Audi A3 TDi S-Line....yay or nay???
Audi A3 TDi S-Line....yay or nay???
Author
Discussion

Zammy

Original Poster:

705 posts

192 months

Thursday 30th September 2010
quotequote all
Hi, am knew to this site so hope this is the right place to post this...

..I'm looking to buy an Audi A3 2.0tdi S-Line (used between 2005 to 2008), although having read some reviews it seems they are full of faults and the suspension on the S-Line is rock solid. Can anyone comment on these cars, does anyone own or owned one?

Many Thanks in advance.
Zammy

Mr Gearchange

5,892 posts

235 months

Thursday 30th September 2010
quotequote all
What do you want from a car?

Sharp driving dynamics?
Feelsome and accurate steering?
A cosseting and comfortable ride?
Straight line performance?
Imagine?

jamesson

3,702 posts

250 months

Thursday 30th September 2010
quotequote all
Never mind any of that. Just think of the imagine. hehe

Mr Gearchange

5,892 posts

235 months

Thursday 30th September 2010
quotequote all
I did think of the Imagine. I left it till last because it was the best.

jamesson

3,702 posts

250 months

Thursday 30th September 2010
quotequote all
On a more serious note, I own an A3 albeit with the 3.2, and it's a Sport rather than the S-Line version.

The ride on mine is ridiculously hard, although I quite enjoy it in a strange sort of way. I don't think I'd particularly recommend it though. S-Line is stiffer still, so that must be awful.

I've never driven the 2.0 diesel, so can't comment on that.

It's nose heavy, doesn't feel particularly well balanced, but does grip well. Haldex came in very handy last winter.

Overall, I love my car. It does feel like a quality product and I like its design. It's quiet, comfortable (on smooth roads anyway), practical and has been broadly reliable in the three years and 45,000 miles I've done. Dealer gets a thumbs up (Caffyns in Brighton) too.

jamesson

3,702 posts

250 months

Thursday 30th September 2010
quotequote all
Mr Gearchange said:
I did think of the Imagine. I left it till last because it was the best.
You beat me to it with your post, but yes, always save the best till last. smile

Daaaveee

916 posts

252 months

Thursday 30th September 2010
quotequote all
jamesson said:
Never mind any of that. Just think of the imagine. hehe
The imagine is strong in this one.

Mr Gear

9,416 posts

219 months

Thursday 30th September 2010
quotequote all
My friend has one. He says it's nice when it's working, but he has had two serious gearbox faults and suspension problems. Lucky it's still under warranty. He's going to get rid the second the warranty expires though.

KENZ

1,229 posts

222 months

Thursday 30th September 2010
quotequote all
Certainly plenty of them round me way. Colour choice seems to be in black.

Imagine we all looked the same..

HellDiver

5,708 posts

211 months

Thursday 30th September 2010
quotequote all
2005-2007 can suffer porus heads in the 2.0TDI. That's a world of hurt when it does, as heads are nearly impossible to get, and it's 50/50 whether the engine will work at all when rebuilt or not.

edo

16,699 posts

294 months

Thursday 30th September 2010
quotequote all
I had a 2007 (170bhp) S-tronic with 18 inch wheels and S-Line. Twas as they say, hard as fook.

Stick with a non S-line and try to avoid the silly wheels.

If you dont mind the looks, a 120d is the better car dynamically.

williamp

20,388 posts

302 months

Thursday 30th September 2010
quotequote all
Daaaveee said:
jamesson said:
Never mind any of that. Just think of the imagine. hehe
The imagine is strong in this one.
Sorry, but VTEC got their first, yo!



I think this is what happened to S-line. Turns out he was really a Jap fan, so was asked to leave the marque

As for the A3, they are common but with good reason; nice cars, but the s-line is too hard suspension for me. Perosnally I'd rather have the Golf. Probably get more toys, too.

Zammy

Original Poster:

705 posts

192 months

Thursday 30th September 2010
quotequote all
Although alot of it will be motorway driving due to working out of town....the town itself is full of sleeping coppers!! Might just go for the A4 instead.

Republik

4,525 posts

219 months

Thursday 30th September 2010
quotequote all
They are sheer luxury.

rb5230

11,657 posts

201 months

Thursday 30th September 2010
quotequote all
nay....BORING!! but then i suppose that is what some people like in a car.

Mr Gearchange

5,892 posts

235 months

Thursday 30th September 2010
quotequote all
Zammy said:
Although alot of it will be motorway driving due to working out of town....the town itself is full of sleeping coppers!! Might just go for the A4 instead.
Then do not even consider anything S-Line. I had an A4 in SE spec and the ride on that was ridiculously hard.

sleep envy

62,260 posts

278 months

Thursday 30th September 2010
quotequote all
I've owned an a3 2.0 tdi 140 sport for the last 3 years

as an everyday car it suits my needs perfectly and I wouldn't change it for any car (if I were paying)

it's been reliable, returns 40/5ish mpg through london in the rush hour, very comfy and attracts little attention

servicing is about £200/250 every 18k miles or 9 months for me

sure it's not the final word on dynamics or steering feel (there's far better cars out there) but it has a reasonable lick of pace and you can get the arse out if you take liberties on greasy roundabouts whistle

I've had the use of an a3 2.0 tdi 170 s-line quattro (!) and I found it fking awful - the transmission kills the car and it's faaaaaaar too stiff, given the choice between the two I'd take a sport fwd