Discussion
Hiya all, I was wondering what price a dealer would offer you for your chimp if it was offered privately for 12k? I'm just looking for a ball park figure. Not part exchange. Just would like to know if your car was worth 12k privately what would a dealer typically give you for it if you handed the keys over?
Thanks
Thanks
when i purchased mine privately the owner had been offered around 20% less by the supplying dealer as a sale or return than he was advertising it for on ph , personaly i would hope that if the seller was pricing a good example realisticly the amount you would pay should be somewhere inbetween if the seller is willing to negotiate , disscuss this with the seller once youve seen the car but remember that good examples MAYBE open to offers not INSULTS !!
I would truly love to name and shame but rules are rules and I'm sure PH does not need a legal bill on my account.
As an experiment I rang a few dealers a while back to sell an imaginary chim that I was hoping to buy privately.
The figures were not 20% I can tell you, I'm sure once you are in the showroom the figure might rise to 20% and you feel you are getting a better deal, but the figures I was quoted ranged from 25% down to 43%.
This fits with one of the posters comments above.
I'll admit not quite as bad as webuyanycardotcom but the car showroom is really no different to say cash convertors.
They know that when you drive onto the forecourt you pretty much want to sell (I won't go as far as saying desperate, although some are), armed with this piece of information, they tend to use it to full advantage.
This is why I don't understand there isn't more flexibility from private sellers, I know its crap getting an insulting offer from a private buyer but the harsh reality is its not a great time to be a seller of anything right now.
As an experiment I rang a few dealers a while back to sell an imaginary chim that I was hoping to buy privately.
The figures were not 20% I can tell you, I'm sure once you are in the showroom the figure might rise to 20% and you feel you are getting a better deal, but the figures I was quoted ranged from 25% down to 43%.
This fits with one of the posters comments above.
I'll admit not quite as bad as webuyanycardotcom but the car showroom is really no different to say cash convertors.
They know that when you drive onto the forecourt you pretty much want to sell (I won't go as far as saying desperate, although some are), armed with this piece of information, they tend to use it to full advantage.
This is why I don't understand there isn't more flexibility from private sellers, I know its crap getting an insulting offer from a private buyer but the harsh reality is its not a great time to be a seller of anything right now.
Have you seen the price of Classic cars recently!Im after another MGB after selling mine last year for 2k less than what they go for today.They also sell like hot cakes .Is the Chimaera not a classic! .A
decent gt is now 4 to 6k , roadster up to 14k and a V8 gt seen for 20k and they still sell...This was my car and im still pig sick.
http://www.carandclassic.co.uk/car/C104129/
Edited by SILICONE KID on Tuesday 12th October 10:23
andy450 said:
as posted before the seller of mine was offered sale or return with 20% cut from his private ph asking price, but that was around 40%+/- less than he had paid cash for it just under 1 year and 1500 miles earlier from the same dealer !!!!!!
Whats the problem Mr MoJo Occupation: Motor Trade,
I'm clearly not alone with my reasoning.Look your industry is no different to any other, but if people understand a little bit more about it, thats gotta be a good thing for the genral buying public.
Nobody wants to see there pride and joy go for less than its worth to a dealer or private buyer by the same token nobody wants to pay over the odds.
Information is the consumers weapon these days and forums are ideal places for sharing this, I honestly had no idea how dealers operated until I joined PH. Sad but very very true. I've learnt so much since I've been on here PH really is a great place to get the knowledge you need.
Its even more important becuase over 10 years ago most transactions were taking place on forecourts now most transactions are taking place online.
blackpoolrocket said:
I honestly had no idea how dealers operated until I joined PH. Sad but very very true. I've learnt so much since I've been on here PH really is a great place to get the knowledge you need.
Dealers buy a car for an amount, then sell it for more than they bought it for. Simple.We really don't need your thousands of threads which all say "Dealer X has a car that's more than Private Seller Y" - most of us here can work out how to buy a car, and what the relative advantages and disadvantages are.
Put up, or shut up IMO.
Its a forum providing I don't break forum rules I will continue to post on what ever subject I like, if that sometimes happens to dealers then so be it.Its not the only subject I post on. You clearly don't like my posts or you find them boring then I'm sorry you feel that way, but you are not the only one reading them.
Mattt said:
I saw the thread title and wondered if blackpoolrocket had posted, surprise surprise there he is!
If you don't want to read my posts, you could maybe stop sniffing them out. Anyway, this is about dealer prices we are steering off the subject I have nothing more to say maybe someone else wants to contributeblackpoolrocket said:
Whats the problem Mr MoJo Occupation: Motor Trade,
I'm clearly not alone with my reasoning.
Mr Rocket sir, I have no problem with your opinion, just commenting on the fact that you seem to pop up whenever this subject is raised. Making the same comments over and over again. Thankyou for pointing out the 'Mr MoJo Occupation: Motor Trade though
I'm clearly not alone with my reasoning.
Not that I have ever hidden this fact from anyone on here or anywhere else (its there for all to see in my profile where you found it).May I suggest it is you who has a little problem with the Motor Trade in general ? You are the one who tends to harp on about it more than most.
[quote
This is why I don't understand there isn't more flexibility from private sellers, I know its crap getting an insulting offer from a private buyer but the harsh reality is its not a great time to be a seller of anything right now.
[/quote]
Why should they ? Dealers quoted above have been offering the same deal to people selling to them for years good or bad encomic climate.what you are implying with above statement is that private buyers should take say on a 10K car a 40% discount as per certain dealers mark ups. i think not. as has been said before if you don't like dealers prices buy private from someone who has maintained their car like most of us here have with a passion and get yourself a "deal" on the condition of the car you are buying.
This is why I don't understand there isn't more flexibility from private sellers, I know its crap getting an insulting offer from a private buyer but the harsh reality is its not a great time to be a seller of anything right now.
[/quote]
Why should they ? Dealers quoted above have been offering the same deal to people selling to them for years good or bad encomic climate.what you are implying with above statement is that private buyers should take say on a 10K car a 40% discount as per certain dealers mark ups. i think not. as has been said before if you don't like dealers prices buy private from someone who has maintained their car like most of us here have with a passion and get yourself a "deal" on the condition of the car you are buying.
No no and No.
What I'm saying is if Mr Dealer is offering you say 40% less then some one comes along and offers you 20% less than its better, not great I know but hey still better. In an ideal world with TVR prices rising and the economy in good shape you'd expect more than the asking price and hopefully that day will come.
I'm not always bashing dealers but lets stick to facts instead of me injecting my own personal view point. The only thing that seperates a private seller from a dealer is sale of goods act and warranty.
The sale of goods act has many times let consumers down as in the case of Darren Egan vs. Motor Services (Bath) Ltd (18 October 2007) which saw the consumer who attempted to reject his vehicle lose out dramatically.
Have you read some of the warrranties supplied, I have, and I'd prefer to take my chances with a private seller and warranty companmy, but thats just me.
I've made my feelings on dealers quite clear, other PH members are gonna either disagree or agree based on what they have experienced.
What I'm saying is if Mr Dealer is offering you say 40% less then some one comes along and offers you 20% less than its better, not great I know but hey still better. In an ideal world with TVR prices rising and the economy in good shape you'd expect more than the asking price and hopefully that day will come.
I'm not always bashing dealers but lets stick to facts instead of me injecting my own personal view point. The only thing that seperates a private seller from a dealer is sale of goods act and warranty.
The sale of goods act has many times let consumers down as in the case of Darren Egan vs. Motor Services (Bath) Ltd (18 October 2007) which saw the consumer who attempted to reject his vehicle lose out dramatically.
Have you read some of the warrranties supplied, I have, and I'd prefer to take my chances with a private seller and warranty companmy, but thats just me.
I've made my feelings on dealers quite clear, other PH members are gonna either disagree or agree based on what they have experienced.
Quinny said:
Most are charlatans
A mate took his very tidy, well serviced Griff to a well known ex TVR place, and was offered £5k, against a £25k car
Says it all really
I might go to £5 and 1/2 K (depending on colour) A mate took his very tidy, well serviced Griff to a well known ex TVR place, and was offered £5k, against a £25k car
Says it all really


