Cayman S.....Almost excellent, but...
Cayman S.....Almost excellent, but...
Author
Discussion

Redlake27

Original Poster:

2,255 posts

275 months

Friday 15th October 2010
quotequote all
I've had my 2007 Cayman S for 2 months now and I'm impressed, but not in love.

I think there is a great car trying to get out, but it needs unlocking.

My feeling is that the car has perfect balance and handling, but doesn't give enough feedback, which makes it feel a bit inert. It also has to be worked surprisingly hard to become truly entertaining.

To turn this into something truly great, I think it needs two things. 1) Lotus-esque damping and 2) More steering feel to communicate its brilliant handling balance better.

I'm not interested in changing springs and dampers and heading off down a route where I spoil the car, but I am intrigued to know if smaller wheels and tyres would improve it.

Mine is on the 18s (235 front, 265 back) but I have read great things about the suppleness and poise of the 2.7/2.9 in road tests. I'm wondering if the narrower tyres improve feedback, make it more playful and the sidewalls will help with damping?

I guess I'm trying to create my perfect car a Porsche engine with Evora feel.


Anyone else tried 17s and 18s back to back?


mrdemon

21,146 posts

296 months

Friday 15th October 2010
quotequote all
I thought it felt better than an Evora.

18" are perfect for it imho, did not have any of the issues you seem to be having.
did have 340BHp and a bespoke geo with PS2 tyres.
a good geo with the best dry tyre on the market makes it the best it can be.

Grinnders

1,558 posts

235 months

Friday 15th October 2010
quotequote all
All of us 3 posters have the same issues. We've experienced the handling of various Lotus and realise as we move to other marques we miss the directness and feedback that we left behind.

I can imagine it's the holy grail to get a Porker to feel like a Lotus. It's a DNA thing.

We have to recognise we own cars that have other attributes and not expect to find the best of all worlds in one package.

heyhobingo

30 posts

195 months

Saturday 16th October 2010
quotequote all
Same here, owner for almost two months, and know where you are coming from, although have yet to really test the car, Dubai autodrone is in my calander!

I do plan to give it a bit more oomph in the way of some ECU upgrades amongst other things, feel it needs just a little more power and response.


jackwood

2,970 posts

239 months

Saturday 16th October 2010
quotequote all
As mrdemon said, get a good geo. The factory geo is terrible. To get a more entertaining or track-biased set-up you might need to get something like camber plates or GT3 lower control arms.

Don't write off changing the coilovers either. Bilstein PSS9's have improved the ride quality no end on my car, yet it corners flatter and offers more grip. The damping is just all-round superior.

It is probably worth a conversation with Chris at CentreGravity to see what your options are. I am sure you can get something far more to your liking than what you have already.

Redlake27

Original Poster:

2,255 posts

275 months

Tuesday 23rd August 2011
quotequote all
I'm the original poster....and I thought I'd update.

My feelings haven't changed. This is a car I'd give 10/10 for in almost every area. Useability, handling, grip, performance, comfort, decent service back-up (now I've found a great independent, PCT in Coventry, rather than the estate-agent experience of an OPC), but I never felt truly connected to it as I did with my Lotus Elise and Europa.

In the winter, I bought a set of old 17" wheels and fitted winter tyres. The car came alive! It was supple, the steering feedback improved and with ESP off, it felt as a good as a Lotus.

Another case of big wheels (and my OE 18s are hardly the most extreme fitment) putting a filter between the driver and road? Maybe Porsche are over-tyring these cars. 235 wide front and 265 wide rear are the same sizes as many much heavier - and more powerful cars. On 215 front and 245 rear, it feels wonderful.




ROK

245 posts

183 months

Tuesday 23rd August 2011
quotequote all
17s? pls post a pic of it with them on.

Redlake27

Original Poster:

2,255 posts

275 months

Tuesday 23rd August 2011
quotequote all
ROK said:
17s? pls post a pic of it with them on.
Mine's currently back on its summer tyres, so its back on its 18s until October. However, I tried googling for a pic of Caymans on 17s. I only found this blurred Evo pic, but a glowing write-up on the standard car on 17s...

gsewell

724 posts

314 months

Tuesday 23rd August 2011
quotequote all
With the best will in the world, I doubt that you'll ever get a Cayman that weighs in at 1.4Tonnes to handle and feel like a lightweight car like an Elise/Evora or even more so a Seven (at just a touch over 500kg).

