Brake calipers
Brake calipers
Author
Discussion

Teetertank

Original Poster:

358 posts

218 months

Monday 20th September 2010
quotequote all
Replaced the front discs and pads at the weekend.

The discs that were supplied were about 3mm less than the original ones on the offset. This meant the spacer washers had to be removed for the discs not to foul with the calliper brackets.

Within a few miles there was a clunking sound when braking, this got worse until the nearside calliper worked it’s way loose and was only held on with a single bolt.

A few miles after that, the other calliper went the same way too. The bolts were definitely done up tight – maybe not tight enough?

So, do these bolts (hex-heads) need to be thread locked, or is something even more solid required? Or is it something to do with removing the spacer washers? If anything I would have thought the brakes should be better without the need for the spacers.

phillpot

17,524 posts

214 months

Monday 20th September 2010
quotequote all

Definately thread locked (IMHO)

Simon says

19,464 posts

252 months

Monday 20th September 2010
quotequote all
phillpot said:
Definately thread locked (IMHO)
And tighter,as even without thread lock they should never have come loose that quick frown don't use the red permanent type though frown

Johno

8,593 posts

313 months

Monday 20th September 2010
quotequote all
I've never used thread lock on these kind of bolts in all my years of mechanicing my cars. My father's an aircraft engineer for 50yrs and he doesn't use it either . . It causes more issues than solves in my experience and as long as bolts on roads cars are done up to the correct torque then there shouldn't be an issue.

The amount of this crud you end cleaning off bolts and out of holes to get a proper thread clean and able to run properly costs more hours than anything else . .

In the right application I'm sure it has it's advantages, but I've never found it necessary in 99% of the jobs I've done on cars from drive shaft CV's, UJ's, caliper bolts etc etc etc . . Just do 'em properly.

Simon says

19,464 posts

252 months

Monday 20th September 2010
quotequote all
These bolts have no locking washers so use non hard setting thread lock frown if you want to take a chance as above it's up to you rolleyes however clean threads still applies smile

Edited by Simon says on Monday 20th September 17:08

roysum

961 posts

220 months

Monday 20th September 2010
quotequote all
phillpot said:
Definately thread locked (IMHO)
+1

Johno

8,593 posts

313 months

Monday 20th September 2010
quotequote all
Simon says said:
These bolts have no locking washers so use non hard setting thread lock frown if you want to take a chance as above it's up to you rolleyes however clean threads still applies smile
Well seems I've taken soo many chances, as have many others I know and if you check with those who do their own maintenance on here how many hand on heart will say every time they do these jobs they've used thread lock ? How many calipers do we hear falling off cars ?

Taking chances, rolleyes (see, I can use that icon too biggrin )

Manufacturers don't use the stuff assembling the cars, so why would you or I need it ?

Locking washers are exactly the same mechanical principle as threads if you're meaning Nordlocks, a ramp giving graduated and increaed resistance.

If you mean a spring washer then it's to maintain pressure on a nut to resist rattling off . . Other washers perform other tasks . . not sure which you mean in this instance.

Washers on their own do not provide the resistance for a threaded bolt, the bolt and reaceiving thread do that.

Manufacturers spend a great deal of money and time researching the correct application of thread type etc (TVR probably didn't hehe) ) so that the correct bolts take the correct torque etc . .

Threadlock is a great way to get us to spend money on something that's not needed to the extent it's portrayed.

If it's that much of an issue why isn't everything lock wired then ?

Maybe I'm just a very very lucky synic . .. You own a garage Simon, are you saying all your bolts in these kind of applications are lock tighted ? You'll also confirm the thread are cleaned properly before it's applied other a build up of the stuff is as bad as not doing em up tight in the first place . .

I can understand in a litigation sense, but I can't see it standing up in court that even though the caliper fell off, it's alright cos the garage used lock tight hehe

ETA formatting for quote

Edited by Johno on Monday 20th September 17:41

Simon says

19,464 posts

252 months

Monday 20th September 2010
quotequote all
But manufacturers do use it rolleyes where did you get that info? BMW,Vauxhall,Ford,do you need any more? Ford caliper bolts come pre coated with the stuff on caliper bolts biggrin maybe you should look at my profile to see what I do daily frown and yes I am still on the tools,not going to get into an argument but at least get the facts straight thumbup my opinion is to use thread lock yours is not to that's fine the OP can make his own mind up cool





Edited by Simon says on Monday 20th September 21:29

phillpot

17,524 posts

214 months

Monday 20th September 2010
quotequote all
Well said that man, and before we had thread lock caliper bolts were always (in my experience) lock tabbed or wired. You'd have to be nuts to rely purely on tightness IMHO.

As for calipers never coming loose, ask the guy on the S forum who pulled over after feeling a strange viabration under braking and found caliper hanging on by just one very loose bolt !!!

WOO5IE

967 posts

228 months

Tuesday 21st September 2010
quotequote all
Teetertank said:
Replaced the front discs and pads at the weekend.

The discs that were supplied were about 3mm less than the original ones on the offset. This meant the spacer washers had to be removed for the discs not to foul with the calliper brackets.

Within a few miles there was a clunking sound when braking, this got worse until the nearside calliper worked it’s way loose and was only held on with a single bolt.

A few miles after that, the other calliper went the same way too. The bolts were definitely done up tight – maybe not tight enough?

So, do these bolts (hex-heads) need to be thread locked, or is something even more solid required? Or is it something to do with removing the spacer washers? If anything I would have thought the brakes should be better without the need for the spacers.
There are two size front discs different offsets.

I seem to remember that one is 58mm and 53mm is the other.
When I replaced mine I just made sure I got the right offset. Cant see why this should make tightened bolts come loose though

Trevfrown

Bassfiend

5,530 posts

281 months

Wednesday 22nd September 2010
quotequote all
I changed my front calipers for a set supplied by Dan Hoenan (sp?) as have many on here - nipped up the caliper retaining bolts nice and tight (can't remember offhand what we torqued them to) but while out a week or so later heard a clunk as something bounced off the road and hit the bottom of the car, followed shortly by another. Touched the brakes and my NSF wheel locked solid ... the bottom caliper bolt had come loose and come out losing both the caliper bolt and spacer.

Nothing at all wrong with the kit of bits from Dan by the way - he's a bloody good bloke and was happy to send me another spacer etc. - but when they went back together I made sure I replaced all four bolts and they were threadlocked just in case... frown

Phil

Keri

156 posts

261 months

Sunday 10th October 2010
quotequote all
I'm pretty sure this is nothing to do with locktite....

When calipers are all bolted up the ends of the (female) threads form a nice tough rust "ridge", it builds up over many years and is not affected by caliper removal or bolt replacement.

This means that if you take a shim out you'll start "bottoming" the bolt onto the ridge, instead of clamping the mounting lugs.

Did you clean the female threads with a tap?

Another way rust can catch you out is it there's a build-up on the mating faces in a part that's not covered by the old shim/spacer, but IS used when the caliper is fitted without the spacer. If this happens the caliper clamps up on this rust, but during use the rust breaks up into dust and again leaves the caliper loose.

Edited by Keri on Monday 11th October 12:31