Battery on the way out... your recommendations pls
Battery on the way out... your recommendations pls
Author
Discussion

900T-R

Original Poster:

20,406 posts

288 months

Saturday 25th September 2010
quotequote all
It's an early (built May/June '93) 4.3 Chimmie, battery is getting rather inept at holding a charge after 4 years and a few 'deep cycle' events... rolleyes

Conditions:

  • Car is run as a second car. Gets out most weekends, but sometimes it sits for a couple of weeks before I use it again. Nearly always medium/long trips.
  • There is no power in the underground parking where it lives, so no way of charging/conditioning the battery inbetween trips.
  • I would like to save a bit of weight if possible
  • But reliability is priority #1
Ideas?

miniman

30,237 posts

293 months

Saturday 25th September 2010
quotequote all
I think you'll struggle. Personally, I would replace the battery, and also fit an Anderson connector to it so you have an easy way of plugging things into it. Then I'd get either a second battery and / or a jump pack so that you can charge something else up in the house and then easily connect it to the car to keep it topped up. You could go as far as fitting an isolator switch for the main battery so that the second one keeps the alarm etc running leaving the other ready for starting duties.

Definitely worth investing in a good jump pack - my Clarke 4000 has never let me down.

frenchie TVR

294 posts

206 months

Saturday 25th September 2010
quotequote all
Hi guys,

I used to have the set up that minima suggested on my previous Chimaera and it does works well: andersan connector hidden under the "glove box", if the car does not start, pull it out, connect the battery booster and it starts, job done.

But on the current Chimaera i have a "battery brain":
http://www.tayna.co.uk/Battery-Brain-Gold-with-Rem...

and i have to admit that it is even better!

I use my car once a week, sometimes once a fortnight (London car) and so far in 3 month battery brain has not let me go down... and you do not even have the problem of having to get in the car when the battery is dead...

Basically, Battery Brain isolates the battery when the "juice" left in it is to low... you come towards the car, press the bliper, if the dor do not unlock, it means that "BB" has isolated the battery. You press on the remote control supplied with BB and the battery gets reconnected, open the doors normally, start the car, bobs your uncle...

You can even decide close the door and press on BB's remote and choose to isolate the battery straight away....

There are several models of BB's, I have the "gold one" and it's one of the best 55 pounds i have spent on my Chimaera (and so far, touch wood, i have not even had issues with my alarm when BB "disconnects" the battery and when I reconnect it using the remote).

Get ones, you will see, it really feels good to know that your car will always start...

Cheers

900T-R

Original Poster:

20,406 posts

288 months

Sunday 26th September 2010
quotequote all
Right, thanks all so far. thumbup

I am not too keen on Anderson connectors (GRP cars with hulking big engines are liable enough to go up in flames without having a big fat live wire and ground hanging about together in 1 plastic connector), I do however have a + (positive) access point under the bonnet, a pair of jump start leads and another car that gets used every day.
I would however much prefer to be able to start the car from its own battery every time smile - it does 6,000 miles per annum (I only use the company car for commuting and business) so it's not like my TVR is a garage queen...

If there's a higher spec battery out there that fits in the battery box without having to bodge the latter, has a lower propensity to self-discharge (I can find very little current 'leaking away' with the multimeter when the car is parked up) has a capacity high enough to stand a couple of weeks' laying idle and still easily start the car (which seems to be a problem with normal-sized Oddyseys et al) and is ideally lighter, but at least no heavier than the standard item, I'd like to hear about it thumbup

Edited by 900T-R on Sunday 26th September 09:53

miniman

30,237 posts

293 months

Sunday 26th September 2010
quotequote all
900T-R said:
I am not too keen on Anderson connectors (GRP cars with hulking big engines are liable enough to go up in flames without having a big fat live wire and ground hanging about together in 1 plastic connector)
To be fair, they were standard fit from the factory from Tuscan onwards...

