BBC1: The Battle of Britain
Author
Discussion

y282

Original Poster:

20,566 posts

203 months

Sunday 19th September 2010
quotequote all
macgregor not withstanding, this looks like having some very good footage.


Wheelrepairit

3,051 posts

235 months

Sunday 19th September 2010
quotequote all
10/10 so far.

JB!

5,255 posts

211 months

Sunday 19th September 2010
quotequote all
Cracking! I'd love a passenger ride or to even own a spit!

boomboompow

7,026 posts

215 months

Sunday 19th September 2010
quotequote all
Cracking program thumbup

Mr E Driver

8,542 posts

215 months

Sunday 19th September 2010
quotequote all
Superb programme, McGregor has a great voice for stuff like this, like he did when he did the voice over for 'Faster' and 'The Doctor, The Tornado and The Kentucky Kid'

Swarley

5,278 posts

262 months

Sunday 19th September 2010
quotequote all
Fantastic! I really enjoyed that!!

ArtVandelay

6,692 posts

215 months

Sunday 19th September 2010
quotequote all
Mr E Driver said:
Superb programme, McGregor has a great voice for stuff like this, like he did when he did the voice over for 'Faster' and 'The Doctor, The Tornado and The Kentucky Kid'
+1

An excellent show that taught me a few things about the battle of Britain. Those pilots were the same age as I am now when they had to defend this country, Churchill knew how to give a speech too, I was almost in tears watching at times.

A well executed program, well done the BBC. Nice touch ending with the pilot's words too.

C8PPO

20,881 posts

234 months

Sunday 19th September 2010
quotequote all
ArtVandelay said:
I was almost in tears watching at times.
Me too. Possibly not "almost" either.

I wonder at:

- the courage of those men
- the ability of those men to fly combat missions after so little training
- the strength they had to carry on in the face of terrible odds
- the strength they had to carry on when they had one less mate than yesterday
- how they feel when they take part in historical programmes like this

I wonder whether they would still like a flight in the 2-seat Spit. Too old? Too infirm? Or just too many memories?

And finally, I wonder how they feel when they survey the appalling state of the UK today and wonder why the populace have dragged this country down to the levels it's now at, with such a lack of respect for what those men did, and gave, to enable us to live where we do today. But that's a discussion for another time and place.


Edited by C8PPO on Sunday 19th September 22:45

Antony Moxey

10,796 posts

250 months

Sunday 19th September 2010
quotequote all
What a thoroughly moving and completely enthralling piece of TV. The quality of the filming too was superb with aerial shots looking stunning in HD. Shows the sort of TV you can make if you put your mind to it, and also makes you wonder why we have to put up endless hours of quizzes, soaps and reality bks when we could have stuff like this instead.

Pothole

34,367 posts

313 months

Sunday 19th September 2010
quotequote all
C8PPO said:
ArtVandelay said:
I was almost in tears watching at times.
Me too. Possibly not "almost" either.

I wonder at:

- the courage of those men
- the abililty of those men to fly combat missions after so little training
- the strength they had to carry on in the face of apparently terrible odds
- the strength they had to carry on when they had one less mate than yesterday
- how they feel when they take part in historical programmes like this

I wonder whether they would still like a flight in the 2-seat Spit. Too old? Too infirm? Or just too many memories?

And finally, I wonder how they feel when they survey the appalling state of the UK today and wonder why the populace have dragged this country down to the levels it's now at, with such a lack of respect for what those men did, and gave, to enable us to live where we do today. But that's a discussion for another time and place.
you have respect for them, so do I. Why do you assume that most don't?

anonymous-user

85 months

Sunday 19th September 2010
quotequote all
Pothole said:
C8PPO said:
ArtVandelay said:
I was almost in tears watching at times.
Me too. Possibly not "almost" either.

I wonder at:

- the courage of those men
- the abililty of those men to fly combat missions after so little training
- the strength they had to carry on in the face of apparently terrible odds
- the strength they had to carry on when they had one less mate than yesterday
- how they feel when they take part in historical programmes like this

I wonder whether they would still like a flight in the 2-seat Spit. Too old? Too infirm? Or just too many memories?

And finally, I wonder how they feel when they survey the appalling state of the UK today and wonder why the populace have dragged this country down to the levels it's now at, with such a lack of respect for what those men did, and gave, to enable us to live where we do today. But that's a discussion for another time and place.
you have respect for them, so do I. Why do you assume that most don't?
Because he's right, and they don't?
To the average yoof of today, "bravery" is breaking the conditions of one's ASBO, "sacrifice" is missing last night's X-Factor, and "freedom" is spray-painting one's tag on the nearest bus shelter.

C8PPO

20,881 posts

234 months

Sunday 19th September 2010
quotequote all
Pothole said:
C8PPO said:
ArtVandelay said:
I was almost in tears watching at times.
Me too. Possibly not "almost" either.

I wonder at:

- the courage of those men
- the abililty of those men to fly combat missions after so little training
- the strength they had to carry on in the face of apparently terrible odds
- the strength they had to carry on when they had one less mate than yesterday
- how they feel when they take part in historical programmes like this

I wonder whether they would still like a flight in the 2-seat Spit. Too old? Too infirm? Or just too many memories?

And finally, I wonder how they feel when they survey the appalling state of the UK today and wonder why the populace have dragged this country down to the levels it's now at, with such a lack of respect for what those men did, and gave, to enable us to live where we do today. But that's a discussion for another time and place.
you have respect for them, so do I. Why do you assume that most don't?
Like I said, probably not a discussion for this thread. But in summary - I just feel that too many citizens, and residents, of this country not only take the war effort for granted, but have thrown away, or even actively destroyed, the opportunities which victory in that battle delivered. Perhaps not "most". But too many, and enough to have done the damage.

