Friend broke my drill ... what to do?
Friend broke my drill ... what to do?
Author
Discussion

zcacogp

Original Poster:

11,239 posts

275 months

Monday 18th October 2010
quotequote all
Chaps,

I lent a couple of tools to a very good friend of mine a few weeks back, and he returned them last night.

However, before he actually handed them back to me, he apologised and said that he thought he had broken the electric drill. Long story short, it was a mistake that anyone could make (me included) and he was profusely apologetic. He said he wanted me to look at it and see whether I thought it really was broken, and if so he was quite happy to buy me a new one OR make a suitable contribution to a better-spec one.

The drill is an 8-year-old Black and Decker. Not the best but not the worst drill ever. Had been used hard for DIY, but still had a lot of life left in it. However it was just about worthless.

I trust the chap totally. I have no doubt that he would very happily buy me a new replacement and feel happy doing so. BUT I don't want him to do that - the thing he broke wasn't worth anything much at all, so it's not on for him to pay the full cost of a new replacement.

I have yet to have any sort of discussion about it with him, but what's the PH way in matters such as this?


Oli.

P.S. I've dismantled the drill and it looks like the commutator is burned out - commensurate with his description of what he was doing with it and the way it failed.

SystemParanoia

14,343 posts

229 months

Monday 18th October 2010
quotequote all
put the motor on a comm lathe, and fit some fresh contacts.

good to go!


or just get him to get you a replacement from wherever as you "need" a drill but dont really care where he gets it from

hornetrider

63,161 posts

236 months

Monday 18th October 2010
quotequote all
Tell him he owes you a pint and to forget about it.

CraigW

12,248 posts

313 months

Monday 18th October 2010
quotequote all
I think you're thinking about it too much, just ask him to get you a similar replacement, he seems happy to and its the fairest option.

y2blade

56,322 posts

246 months

Monday 18th October 2010
quotequote all
he apologised and it was an accident...if a friend of mine did the same I'd tell him not to worry about


accidents happen

chrisj_abz

807 posts

216 months

Monday 18th October 2010
quotequote all
check the price on a similarly specced drill and ask for half the cost?

Muncher

12,235 posts

280 months

Monday 18th October 2010
quotequote all
As you both need a drill why not suggest going halves on a "good" drill that will last a while and share the use of it in future?

Pferdestarke

7,192 posts

218 months

Monday 18th October 2010
quotequote all
You should thank him for his honesty and tell him that a small contribution would be welcome towards the cost of replacement.

He was obviously giving it some stick when it went.

Tell him to buy his own fking drill too!

Fer

7,781 posts

311 months

Monday 18th October 2010
quotequote all
Pferdestarke said:
You should thank him for his honesty and tell him that a small contribution would be welcome towards the cost of replacement.
This - He could have been a s**t and not told you.


Pferdestarke said:
Tell him to buy his own fking drill too!
This bit: Optional.

PD9

2,040 posts

216 months

Monday 18th October 2010
quotequote all
8 years! B&D don't make them like they used to. The drill sounds like it's had a good hard life and you've had plenty of work from it. As above, forget about it and treat yourself to a nice DeWALT XRP.

Pat H

8,058 posts

287 months

Monday 18th October 2010
quotequote all
hornetrider said:
Tell him he owes you a pint and to forget about it.
This.

drink

maxrider

2,481 posts

267 months

Monday 18th October 2010
quotequote all
I learnt many years ago never to lend anything to anybody, friend or otherwise. It avoids the type of problem you describe.

If I want something I buy it or hire it and I expect everyone else to do the same, I doubt very much a tool hire co. would say 'forget about it it's not worth much' smile

Edit to add: What sort of a bloke doesn't posess something as basic as a fking drill anyway?

Edited by maxrider on Monday 18th October 16:03

y2blade

56,322 posts

246 months

Monday 18th October 2010
quotequote all
chrisj_abz said:
check the price on a similarly specced drill and ask for half the cost?
you're kidding right?


obscene

5,180 posts

216 months

Monday 18th October 2010
quotequote all
PH way? Shag his wife and call it even.

anonymous-user

85 months

Monday 18th October 2010
quotequote all
Tell him not to worry but if he insists get a £10 voucher for B&Q or something

Then get down to Early Learning and get a plastic toy one to present to him for his next job, should clear the air in case he still feels tense! smile

WorAl

10,877 posts

219 months

Monday 18th October 2010
quotequote all
You are taking the piss right? Just tell him to forget about it and buy a new one.

Or in PH fashion, as above, rape Sorry, shag his wife. It's only rape if she doesn't enjoy it.

Edited by WorAl on Monday 18th October 16:06

dilbert

7,741 posts

262 months

Monday 18th October 2010
quotequote all
PD9 said:
8 years! B&D don't make them like they used to. The drill sounds like it's had a good hard life and you've had plenty of work from it. As above, forget about it and treat yourself to a nice DeWALT XRP.
I have an old aluminium bodied B&D electric drill.
It must be at least 40 (years old). It's had at least five new power cords, but it still goes on strong!

Edited by dilbert on Monday 18th October 16:07

PHmember

2,487 posts

202 months

Monday 18th October 2010
quotequote all
hornetrider said:
Tell him he owes you a pint and to forget about it.
^^^ This. ^^^

PintOfKittens

1,336 posts

221 months

Monday 18th October 2010
quotequote all
obscene said:
PH way? Shag his wife and call it even.
I believe the PH way would be VBRJ, involving a mapped red bull email.

zcacogp

Original Poster:

11,239 posts

275 months

Monday 18th October 2010
quotequote all
Hornetrider is on the money. He can owe me a pint and leave it at that.

(In fact, I think I owe him a pint anyway, so I think we'll call it quits!)

In fact, I'll probably not mention it to him, and see if he raises the topic. Much better idea!

Thanks for your input chaps.

PD9 said:
... nice DeWALT XRP.
Not a fan of DeWalt ... 'twould be Makita. But we can leave that argument for the HG&DIY forum.


Oli.