At the end of the day its an offer, to be accepted, haggled or refused.
Dealer may have been "over stocked" so a low offer is another way of saying "I don't really want your car unless its for silly money and I can move it on quickly" ?
Surprises me how wound up some folk get on this subject, dealers are like anyone else selling anything, you buy, you mark up and you (hopefully) sell.
Edited by phillpot on Tuesday 12th October 20:27
Markup is typically 25 -35% minimum 1500
Obviously this depends on a dealer from house/side of road or a dealer with big windows.
When dealing with a dealers haggle, haggle, haggle, then condition, condition, condition then if you're still not happy WALK AWAY. Its a transaction like any other just be aware you are dealing with a sales person no matter how knowledegable he or she maybe. They are in the buisness of selling cars.
Haggle about price, haggle about the time of year (how many cars do you think they plan on selling in december?), haggle about price some more, get a better warranty if they won't budge on price, if its a good a car as they say it is why would'nt they extend the warranty, then finally get the price down again.If non of thst works go private. Simples
Obviously this depends on a dealer from house/side of road or a dealer with big windows.
When dealing with a dealers haggle, haggle, haggle, then condition, condition, condition then if you're still not happy WALK AWAY. Its a transaction like any other just be aware you are dealing with a sales person no matter how knowledegable he or she maybe. They are in the buisness of selling cars.
Haggle about price, haggle about the time of year (how many cars do you think they plan on selling in december?), haggle about price some more, get a better warranty if they won't budge on price, if its a good a car as they say it is why would'nt they extend the warranty, then finally get the price down again.If non of thst works go private. Simples

Edited by blackpoolrocket on Tuesday 12th October 20:38
blackpoolrocket said:
Markup is typically 25 -35% minimum 1500
Obviously this depends on a dealer from house/side of road or a dealer with big windows.
When dealing with a dealers haggle, haggle, haggle, then condition, condition, condition then if you're still not happy WALK AWAY. Its a transaction like any other just be aware you are dealing with a sales person no matter how knowledegable he or she maybe. They are in the buisness of selling cars.
Haggle about price, haggle about the time of year (how many cars do you think they plan on selling in december?), haggle about price some more, get a better warranty if they won't budge on price, if its a good a car as they say it is why would'nt they extend the warranty, then finally get the price down again.If non of thst works go private. Simples
Why not go private in the first place? Obviously this depends on a dealer from house/side of road or a dealer with big windows.
When dealing with a dealers haggle, haggle, haggle, then condition, condition, condition then if you're still not happy WALK AWAY. Its a transaction like any other just be aware you are dealing with a sales person no matter how knowledegable he or she maybe. They are in the buisness of selling cars.
Haggle about price, haggle about the time of year (how many cars do you think they plan on selling in december?), haggle about price some more, get a better warranty if they won't budge on price, if its a good a car as they say it is why would'nt they extend the warranty, then finally get the price down again.If non of thst works go private. Simples

Edited by blackpoolrocket on Tuesday 12th October 20:38
Your method sure seems like a lot of hard work to me. But then, I see the principle benefit of buying from a dealer is to be looked after afterwards - and if I'd dealt with them in the way you advocate, I wouldn't expect them to look after me very well!
Gassing Station | Chimaera | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff



Did you really believe he wouldn't !!