A TTS or Caymen S?
Author
Discussion

colin 82

Original Poster:

237 posts

233 months

Wednesday 29th September 2010
quotequote all
Looking for a change of car again.

Its between a 2008/2009 Audi TTS or a 2007/2008 Cayman S.

Pros on cons for both please people. This will be used as a daily driver......Snow depending.

Thanks you

Sideways Rich

1,121 posts

208 months

Wednesday 29th September 2010
quotequote all
Cayman S everytime but then I am biased!

MintyChris

848 posts

223 months

Wednesday 29th September 2010
quotequote all
Not sure about the Caymen S but It will certainly be a more capable car in normal conditions but the TTS does have awd which is great in the wet/snow and also if it takes your fancy it could be brought upto around 350bhp very easily.



Edited by MintyChris on Wednesday 29th September 14:13

PaulHogan

7,695 posts

309 months

Wednesday 29th September 2010
quotequote all
There are very few people on here with both the talent and the real world experience of both to qualify either as the better drive. I went for the Cayman S because it is faster than I am and the interior is clearly a much nicer place to be than the interior of the Audi. It also copes with three times the amount of luggage.

bakes

50 posts

259 months

Wednesday 29th September 2010
quotequote all
Cayman S hands down. Great fuel economy - I managed 37mpg on a motorway journey once, lot's of boot space, amazing handling and usable speed.

Rarity value too - you see loads of TT's on the road and not many will make the distinction over the S. You see a few, but not many Caymans.

Gren

2,030 posts

283 months

Wednesday 29th September 2010
quotequote all
I've a TTS but only because I couldn't stretch to a Cayman S - was buying new and could not justify the £12k or so extra, that's more like TT-RS money. Will a 3 year old Cayman really be the same price as a 2 year old TTS? Would imagine the TTS would be around £25k, couldn't comment on the Cayman.

The Cayman is faster and better handling (and the better brand if that matters)although I'd argue the above point about the interior. I'd have also thought the TTS would be better on fuel economy (I average about 30mpg) and tax etc - 37mpg from the Cayman is something else!? On the other hand the depreciation will probably be much less on the Cayman

Edited by Gren on Wednesday 29th September 13:41

colin 82

Original Poster:

237 posts

233 months

Wednesday 29th September 2010
quotequote all
Gren said:
I've a TTS but only because I couldn't stretch to a Cayman S - was buying new and could not justify the £12k or so extra, that's more like TT-RS money. Will a 3 year old Cayman really be the same price as a 2 year old TTS? Would imagine the TTS would be around £25k, couldn't comment on the Cayman.

The Cayman is faster and better handling (and the better brand if that matters)although I'd argue the above point about the interior. I'd have also thought the TTS would be better on fuel economy (I average about 30mpg) and tax etc - 37mpg from the Cayman is something else!? On the other hand the depreciation will probably be much less on the Cayman

Edited by Gren on Wednesday 29th September 13:41
A used low milage TTS up our way will be 29,000 and over. I dont want to spent over 35,000 for this car.
Ive never been impressed with the catman interior to be honest. Im going to drive one tomorrow.

I agree on the badge thing.....However my lady is being sucked into the Audi TTS bubble.

Many thanks for the help mate

Gren

2,030 posts

283 months

Wednesday 29th September 2010
quotequote all
I assume a 2009 rather than 2008 for £29k. They are holding their value well at the moment. Hope that stays the same for the next 5 years! Tend to hang on to mine for a while.

I love my car anyway and have not regretted not spending that extra cash. It's more than fast enough and handles a whole lot better than my Mk1 TT. Back seats are pointless but I just think of them as extra luggage space.

It does look a whole lot better than the standard TT (lower, better body kit, quad pipes etc) but as mentioned above it's probably not noticeable to all.

colin 82

Original Poster:

237 posts

233 months

Wednesday 29th September 2010
quotequote all
Gren said:
I assume a 2009 rather than 2008 for £29k. They are holding their value well at the moment. Hope that stays the same for the next 5 years! Tend to hang on to mine for a while.

I love my car anyway and have not regretted not spending that extra cash. It's more than fast enough and handles a whole lot better than my Mk1 TT. Back seats are pointless but I just think of them as extra luggage space.

It does look a whole lot better than the standard TT (lower, better body kit, quad pipes etc) but as mentioned above it's probably not noticeable to all.
A 2009 TTS up in Aberdeen from a dealer can be as much at 33,000!!
theres a nice '58 plated one....dealer....for 29,000.

I drove a TTS last weekend and liked it. My lady LOVED it. To me its no about the speed as I have a dry weather toy that would leave both standing.

I really know what you mean about the TTS looks wise. Im looking forward to driving the Cayman S tomorrow. I drove a friends 2010 Boxster S and actually liked it!!

Because im buying used I guess its whats i see at the time, spec, mileage etc....

Thanks again, Oh have you had any issues or is there any common things to look for on the Cayman?

Gren

2,030 posts

283 months

Wednesday 29th September 2010
quotequote all
Can't speak for the Cayman but the only isssue I've had after 1 year of ownership was an over-sensitive alarm. Kept going off in the middle of the night. One of those lovely software updates at the dealership sorted it.

10k of daily driving - 50mile round trip to work, its not used a drop of oil (although it did need changing at 9.5k miles) and is still looking good on its first set of tyres.

ellroy

7,858 posts

256 months

Wednesday 29th September 2010
quotequote all
I love fast Audis, but just feel for the price the TTs isn't special enough. Cayman for me every time.

Tame Technician

2,467 posts

235 months

Thursday 30th September 2010
quotequote all
Unless your talking about TTRS, the its got to be the Porsche, no question. And I really rate the TTS.