Ok, So Whats Going To Win......

[Castrol Craig]

in a hypothetical fight between....

Enterprise D..



Battlestar Galactica



or, wildcard.....

The Millenium Falcon...





i throw the floor open to you, noble PH'ers.

[Gargamel]

Clearly not the falcon, although they'll be safe enough once they get the numbers out of the hyperdrive computer.



Battlestar galatica, only one that can launch secondary fighters, duh.

[Blib]

It is impossible for Captain Kirk to lose any battle.

Fact.

[Smokey2326]

You geek!

[JungleJim]

The bsg obviously!

[deevlash]

Blib said:

It is impossible for Captain Kirk to lose any battle.

Fact.

Picard was captain of the Enterprise D

[ZOLLAR]

Blib said:

It is impossible for Captain Kirk to lose any battle.

Fact.

Enterprise D was picard

[captainmatt]

Not actually seen Battlestar, but from my knowledge of Star Trek and Star Wars, I would probably say the Enterprise D would win, except it would get destroyed in the process (as per all the other Enterprises).

Millenium Falcon would probably fall to bits in a comical fashion.

[Jasandjules]

Enterprise.

[4988cc]

Blib said:

It is impossible for Captain Kirk to lose any battle.

Fact.

Kirk, Spock and Sulu - in the Falcon. Although both Kirk and Solo had woeful chief mechanics, so there's your weak link.

[IforB]

Blib said:

It is impossible for Captain Kirk to lose any battle.

Fact.

[Castrol Craig]

Smokey2326 said:

You geek!

i was bored, and its a very important matter.

[mattmoxon]

I recon one well placed phaser hit or a photon torpedo would take the Millennium Falcon out, so it is out of the picture right away, then it is just BSG and the Enterprise D to duke it out, however having never watched BSG I can't comment on the likely outcome of that, one would hope Picard would triumph.

[deevlash]

The enterprise would win anyway, its the fastest and has photon torpedos. It could drop out of warp next to BSG, photon its ass and warp away before bsg knew what had happened.

[Sonic]

Enterprise. Those shields should cope with any BSG fighters trying it on, and the falcon is going to struggle to get away with the tractor-beam focused on it.

[4988cc]

IforB said:

Blib said:

It is impossible for Captain Kirk to lose any battle.

Fact.

for the most apt application of that I've ever seen.

[Sheets Tabuer]

Enterprise, it has phasers and photon torpedoes, plus it has much more powerful shields.

If it got in to any trouble it could off course re-route auxiliary power from the deflector array to wtf pwn the battlestar

[NiceCupOfTea]

Blib said:

It is impossible for Captain Kirk to lose any battle.

Fact.

True. He might have to crash it into a planet, sacrifice a couple of anonymous red shirted blokes and lose his top somewhere down the line, but he'd still win.

[ZOLLAR]

4988cc said:

IforB said:

Blib said:

It is impossible for Captain Kirk to lose any battle.

Fact.

for the most apt application of that I've ever seen.

+1 perfect use of that picture!.

[AndrewW-G]

Wouldn't a Star Destroyer be a nearer equivalent to Galactica, than the MF?