Winter tyres, are they worth it?
Winter tyres, are they worth it?
Author
Discussion

G-P

Original Poster:

244 posts

210 months

Saturday 2nd October 2010
quotequote all
Never driven a car with them on but like the idea of them on the wife's car. She has a A4 3.0 TDI Quattro auto with 18" wheels and Pirelli P zero Rossos on. I already have a spare set of 17" Audi alloys so I am half way there but don't want to spend £400 on tyres and not notice much of a difference.

Cupramax

11,007 posts

283 months

Saturday 2nd October 2010
quotequote all
I had Eagle F1 assymetrics on my A4 quattro last winter and I never got stuck in the snow or even had the remotest problem, infact i couldn't believe how good it was considering the tyres. I'd say dont bother.

Deerfoot

5,258 posts

215 months

Saturday 2nd October 2010
quotequote all
Cupramax said:
I'd say dont bother.
Try some and you`ll be amazed how good they are.

ecain63

10,653 posts

206 months

Saturday 2nd October 2010
quotequote all
If its quattro then there's really no need. Yes winter tyres are good, but only really worth it on 2wd. I spent last xmas in scotland. Motorways snowed under, roads blocked etc. The RS6 wasn't even phased. Passing the hundreds of bm's and mercs on the side of the road was very satisfying. Did quite a few trips to the shops for the nieghbours as they were stuck in their driveways. All in a days work for the quattro. The tyres I was running were p zeros as per standard fit. They were only a couple of k off replacement too. Save yourself a tidy few hundred quid and just drive sensibly.

On a different angle, why not spend some of the savings on a snow and ice driving course. I've done loads (now an instructor) and the training is invaluable. Got a bus out of a snow drift in wales last xmas first attempt so the techniques work.

Deerfoot

5,258 posts

215 months

Saturday 2nd October 2010
quotequote all
ecain63 said:
If its quattro then there's really no need.
Does quattro give better brake performance in snow?

Consider the fact that winter tyres are fitted to all vehicles (not just 2 wheel drive ones) in Germany / Austria / Switzerland etc and you`ll come to your own conclusion about the worth of winter tyres.


istoo

2,365 posts

233 months

Sunday 3rd October 2010
quotequote all
Cupramax said:
I had Eagle F1 assymetrics on my A4 quattro last winter and I never got stuck in the snow or even had the remotest problem, infact i couldn't believe how good it was considering the tyres. I'd say dont bother.
have to disagree, Eagle F1s are the worst tyres i have had in the snow on a quattro. had them on two quattros over winter, and i am speaking scottish grampians snow. The car however makes a difference, yes a quattro on like for like tyres will be a lot better than most but winter tyres make the world of difference. No i never got stuck but i did have to spend a while tackling some tricky sections. And couldnt get the A4 quattro out of the lecht carpark, they are superb road tyres, one of my favourites, but truely hopeless winter tyres.

Its not just traction, braking, grip and safety are all improved. Evo magazine did a good article on this a few months ago. Also means you get more life from your summer tyres when you want too, worth the long term investment imho, provided you live in an area where it is more warranted.

istoo

2,365 posts

233 months

Sunday 3rd October 2010
quotequote all
ecain63 said:
On a different angle, why not spend some of the savings on a snow and ice driving course. I've done loads (now an instructor) and the training is invaluable. Got a bus out of a snow drift in wales last xmas first attempt so the techniques work.
also utterly agree with this, or if your fortunate enough to be brought up where this was an every winter occurance also helps enormously. And I really think this is the route of the problem, not the car but the driver... I saw a daft amount of it last winter, to the stage i drove the uncleared B roads as at least it would be my fault if i got stuck.

Cupramax

11,007 posts

283 months

Sunday 3rd October 2010
quotequote all
istoo said:
have to disagree, Eagle F1s are the worst tyres i have had in the snow on a quattro.
I'm not questioning that, all I said was that the car handled the conditions admirably DESPITE the tyres.

