Gaz or Protec Shocks
Gaz or Protec Shocks
Author
Discussion

chris2002hk

Original Poster:

168 posts

193 months

Thursday 14th October 2010
quotequote all
My suspension is soft as hell, prob 13yr old gear and never changed. Car a handful round fast bends
Im thinking the Gaz shocks seem a reasonable deal, but Ive also seen the protec coilovers as well on the net.
Anyone any experience of either?

I dont want to go OTT on the upgrade, as cost wise the car aint worth it, just need a good fix
for the softies Ive got (only road use)

Comments appreciated!

chimaera1855

334 posts

199 months

Thursday 14th October 2010
quotequote all
same here but was more thinking of getting racing red.how will u compare it to GAZ.cause when i asked this question racing red were pretty new in the market.any happy user???

pk500

1,975 posts

243 months

Friday 15th October 2010
quotequote all
I got gaz on mine with 17 front and 18 rear they are great

TVR Beaver

2,874 posts

211 months

Friday 15th October 2010
quotequote all
Looking myself.. .did see a lot of post over last winter but guess the topic's just coming up for winter re-furbs this year...
So 12 months on... any bad reports / experiances?

Edited by TVR Beaver on Friday 15th October 19:36

Pupp

13,036 posts

303 months

Friday 15th October 2010
quotequote all
Installed Gaz in early summer 2006, they were the (then) newly revalved nickel bodied model that I recall were sold to me on the basis that these ones were built internally as golds. I was then, and remain, impressed with their function. The car was instantly much more planted than the (then knackered) Bilstein originals ever managed and remains so 'til this day. Only gripe was/is the durability of the finish; the bodies (not the rods nor the springs particularly) tarnished very quickly indeed, and the adjusters seized not too long after. They now need replacing and I'm anticipating they will fall foul of the MOT tester in a couple of weeks time for rust. That said, they are in a harsh environment and I drive all weathers without having taken especial trouble to clean them so maybe it's not too bad a life although I feel it could be so much better but for the want of more effective corrosion resistance. Would I buy again? Probably, if price was right but I would take full advantage of the warranty if/when they start to deteriorate as the current ones have.

I like the idea of the alloy bodied versions but wonder how they would fare in similar service, and I'm cautious given the eye failures that have been reported...

Badmutha

658 posts

224 months

Friday 15th October 2010
quotequote all
chris2002hk said:
My suspension is soft as hell, prob 13yr old gear and never changed. Car a handful round fast bends
Im thinking the Gaz shocks seem a reasonable deal, but Ive also seen the protec coilovers as well on the net.
Anyone any experience of either?

I dont want to go OTT on the upgrade, as cost wise the car aint worth it, just need a good fix
for the softies Ive got (only road use)

Comments appreciated!
The cheapest fix would be to get them overhauled at Bilstein (assuming they are Billies), about £60 each I believe.

Badmutha

658 posts

224 months

Friday 15th October 2010
quotequote all
chimaera1855 said:
same here but was more thinking of getting racing red.how will u compare it to GAZ.cause when i asked this question racing red were pretty new in the market.any happy user???
Had mine on for 2 years and very satisfied. Some have had a problem with leaks but I can't fault them.

Chimpaholic

9,637 posts

210 months

Saturday 16th October 2010
quotequote all
Derek from Absolute Shocks fitted my Gaz Gold Pros at the Gaz factory.

Derek is a top bloke.

5,000 miles later and they are perfect, in fact I think they are bedding in nicely now.

No leaks, no squeaks, very happy with them.


chris2002hk

Original Poster:

168 posts

193 months

Saturday 16th October 2010
quotequote all
Ive now ordered a set of the basic "Nickel" suspension from Absoluteshocks. The Billstien overhaul option is not possible as Im in Hong Kong, and anyway the basic TVR design is 20 years old now, time for a change. As they say on Gaz website, the original design is OK, but things have moved on now. I previously had a Nissan Skyline, that I changed to coilovers, and the improvemet was quite noticable. Lets hope it works for the Chimmy.

Has anyone fitted them DIY? I dont have an impact wrench so maybe best left to the Pros to separate the old units?
Thanks for the helpful comments.


TV8

3,578 posts

206 months

Saturday 16th October 2010
quotequote all
I was pleased with the gaz golds when they first went on. I was even more pleased when Dan Taylor did a full set-up.

Edited by TV8 on Saturday 16th October 10:53

sustech

26 posts

208 months

Saturday 16th October 2010
quotequote all
At the moment I am working on some dampers built from parts sourced in Europe. The quality is very good and they run up well on the dyno. I am hoping in the near future to valve a set to some Ohlins curves I have and get them on a car for a trial. Can't be too sure but should be around £1100 a set. Will let you know when I know.

TVR Beaver

2,874 posts

211 months

Saturday 16th October 2010
quotequote all
Badmutha said:
chris2002hk said:
My suspension is soft as hell, prob 13yr old gear and never changed. Car a handful round fast bends
Im thinking the Gaz shocks seem a reasonable deal, but Ive also seen the protec coilovers as well on the net.
Anyone any experience of either?