900T-R

Original Poster:

20,406 posts

288 months

Sunday 26th September 2010
quotequote all
miniman said:
900T-R said:
I am not too keen on Anderson connectors (GRP cars with hulking big engines are liable enough to go up in flames without having a big fat live wire and ground hanging about together in 1 plastic connector)
To be fair, they were standard fit from the factory from Tuscan onwards...
... which I'm not sure is a recommendation. hehe

IIRC there's been a couple of cases of cars burning down to the ground at least wtritten dwon to shorts in the Anderson connectors?

miniman

30,237 posts

293 months

Sunday 26th September 2010
quotequote all
900T-R said:
miniman said:
900T-R said:
I am not too keen on Anderson connectors (GRP cars with hulking big engines are liable enough to go up in flames without having a big fat live wire and ground hanging about together in 1 plastic connector)
To be fair, they were standard fit from the factory from Tuscan onwards...
... which I'm not sure is a recommendation. hehe

IIRC there's been a couple of cases of cars burning down to the ground at least wtritten dwon to shorts in the Anderson connectors?
I find it hard to believe - every recovery vehicle in the land has at least two Anderson connectors on it - how many of those do you see burnt out and would they keep using them if they did?

Anyway, you could go for another connection type (e.g. the cigar lighter) for keeping the battery topped up, but it wouldn't double as a jump start connection as the wiring is not even remotely up to it.

sgrimshaw

7,587 posts

281 months

Sunday 26th September 2010
quotequote all
900T-R said:
easily start the car (which seems to be a problem with normal-sized Oddyseys et al) and is ideally lighter, but at least no heavier than the standard item, I'd like to hear about it thumbup
I have an Oddysey 925 in my 400 and it has no problem in starting the car.

Mine was fitted as part of moving the battery to the boot.

The 925 is less than half the size of the original battery, there are higher capacity Oddyseys available which have a higher capacity/cranking capability if for some reason the 925 is not enough for you.



900T-R

Original Poster:

20,406 posts

288 months

Sunday 26th September 2010
quotequote all
sgrimshaw said:
900T-R said:
easily start the car (which seems to be a problem with normal-sized Oddyseys et al) and is ideally lighter, but at least no heavier than the standard item, I'd like to hear about it thumbup
I have an Oddysey 925 in my 400 and it has no problem in starting the car.
How long do you leave your car between outings? smile

scotty_d

6,795 posts

225 months

Sunday 26th September 2010
quotequote all
900T-R said:
miniman said:
900T-R said:
I am not too keen on Anderson connectors (GRP cars with hulking big engines are liable enough to go up in flames without having a big fat live wire and ground hanging about together in 1 plastic connector)
To be fair, they were standard fit from the factory from Tuscan onwards...
... which I'm not sure is a recommendation. hehe

IIRC there's been a couple of cases of cars burning down to the ground at least wtritten dwon to shorts in the Anderson connectors?
Simple cheap fix to stop them shorting is to fit a isolator in line inside the car so when not in use no power to them, Then when needed flick of a switch and plug it in. Simples no fire hazzard and a good coating of silicon grease on the connections them selfs will keep corrosion and crap out under the cap.

sgrimshaw

7,587 posts

281 months

Sunday 26th September 2010
quotequote all
900T-R said:
How long do you leave your car between outings? smile
I'm lucky to get time to drive it once a month.

Saying that, it is normally on an Accumate.

I say normally, because I have been known to forget to plug it in.

The car has been stood for 6 weeks before without it being plugged in - still had no problem starting it.

I did hear, but not sure if it's true, that the Ody925 is used by Morgan in their V8.

Mine certainly has no problem, and by moving mine to the boot the passenger footwell space increased dramatically.

Dulford Automotive did mine, and if you look on their website the picture they show is actually my car.


BrianMillar

192 posts

236 months

Sunday 26th September 2010
quotequote all
I recently replaced the battery in my Chim 500 with one of these:
ABXAGM AX D26R
from Performancebatteries.co.uk
It is not cheap but is a straight swap and has one of the highest CCA values I have seen for this size battery.
Also a 5 year guarantee.

frenchie TVR

294 posts

206 months

Monday 27th September 2010
quotequote all
Hi again,

As I mentionned it, fit the baterry brain, it works... Yesterday I tookd my Chimaear to go to Kophill, it had not be used and the battery has been isolated by teh Battery Brain: The preselection where lost on teh radio and the clock needed setting up...

