stiggly

33 posts

195 months

Thursday 23rd September 2010
quotequote all
The Boxster I had was made in Finland from lumpen German designed 'modules' and nasty cheap plastics. The seats were hopeless. You can't see the engine. You can't really hear the engine most of the time. It's clearly designed (very cleverly) to be sporty but still enable you to commute to work everyday, and behaves horribly like a 'normal' car at low revs. (as does the Honda S2000). As for reliability and longevity in water cooled Porsches (except the wonderful and hugely underrated 944/968, which is better to drive than the Boxster) all I can say is, be careful what you buy. Unless it's been METICULOUSLY maintained, a used Porsche can be an infinitely greater money pit than a Chimaera could ever be. I recently had a PPI done on a '98 996 on a forecourt at £15k and was advise that the work required to rescue it would cost around £8,000. My low mileage, shouty, V8 powered, uncommon, handsome from any angle, Chimaera cost about that, and I can still afford to run an old Focus to go shopping and drive to work. Not to mention the fact that virtually any competent mechanic can service the engine, and not at £55.00/ hour plus. It's a no-brainer, isn't it?

haircutmike

22,511 posts

235 months

Thursday 23rd September 2010
quotequote all
Mmmm, the jury should consider everything.

Drove a 3.4S for two days, not got the carisma of a tiv but, you can cover ground faster, magnifceant without trying, undeniably quick without the drama.

This one was top quality and when I gave it back and picked up the chim, well it felt like sh*t for the first ten miles.

Early and smaller models for women and poseurs, late 3.4's, you have to try one and drive it fast!!!!!!!

Just had a quick look, we must be in a recession, the best model is getting affordable!

http://cgi.ebay.co.uk/PORSCHE-BOXSTER-S-3-4-2006-5...

Edited by haircutmike on Thursday 23 September 07:24

saxmund

364 posts

266 months

Thursday 23rd September 2010
quotequote all
We're not really talking like-for-like with that one, though, are we? 5 years newer than even the most recent Chim and twice the price of a decent 450.

If someone has £10K-ish to hand I would say a Chim is better value. Especially if you are posting on a TVR forum: you obviously like that sort of thing. Loud, a bit rough round the edges, fast, relatively rare and imaginitive design.

If I'd had an extra 10K to spend I would have been looking at 996s or 993s and Tuscans (or 3.2 Carreras and if necessary leaving 5 grand in the bank for a top end rebuild). Bet I would have got a Tuscan though.

jdl1981

299 posts

214 months

Thursday 23rd September 2010
quotequote all
Stiggly said:
The Boxster I had was made in Finland from lumpen German designed 'modules' and nasty cheap plastics. The seats were hopeless. You can't see the engine. You can't really hear the engine most of the time. It's clearly designed (very cleverly) to be sporty but still enable you to commute to work everyday, and behaves horribly like a 'normal' car at low revs. (as does the Honda S2000). As for reliability and longevity in water cooled Porsches (except the wonderful and hugely underrated 944/968, which is better to drive than the Boxster) all I can say is, be careful what you buy. Unless it's been METICULOUSLY maintained, a used Porsche can be an infinitely greater money pit than a Chimaera could ever be. I recently had a PPI done on a '98 996 on a forecourt at £15k and was advise that the work required to rescue it would cost around £8,000. My low mileage, shouty, V8 powered, uncommon, handsome from any angle, Chimaera cost about that, and I can still afford to run an old Focus to go shopping and drive to work. Not to mention the fact that virtually any competent mechanic can service the engine, and not at £55.00/ hour plus. It's a no-brainer, isn't it?
i agree about potential bills on 996's but aren't they a bit more complex than a boxster? And lets not forget it is easy to buy what looks like an excellent chim and find out you need to throw another 7 or 8k, maybe more, at it just to bring it up to standard. i know this from experience! Engine wise chims are no less reliable than most cars, it's chassis that will cause big bills, trim and running gear are not always cheap fixes either.

To the OP, if you want a v8 mate get it, chims are great. Just make sure you buy a great one, buy on condition only and get it inspected by someone in the know otherwise the TVR 'experience' may not be what you thought it was and you may be posting on the porsche forum asking why you sold the common,boring, quiet and souless boxster!

daxtojeiro

743 posts

277 months

Thursday 23rd September 2010
quotequote all
I have to say I know where your coming from. I too have had a Boxster S, I did concider a TVR but as I wanted something my wife could drive and it had to sit outside, I decided on the Porsche.

Absolutely great car, does everything perfectly, very well built, but it had no soul. Cant explain it, but it just didnt do it for me. After 18 months of owning it, I sold it and havent missed it once. Cost me £3K in parts (£1K of that was for a service and alternator at an indy) and I lost £2K when I sold it too, so not a cheap experience either frown

Phil

Speedracer329

1,507 posts

208 months

Thursday 23rd September 2010
quotequote all
saxmund said:
And although I have to stretch slightly for the pedals in my work shoes (I'm OK in anything with a slightly thicker sole) I think it is the most comfortable, most ergonomically designed car cockpit I have ever sat in.
Did you know you can adjust the pedals & gain a few inches of reach?