Audi Q5 Winter Tyres
Author
Discussion

Sevo

Original Poster:

297 posts

222 months

Friday 24th September 2010
quotequote all
My parents have just bought a Q5 and are planning on buying winter tyres. Its the special ed S line and so has the awesome but ridiculous 20" wheels.

Recommendations on the net seem to be Pirelli Scorpion Ice and Snow or Vredestein Wintrac 4 xtreme. Any other suggestions?

I'm assuming that it would be better to put some smaller (17's?) wheels on for the winter tyres? Will that necessitate any fettling of suspension etc?

Thanks.

Hereward

5,170 posts

261 months

Friday 24th September 2010
quotequote all
Nokian make fabulous winter tyres specifically for 4x4's. Look at their website.

Sevo

Original Poster:

297 posts

222 months

Friday 24th September 2010
quotequote all
Cheers.

Hereward

5,170 posts

261 months

Friday 24th September 2010
quotequote all
These would be worth considering:

http://www.nokiantyres.com/tyre?id=11195214&gr...

The Q5's handbook will state what different sizes of wheel/tyres the car is designed for, you won't need to make any suspension adjustments. Only thing is that a second set of wheels for the Q5 will probably be quite pricey. If they keep the same alloys then they could simply take off the current tyres and fit the Winter tyres, assuming the Winter tyres are available in the right size.

Sevo

Original Poster:

297 posts

222 months

Saturday 25th September 2010
quotequote all
I'd been looking at those after you suggested the company. They look good.

I assumed it'd be far cheaper to get some reasonably cheap 17 or 18" alloys to stick the winters on than to buy 20" winters, incorrect do you think? Plus won't the performance of smaller winter tyres be better?

blank

3,767 posts

219 months

Saturday 25th September 2010
quotequote all
Sevo said:
I'd been looking at those after you suggested the company. They look good.

I assumed it'd be far cheaper to get some reasonably cheap 17 or 18" alloys to stick the winters on than to buy 20" winters, incorrect do you think? Plus won't the performance of smaller winter tyres be better?
I'd go for that option.

I've just picked up some OK looking Golf V wheels to use with winter tyres for £100.


There will be plenty of VAG wheels that will go on a Q5. Just make sure you know the minimum size you can get away with.

Mojocvh

16,837 posts

293 months

Saturday 25th September 2010
quotequote all
On all the VW and Audi's I have owned the advice was to go back to "stock" sizes for winter tyres, the reason being the taller sidewalls give better traction when you get frozen snow/ice rutting up.

Mo.

Russ T Bolt

1,779 posts

314 months

Sunday 26th September 2010
quotequote all
Sevo said:
My parents have just bought a Q5 and are planning on buying winter tyres. Its the special ed S line and so has the awesome but ridiculous 20" wheels.

Recommendations on the net seem to be Pirelli Scorpion Ice and Snow or Vredestein Wintrac 4 xtreme. Any other suggestions?

I'm assuming that it would be better to put some smaller (17's?) wheels on for the winter tyres? Will that necessitate any fettling of suspension etc?

Thanks.
I have been using Wintrac Xtreme's on my Subaru for 4 years (on 2nd set), fantastic tyres.

However last winter they seemed fairly pointless as I couldn't get anywhere with all the cars on the road getting stuck.

I run them all year and they last 20k miles.

Sevo

Original Poster:

297 posts

222 months

Sunday 26th September 2010
quotequote all
Thanks for the replies. Sounds like it should be feasible.

Sevo

Original Poster:

297 posts

222 months

Friday 1st October 2010
quotequote all
Audi have advised 235/65/R17 wheels with Dunlop Winter Sport 3D tyres. Anyone have any experience of them?

The email from audi seems to imply 4 wheels and tyres fitted for £1200 inc VAT. Sounds implausibly low for a dealer, the wording could mean just for the wheels, or does it sound right?

Mojocvh

16,837 posts

293 months

Wednesday 6th October 2010
quotequote all
4 wheels and tyres fitted for £1200 inc VAT.

1. Are they stock sized steel wheels?
2. Never seen an ADAC (or any other German association) mention DUNLOP winter tyres in their tests.

sorry not much help, but try surfing to see what's about, info wise in that size

edit.

http://www.camskill.co.uk/products.php?plid=m56b62...