Anohow, arrived to the car, pushed teh button on the BB remote to activate teh battery (you hear a little noise telling you that it;s been ativated), pressed on the car fob to open the door and desactivate the alarm and started the car....

It's cheap, it works, apparently easy to install (I had it isntalled buy the TVR Center though ...) and it's safe!

Frenchie

spend

12,581 posts

282 months

Monday 27th September 2010
quotequote all
Seems to me like most recommendations are going to be a real struggle fit in the early battery shoe cupboard confused

VictorMeldrew

8,293 posts

308 months

Thursday 7th October 2010
quotequote all
900T-R said:
miniman said:
900T-R said:
I am not too keen on Anderson connectors (GRP cars with hulking big engines are liable enough to go up in flames without having a big fat live wire and ground hanging about together in 1 plastic connector)
To be fair, they were standard fit from the factory from Tuscan onwards...
... which I'm not sure is a recommendation. hehe

IIRC there's been a couple of cases of cars burning down to the ground at least wtritten dwon to shorts in the Anderson connectors?
Wouldn't surprise me. I fitted an Andersen years ago under the bonnet of my Chim, bolted to the front cross member. After a few years the plastic body crumbled and basically fell apart. I sourced what I hope is a better quality Anderson from Demon Tweeks protected by a silicone rubber sleeve and cap, so hopefully this one won't get cooked.



Edited by VictorMeldrew on Thursday 7th October 22:26

spend

12,581 posts

282 months

Friday 8th October 2010
quotequote all
I don't understand the fixation with putting them under the bonnet Phil, nosecone or footwell seem more logical locations to me?

Kwacker

641 posts

315 months

Friday 8th October 2010
quotequote all
I have had an anderson connector in the passenger footwell/Cubby hole behind the passenger seat for a couple of years now with no trouble what so ever.

I have also fitted an Isolation switch to the battery which means I can completely disconnect the battery if it is not going to be used for any length of time. Turn the switch and she starts first time. It is also handy if you want to do some work and are concerned about the battery being connected, simply turn the switch and the battery is disconnected.

Finally I would suggest that you buy a battery from Halfords. Their batteries have a four year warranty. I have never had a battery last that long and Halfords happily replace them free of charge. At least the first two times they did the third time they complained a little and said it would be the last time they swapped it, so I went to another Halfords. And they were happy to swap it.

My 2p inserted!

Kwacker



Edited by Kwacker on Friday 8th October 13:35

MischaVisserv8

161 posts

239 months

Friday 8th October 2010
quotequote all
hi eric,

i have an emergency battery cut-off in my glove box, very handy!

same battery for 5 years now in my car and never had any problems i always cut-off the battery during the year after every trip.

so after every trip; battery cut-off and put the plastic key with yr car keys so everything save!?

downside no alarm but nobody can start or nick yr car though and you have enclosed parking so no problem?!

cheers

mischa

VictorMeldrew

8,293 posts

308 months

Friday 8th October 2010
quotequote all
spend said:
I don't understand the fixation with putting them under the bonnet Phil, nosecone or footwell seem more logical locations to me?
That's where the original kit from Leven had you put them Dave. They came with an exhaust clamp to bolt them to the front crossmember.

Not the best place from a heat damage perspective, clearly, but from the point of view of connecting jump start leads it made some sort of sense.

Pre-facelift, the nosecone wasn't an option of course.

blitzracing

6,422 posts

251 months

Friday 8th October 2010
quotequote all
The Varta range of car batterys have very low discharge, but I hear the 14CUX ecu does draw a significant standby current which wont help. (Ill get round to measuring it at some point). Just a thought though, is the car park lit, as a largish solar panel might provide enough to keep it topped up.