R32 DSG or manual
Author
Discussion

stewies_minion

Original Poster:

1,167 posts

218 months

Saturday 25th September 2010
quotequote all
I've pretty much decided on a MKV R32 for my new toy.

Currently have a MKV TDI 140 DSG. Really love the DSG. As a commuter diesel, it serves its purpose and makes it nice & lazy. Fine.

BUT - the R32 will be a toy so I'm wondering from R32 owners how well the R suits DSG and what swayed your decision to / from DSG.

Cheers

peeves

390 posts

194 months

Saturday 25th September 2010
quotequote all
We had an 06 plate R32 traded in for a Focus RS at the garage in March - it had the DSG box on it. Complemented the car really well, as you know you don't get smoother than a DSG. Unless you are a really hardcore driver and have a need to be "at one with the car" then DSG is the way to go mate. For every day life it cant be beat!

stewies_minion

Original Poster:

1,167 posts

218 months

Saturday 25th September 2010
quotequote all
I'm far from hardcore. Out of interest, what made you change ot for the Ford?

Cheers

peeves

390 posts

194 months

Saturday 25th September 2010
quotequote all
Sorry, should have explained better. I work at a Ford garage, the R32 was a trade in. Came in one day, we thrashed it for a day and sold it the next. Didn't even make it t the forecourt - lovely car!

MaverickTFSI

10 posts

194 months

Saturday 25th September 2010
quotequote all
DSG mate cool. When my Scirocco had a multi media failure VW gave me the quite rare Pirelli Edition Mk5 Golf GTI with DSG as a courtesy car, it was amazing, really responsive and quick.

cuprabob

19,928 posts

245 months

Sunday 26th September 2010
quotequote all
V6 and DSG go very well together in the R32

Biggriff

2,312 posts

315 months

Sunday 26th September 2010
quotequote all
I've got an R32 DSG and it really is very good. Involved if you want to be or lazy auto if you dont and plenty of in between action.


Dr G

16,009 posts

273 months

Sunday 26th September 2010
quotequote all
This is one that you really can discuss until the cows come home!

DSG/S-Tronic offers a fantastic Jekyll and Hyde drive. Plonk it in D and it's an excellent automatic, the very latest generation still do not offer the 'magic carpet' pull away of a conventional torque converter but shifts are imperceptible making for a very relaxed drive. Paddle shift allows you to take over from the smooth shift pattern at a split second's notice. Sport mode is a bit useless, may as well be in manual. It's just too aggressive. Manual offers very, very fast if slightly anodyne shifts (flat shifts sound fantastic 'BRRRRRAP'). As autos go DSG will let you be fairly controlling in the timing of your shifts; it will not ride let you ride the last few hundred RPM which can on the very, very odd occasions put you in a gear the box won't let you back down from quite quickly enough. Kick down switch still works in manual too which can result in an undesired flare of revs if you get over keen and stomp on the throttle.

Now tear up all of the above and stop pretending it's a manual, it isn't. It's a double clutch box and if you're expecting it to behave like a manual driven in a brash manner you'll be disappointed, buy the manual.

DSG allows you to be a very fast, very calculated, very smooth driver. Think Jensen Button or Michael Schumacher rather than your Villeneuve or early Hamilton. DSG allows you to focus on your line, on your braking, on your throttle, on your steering and your road/track position. You could pass off what is sounding these days like a fairly secondhand opinion that it removes an element of interaction and enjoyment from a drive. I say buy and drive what you prefer and you enjoy. On our give and take, twisting and undulating roads having your hands on the wheel and your mind and car primed to take a corner on line and safely is preferable to fumbling a shift and making a complete hash of it.

Personally I love manual gearboxes but I wouldn't feel hard done by with DSG.

For anyone teetering or worrying about some of the comments above hold in mind that Revo do DSG as well as engine ECU flashes:

http://www.revotechnik.com/index.php?mod=volkswage...

Raised and lowered rev limits, remove auto upshift, remove kickdown.

Edited by Dr G on Monday 27th September 10:39

Cost Captain

3,920 posts

211 months

Sunday 26th September 2010
quotequote all
I have a manual 3.2 a3 (essentially, it's a mk v r32) and if I'm honest I probably would have been better off waiting to find a DSG model. Whilst I agree a true drivers car should be a manual, the car is never going to be a true drivers car because of the weight and feel of the car.

stewies_minion

Original Poster:

1,167 posts

218 months

Monday 27th September 2010
quotequote all
Thanks for the comments folks. Seems to agree with me that DSG would suit it ok.

I've had a slight re-adjustment on the R32. Having driven diesel for years, I didn't really pay attention to road tax. It seems an R32 would be £400 pa to tax.

Now, I'm happy with daft fuel costs, but the miserly diesel owner in me won't fork out £400 for tax.

Now a GTI is a more sensible £200 pa, so I may have to have a rethink.

cuprabob

19,928 posts

245 months

Monday 27th September 2010
quotequote all
You could always go for a pre March 2006 car and the road tax will be circa. £215.

To be honest with the extra fuel costs going from diesel to R32, another £200 per year for the £425 road tax is nothing. The R32 is more than worth it. Yes it's painful paying for it every year for the privledge to drive on our pot holed roads.

ol

2,387 posts

239 months

Tuesday 28th September 2010
quotequote all
Don't miss the opportunity for an R32 just because of an extra £200 per year tax?!?! That's crazy. Believe me that ifyou love the R32 noise and power then the GTI will feel soft in comparison. Also, if you buy hte GTI then every time you see an R32 on the roads you'll wish you hadn't got the GTI.

With regards to your original question, I think DSG suite the R32's power deliver perfectly. Have had mine a year and done about 35k miles, 4 trackdays and a 4,000 Euro-hoon taking in the Nurburgring and I wouldnt swap it for anything. I've fitted a Milltek exhaust and some BBS wheels, and would recommend the Miltek non res exhaust.

Have a look at my you tube thinggy for loads of R32 videos. My username is 'olnorth'

missing the VR6

2,540 posts

220 months

Tuesday 28th September 2010
quotequote all
Seriously in the grand scheme of running a car is a few quid a month extra on VED a big deal? If so I'd suggest a £500 snotter that depreciation won't get to. Depreciation is a bigger factor than VED!

As for the DSG working for Skoda I've had the pleasure of it on many occasions and would conclude, the good Dr G has summed it up perfectly. (As per usual)
My current company car is a Fabia VRS and the DSG is seriously winning me over as a staunch manual fan I find this very surprising but it really does answer so many questions it'd be hard to resist if parting with my own cash.


stewies_minion

Original Poster:

1,167 posts

218 months

Tuesday 28th September 2010
quotequote all
cuprabob said:
You could always go for a pre March 2006 car and the road tax will be circa. £215.
That's a very valid point, thanks.

I'm still very much in the diesel mindset. Cheap. Cheap. Cheap.

It's going to take some adjusting to get the V6 frame of mind...




cuprabob

19,928 posts

245 months

Tuesday 28th September 2010
quotequote all
If you are in a "cheap" mindset then the R32 is not for you just for fuel bills alone. I do a 33 mile each way commute on motorway and driving it like a girl I manage around 28mpg. Any serious right foot action and it easily goes into the teens.

But fuel and Road Tax aside everything else is comparable with a normal ot hatch such as servicing.