I dont want to go OTT on the upgrade, as cost wise the car aint worth it, just need a good fix
for the softies Ive got (only road use)

Comments appreciated!
The cheapest fix would be to get them overhauled at Bilstein (assuming they are Billies), about £60 each I believe.
That's interesting.. didn't think of having the Bilstein's re-furbished?.. Do you know what they offer?... If not I call them Monday... Cheers !! smile

chimaera1855

334 posts

199 months

Saturday 16th October 2010
quotequote all
how about the RACING REDS nobody has them on their car???

Badmutha

658 posts

224 months

Saturday 16th October 2010
quotequote all
chimaera1855 said:
how about the RACING REDS nobody has them on their car???
Check my last post wink

Badmutha

658 posts

224 months

Saturday 16th October 2010
quotequote all
TVR Beaver said:
Badmutha said:
chris2002hk said:
My suspension is soft as hell, prob 13yr old gear and never changed. Car a handful round fast bends
Im thinking the Gaz shocks seem a reasonable deal, but Ive also seen the protec coilovers as well on the net.
Anyone any experience of either?

I dont want to go OTT on the upgrade, as cost wise the car aint worth it, just need a good fix
for the softies Ive got (only road use)

Comments appreciated!
The cheapest fix would be to get them overhauled at Bilstein (assuming they are Billies), about £60 each I believe.
That's interesting.. didn't think of having the Bilstein's re-furbished?.. Do you know what they offer?... If not I call them Monday... Cheers !! smile
They just offered to re-furb and quoted £60 each plus postage.(this was 2 years ago).You will have to source new springs yourself if you need them.
HTH Bm

frenchie TVR

294 posts

206 months

Monday 18th October 2010
quotequote all
Hi,

I followed Chipaholic on his advise (the guy knows what he is talking: he is a competent mechanic or should I say "realy competnet mechanic", has a set of Gold Pros fitted and 3 months laters (only maybe 1000 miles or so), I am really, really happy.... The way teh car behaves has been greatly improved!

When I bough my Gas Gold Pros the Racing Reds where not available ..., so it made my choice easier (I was going to buy either teh RR's or the GGP).

There are as you know, "better ones" out there, but much more expensive and also propably more adapted to really serious track users....

As I said, so far I cannot fault the Gas Gold Pros and would recomend them!

Frenchie


Chimpaholic

9,637 posts

210 months

Monday 18th October 2010
quotequote all
chris2002hk, although the GGP dampers are excellent I strongly advise you look elsewhere for you handling problems first.

A lot of people look to a new set of adjustable dampers as the "cure all" for their handling problems and its just not the correct way to do things.

In my opinion dampers (unless they are leaking) are the last part in a long list of suspension and steering components that should be looked at first.

I would go back to first principles, make sure all the suspension bushes are in good order, they don't have a long life in a TVR.

Then replace the ARB drop links with a Leven set, the standard drop links are best described as inadequate, as such they also have a very short life.

Then look at condition of the top & bottom ball joints and replace them if there is any play at all.

A pair of track rod ends and perhaps the upper and lower steering column UJ if needed will also help.

By this point you may well have spent about the same money as you would on a set of good quality dampers.

All these parts are not sexy like a set of new dampers, but you will be doing the job correctly.

After all this you may well find you actually like the compliment well damped ride the standard Bilstiens give.

If they are in good order the Billies are great dampers and the spring rates were well chosen to work with them to give an excellent ride.

The best single component improvement I have fitted so far is a full set of Leven drop links.

At £170.00 for a set of 4 they are not cheap, but for me they were by far the best value mod.

Its like this:

Gaz Gold Pros give a 10% improvement for over £600.00.

Leven drop links give a 30% improvement for £170.00

However neither are worth fitting if the rest of the suspension and steering are shot.

sustech

26 posts

208 months

Monday 18th October 2010
quotequote all
Quinny said:
sustech said:
At the moment I am working on some dampers built from parts sourced in Europe. The quality is very good and they run up well on the dyno. I am hoping in the near future to valve a set to some Ohlins curves I have and get them on a car for a trial. Can't be too sure but should be around £1100 a set. Will let you know when I know.
£1100 is a lot of money to be a guinea pig
No guinea pigs required. The first set will be put on a car and tested. Could take months, who knows. I know the company has built many sets, mostly for bikes so reliability shouldn't be a problem.


Edited by sustech on Monday 18th October 23:49

chris2002hk

Original Poster:

168 posts

193 months

Saturday 23rd October 2010
quotequote all
Chimp, thanks for the advice, where can I purchase a set of Levens?

Ive now taken delivery of the Gaz Coilovers, but my next move is to check out all the bushes and perhaps fit those links you mentioned.

I dont expect miracles, as compared to a modern active ride car, the Chimmy will always feel "classic" but thats the fun of it!

cs174

1,271 posts

251 months

Saturday 23rd October 2010
quotequote all
chris2002hk said:
Chimp, thanks for the advice, where can I purchase a set of Levens?

Ive now taken delivery of the Gaz Coilovers, but my next move is to check out all the bushes and perhaps fit those links you mentioned.

I dont expect miracles, as compared to a modern active ride car, the Chimmy will always feel "classic" but thats the fun of it!
I don't think Leven do drop-links. The ones I have are by Steve Heath and can be bought here: www.shengltd.com/catalog

Best up-grade there is IMHO.