Again you won't get the same steering feel through power steering that you get from the direct steering rack on a Seven.

If you accept the compromise of the weight, then I think the Cayman is very good - especially in the feel.

nickfrog

25,491 posts

248 months

Tuesday 23rd August 2011
quotequote all
I am surprised that the 17' fitted, what with the big calipers ?
Chris Harris said he much preferred his Cayman 2.9 on 17' than on the bigger rubber, whether 18 or 19.

Redlake27

Original Poster:

2,255 posts

275 months

Tuesday 23rd August 2011
quotequote all
It did require a pair of spacers to clear the front calipers..

chris7676

2,685 posts

251 months

Wednesday 24th August 2011
quotequote all
gsewell said:
With the best will in the world, I doubt that you'll ever get a Cayman that weighs in at 1.4Tonnes to handle and feel like a lightweight car like an Elise/Evora
Evora is even heavier than Cayman...

mollytherocker

14,472 posts

240 months

Wednesday 24th August 2011
quotequote all
chris7676 said:
gsewell said:
With the best will in the world, I doubt that you'll ever get a Cayman that weighs in at 1.4Tonnes to handle and feel like a lightweight car like an Elise/Evora
Evora is even heavier than Cayman...
I test drove the Evora and S at Silverstone and my only complaints were its poor gearchange and its weight.

Great cars, but God knows why its so heavy. What would Chapman think?

MTR

gsewell

724 posts

314 months

Wednesday 24th August 2011
quotequote all
These days, Chapman would spend all his time trying to circumvent the legislation on safety devices (air bags, etc) and removing cup holders, and apparently motorized everything (boot lids included).

chris7676

2,685 posts

251 months

Wednesday 24th August 2011
quotequote all
nickfrog said:
I am surprised that the 17' fitted, what with the big calipers ?
Chris Harris said he much preferred his Cayman 2.9 on 17' than on the bigger rubber, whether 18 or 19.
The "big" S calipers require 17 inch wheels, as they were put on the 986 Boxster S a decade ago. Not much changed since then, apart from the perception that you may need bigger wheels. But it's actually funny how small these calipers look with 19inch wheels.

MogulBoy

3,066 posts

254 months

Wednesday 24th August 2011
quotequote all
ISTR that you cannot run 17" wheels on a PCCB equipped Boxster/Cayman.

mollytherocker

14,472 posts

240 months

Wednesday 24th August 2011
quotequote all
gsewell said:
These days, Chapman would spend all his time trying to circumvent the legislation on safety devices (air bags, etc) and removing cup holders, and apparently motorized everything (boot lids included).
I often wondered how many motors are fitted to the average car. It must be over 20 surely?

Lord knows how many are fitted to prestige stuff, must be a hundred!

MTR

chris7676

2,685 posts

251 months

Wednesday 24th August 2011
quotequote all
MogulBoy said:
ISTR that you cannot run 17" wheels on a PCCB equipped Boxster/Cayman.
You may be right, translation is required though (ISTR, PCCB) wink

GezzerRS4

35 posts

189 months

Wednesday 24th August 2011
quotequote all
ISTR - I Seem To Recall
PCCB - Porsche Ceramic Composite Brakes

I thought you had to run 19" wheels with PCCB, mine has PCCB with 19" and was told by the OPM that there are not many wheel options for a Cayman with PCCB for that reason, and also that I cannot have spacers due to the wheel size and offset needed for PCCB

NickUSA

812 posts

198 months

Wednesday 24th August 2011
quotequote all
MogulBoy said:
ISTR that you cannot run 17" wheels on a PCCB equipped Boxster/Cayman.
You cannot run 17" wheels on a Cayman S or Boxster (987) S regardless. PCCB not relevant as the 17" rims wont clear the standard (steel) S front callipers.

PCCB will fit under 18" rims btw.

Edited by NickUSA on Wednesday 24th August 22:03