Targarama

14,792 posts

314 months

Sunday 3rd October 2010
quotequote all
G-P said:
Never driven a car with them on but like the idea of them on the wife's car. She has a A4 3.0 TDI Quattro auto with 18" wheels and Pirelli P zero Rossos on. I already have a spare set of 17" Audi alloys so I am half way there but don't want to spend £400 on tyres and not notice much of a difference.
As a compromise how about some all season tyres? In other words a tread style/compound which is less overtly 'sporty'. It will probably make the car comfier, and unless she drives the balls off the car she won't notice a difference in warm weather.

Kevin VRs

13,897 posts

311 months

Sunday 3rd October 2010
quotequote all
In answer to the original question - Yes, next question?

mad4amanda

2,410 posts

195 months

Sunday 3rd October 2010
quotequote all
yes! I have a set of Toyo Snowproxes for my 540i for the winter and they are excellent.

istoo

2,365 posts

233 months

Sunday 3rd October 2010
quotequote all
Cupramax said:
istoo said:
have to disagree, Eagle F1s are the worst tyres i have had in the snow on a quattro.
I'm not questioning that, all I said was that the car handled the conditions admirably DESPITE the tyres.
Cant argue with that smile

Patrick Bateman

13,220 posts

205 months

Monday 4th October 2010
quotequote all
http://www.evo.co.uk/news/evonews/248524/winter_ty...

That article is rather good, point being well illustrated in the comparison against the Evo.

fluffnik

20,156 posts

258 months

Monday 4th October 2010
quotequote all
ecain63 said:
If its quattro then there's really no need.
I couldn't agree less.

AWD gives you more traction no more grip so you'll likely be going faster when you discover the lack of grip under braking.

bluesatin

3,115 posts

303 months

Monday 4th October 2010
quotequote all
I have quattro on my R8 v10 and it was shocking in the snow. I am in Switzerland this week and everybody has to have winter tyres and they have no problem with the type of snow we have in the UK.

SunDiver

780 posts

268 months

Monday 4th October 2010
quotequote all
fluffnik said:
ecain63 said:
If its quattro then there's really no need.
I couldn't agree less.

AWD gives you more traction no more grip so you'll likely be going faster when you discover the lack of grip under braking.
+1

A 2wd car on winter tyres will spank a quattro on regular tyres. Go to the Alps to see this where you can watch visiting Brits with misconceptions. Put winter tyres on 4wd and you're in a strong position. My quattro S4 was truly awful in proper snow on both Eagle F1s and Vredestein Sessantas. Low traction and woeful braking. It's wonderful on Vredestein Wintracs. I wouldn't be without 'em in Winter. It's not just a bit better - there's no comparison.

s2driveruk

350 posts

240 months

Friday 8th October 2010
quotequote all
anything running wide summer rubber in winter is going to be terrible in low temps and ice snow...period. Add in the weight of the car and you'd be surprised about how much influence grvaity has when you hit gradients (ahem, especially going downhill!!!) Totally agree about a driving course for winter driving, in fact i am never sure why there isnt a mandatory aspect to the driving test these days on a skid pan etc.

I've used winter tyres for several years driving to and from the alps and they stay on the car in the UK from end of October until April. The difference is night and day, even on a quattro, get some smile

jollysoutherner

167 posts

254 months

Friday 8th October 2010
quotequote all
Any thoughts on keeping the tyre width the same or going for a narrower tyre when changing to winter tyres, as it would be easier for me to swap tyres than store a spare set of rims?

I've got a quattro on 225x45x17 Michellin Pilot Sports, acceleration in the snow is fantastic biggrin but under braking it brings it home how little grip is actually available. During last years snow I always took the works combo van as it was so much better under braking with a set of TDF tyres.







mad4amanda

2,410 posts

195 months

Friday 8th October 2010
quotequote all
Most manufacturers have a spec for winter tyre size so best have a look in the handbook or speak to them direct before making your own decision. After all unless you follow thier guideline you could have insurance issues in the event of a claim?

G-P

Original Poster:

244 posts

210 months

Sunday 31st October 2010
quotequote all
Thanks for all your help, next question what winter tyres should I go for?