Sorry. It's a bugbear of mine.

Marf

22,907 posts

272 months

Sunday 19th September 2010
quotequote all
I do wonder how much kids today are taught about this period in our history.

I'm 29, nearly 30 and at primary school we spent two out of three terms in year 5 learning about WWI and WWII

Edited by Marf on Sunday 19th September 22:56

Pothole

34,367 posts

313 months

Sunday 19th September 2010
quotequote all
Crossflow Kid said:
Pothole said:
C8PPO said:
ArtVandelay said:
I was almost in tears watching at times.
Me too. Possibly not "almost" either.

I wonder at:

- the courage of those men
- the abililty of those men to fly combat missions after so little training
- the strength they had to carry on in the face of apparently terrible odds
- the strength they had to carry on when they had one less mate than yesterday
- how they feel when they take part in historical programmes like this

I wonder whether they would still like a flight in the 2-seat Spit. Too old? Too infirm? Or just too many memories?

And finally, I wonder how they feel when they survey the appalling state of the UK today and wonder why the populace have dragged this country down to the levels it's now at, with such a lack of respect for what those men did, and gave, to enable us to live where we do today. But that's a discussion for another time and place.
you have respect for them, so do I. Why do you assume that most don't?
Because he's right, and they don't?
To the average yoof of today, "bravery" is breaking the conditions of one's ASBO, "sacrifice" is missing last night's X-Factor, and "freedom" is spray-painting one's tag on the nearest bus shelter.
I volunteer with a lot of 'yoofs' and none of them are like that. I don't believe the Daily Mail's hype.

ArtVandelay

6,692 posts

215 months

Sunday 19th September 2010
quotequote all
Marf said:
I do wonder how much kids today are taught about this period in our history.

I'm 29, nearly 30 and at primary school we spent two out of three terms in year 5 learning about the WWI and WWII
Not sure what it's like now but we learnt a fair bit about WWI and WWII not just in history but also in English classes.

We read a lot of poetry from those two wars, and it did leave a lasting impression. I knew of the sacrifice British troops and troops from our colonies had made but the poetry and text told you more about the conditions and the effects of the war on morale. Even watching the end of Blackadder goes forth is upsetting, again the BBC did a good job of that too.

I'm 20, so I'm not sure if it's the same now. My Grandad was sunk several times during WWII, his brother never made it (although I can't recall the name of the vessel)

Also learnt a fair bit about the war during my radar course at college, it really was a remarkable advantage we held, in terms of intel.

tdm34ds

7,505 posts

241 months

Sunday 19th September 2010
quotequote all
absolutely the most moving piece of TV about the BoB i've seen during the 70th anniversary

Moist eyed at the end.

anonymous-user

85 months

Sunday 19th September 2010
quotequote all
Pothole said:
Crossflow Kid said:
Pothole said:
C8PPO said:
ArtVandelay said:
I was almost in tears watching at times.
Me too. Possibly not "almost" either.

I wonder at:

- the courage of those men
- the abililty of those men to fly combat missions after so little training
- the strength they had to carry on in the face of apparently terrible odds
- the strength they had to carry on when they had one less mate than yesterday
- how they feel when they take part in historical programmes like this

I wonder whether they would still like a flight in the 2-seat Spit. Too old? Too infirm? Or just too many memories?

And finally, I wonder how they feel when they survey the appalling state of the UK today and wonder why the populace have dragged this country down to the levels it's now at, with such a lack of respect for what those men did, and gave, to enable us to live where we do today. But that's a discussion for another time and place.
you have respect for them, so do I. Why do you assume that most don't?
Because he's right, and they don't?
To the average yoof of today, "bravery" is breaking the conditions of one's ASBO, "sacrifice" is missing last night's X-Factor, and "freedom" is spray-painting one's tag on the nearest bus shelter.
I volunteer with a lot of 'yoofs' and none of them are like that. I don't believe the Daily Mail's hype.
Agreed, there are lots who aren't like that but plenty who are and sadly they appear to be the majority.
Gave a presentation about air power to a bunch of said yoofs once upon a time.
Asked them what the role of the RAF was during the Battle of Britain and the reply came back...
"Woss the Battle ov Britain then?"
And no, they weren't joking, and they were only a few years younger than those who took actually part. It wasn't genuine ignorance they displayed, it was pure apathetic disinterest.

Pothole

34,367 posts

313 months

Monday 20th September 2010
quotequote all
My point was they don't appear to be the majority to me. ETA; I'm not sure I'd have much more than apathetic disinterest in something my Great-Grandfather was involved in if I didn't already have an interest in history. I have a mate of 24 who is far more interested in the two world wars than anyone of my age (45) who I've met recently (in the last 5 years or so) if it can be presented in a way which makes it relevant there'll be interest and perhaps respect, but I don't think there's any less respect now than there was in the 50s amongst teenagers

Edited by Pothole on Monday 20th September 00:08

y2blade

56,322 posts

246 months

Monday 20th September 2010
quotequote all
just watching this now on Sky+

very moving, one of the best things I've seen on the BBC

Ginetta G15 Girl

3,220 posts

215 months

Monday 20th September 2010
quotequote all
Very 'Curate's Egg' for me.

Why oh why oh WHY can't BBC Producers CHECK their facts before transmitting a programme?

The thing was FULL of innacuracies from the shot of the Buchon being called a 109 to Adlertag being the 12th August 1944 (Luftwaffe records state that it was the 13th August - yet they were quite happy to rely on the [flawed] Luftwaffe records of the losses on sep 15th]) to Bader being the leader of 12 Gp (it was Trafford Leigh-Mallory).

It could (SHOULD) have been so much better!