YOU NEED TO CONFIRM THE LOAD AND SPEED RATINGS WITH WHAT'S IN THE HANDBOOK FOR WINTER TYRES.

GENERAL INFO..

http://www.vredestein.nl/Banden_Bandtypes.asp?User...

ps I SWEAR by the (various) winter vredestiens I have had fitted to Audi's, pugs and VW's and have done so for some 15 years now.
They need de-greening (as any tyre) and once slightly worn the sipes come into their own.

http://www.tyrereviews.co.uk/Tyre/Vredestein/Snowt...

Mo.

pps I REALLY dislike how dealers try to rip folk off for trying to improve their winter driving safety.



Edited by Mojocvh on Wednesday 6th October 22:35

s2driveruk

350 posts

240 months

Friday 8th October 2010
quotequote all
Nokian WR's are a good alternative if they are offered in the correct size for the car....quiet, grippy and long lasting on my A6 avant and have performed so well in the mountains that i have yet to have got the chains out when the roads haven't been plaughed after a fresh fall.

Narrower/smaller tyre would be better but you need to ensure you still have adequate clearance for the brake caliper etc and that if you go aftermarket for a set of rims you get the correct ET as dragging the wheel too far inboard will possibly foul other suspension bits.

HTH
David

Sevo

Original Poster:

297 posts

222 months

Friday 8th October 2010
quotequote all
Mojocvh said:
4 wheels and tyres fitted for £1200 inc VAT.

1. Are they stock sized steel wheels?
2. Never seen an ADAC (or any other German association) mention DUNLOP winter tyres in their tests.
Thanks for the links. I cant believe how cheap some of these tyres are (warped perspective from my bloody 135!)

I suspect they are stock for the Q5.

Looking at the reviews online of the Dunlops they do fairly well. They are (at least according to the dealer!) sent over from Germany on the advice of Audi in Germany. Online prices seem to be about £150/tyre so 4 official 17" alloys and 4 tyres for £1200 fitted is not actually too bad as far as I can see. When you add in the fact that my parents would feel more comfortable with dealer supplied and fitted stuff it seems reasonable to go for. If the tyres are crap then at least we have the wheels ready to try some Nokians or Vredsteins next winter.

s2driveruk said:
Nokian WR's are a good alternative if they are offered in the correct size for the car....quiet, grippy and long lasting on my A6 avant and have performed so well in the mountains that i have yet to have got the chains out when the roads haven't been plaughed after a fresh fall.

Narrower/smaller tyre would be better but you need to ensure you still have adequate clearance for the brake caliper etc and that if you go aftermarket for a set of rims you get the correct ET as dragging the wheel too far inboard will possibly foul other suspension bits.

HTH
David
Cheers. I think, as I mentioned just above, that they're going with the dealer option. Will try to remember to post if they're shocking!

Mojocvh

16,837 posts

293 months

Saturday 9th October 2010
quotequote all
Sevo said:
Mojocvh said:
4 wheels and tyres fitted for £1200 inc VAT.

1. Are they stock sized steel wheels?
2. Never seen an ADAC (or any other German association) mention DUNLOP winter tyres in their tests.
Thanks for the links. I cant believe how cheap some of these tyres are (warped perspective from my bloody 135!)

I suspect they are stock for the Q5.

Looking at the reviews online of the Dunlops they do fairly well. They are (at least according to the dealer!) sent over from Germany on the advice of Audi in Germany. Online prices seem to be about £150/tyre so 4 official 17" alloys and 4 tyres for £1200 fitted is not actually too bad as far as I can see. When you add in the fact that my parents would feel more comfortable with dealer supplied and fitted stuff it seems reasonable to go for. If the tyres are crap then at least we have the wheels ready to try some Nokians or Vredsteins next winter.

s2driveruk said:
Nokian WR's are a good alternative if they are offered in the correct size for the car....quiet, grippy and long lasting on my A6 avant and have performed so well in the mountains that i have yet to have got the chains out when the roads haven't been plaughed after a fresh fall.

Narrower/smaller tyre would be better but you need to ensure you still have adequate clearance for the brake caliper etc and that if you go aftermarket for a set of rims you get the correct ET as dragging the wheel too far inboard will possibly foul other suspension bits.

HTH
David
Cheers. I think, as I mentioned just above, that they're going with the dealer option. Will try to remember to post if they're shocking!
fair dues to them, at least they are making an informed decision..