What van? £6k and black
What van? £6k and black
Author
Discussion

Gruber

Original Poster:

6,313 posts

238 months

Tuesday 19th October 2010
quotequote all
A friend who runs a gardening business has asked me to help him find a new van. Trouble is, I know nothing about vans, so I'm hoping the wisdom of PH will help me to help him.

His budget is up to £6k

It has to be black - for branding purposes.

He wants something Transit / Vito sized. Not a LWB and not a hi-top. Just an ordinary van. No need for back seats or windows.

Most importantly, it needs to be strong and resilient to having tools and garden waste chucked in the back, and muddy gardeners climbing all over it. It isn't going to lead an easy life and it won't be looked after very well. He has been using an old Merc Vito which has cost him a fair bit and hasn't been all that reliable, so he doesn't want another one of those.

So... what should I be recommending?

Thanks in advance!

HellDiver

5,708 posts

206 months

Tuesday 19th October 2010
quotequote all
Vivaro.

JM

3,170 posts

230 months

Tuesday 19th October 2010
quotequote all
Transit

VW Transporter


MX7

7,902 posts

198 months

Tuesday 19th October 2010
quotequote all
Transit.

aka_kerrly

12,498 posts

234 months

Tuesday 19th October 2010
quotequote all
HellDiver said:
Vivaro.
yep, or the renault traffic and Nissan Primestar are the same vehicle.

Saw loads of Ex British Gas vans being auctioned off at very good prices. A mate picked up a 56plate Berlingo with 60k an FSH for £4k but similar age Vivaros and traffic masters werent going for a lot more!

dave

teen_cerbera

7,926 posts

249 months

Tuesday 19th October 2010
quotequote all
Overall a Transit always sets the bench marks. I have run a few, also vivaros, two different kind of vans - both have their plus points, overall the transit wins it for me.

Lower Mileage & Newer the better. Wouldnt worry about the black colour (this will be your main issue, restricts choice hugely) to much, just wrap it in black when the vans in for the livery change!

Gruber

Original Poster:

6,313 posts

238 months

Tuesday 19th October 2010
quotequote all
Thanks all - some useful stuff there...

To those who've suggested the Vivaro, what is it that makes these so good in you view?

TC - you say the Transit and the Vivaro are "two different kinds of vans" - in what way?

I'm sorry to be asking numpty questions, but I'm a van novice.

I should have added that the van will be used predominantly for short journeys - a couple of miles or so - so long distance comfort isn't a key concern. Reliability and ruggedness are the key crtieria.

Loving the A-team van. Completely inappropriate, yet brilliant.

Any other views / suggestions?


Edited by Gruber on Tuesday 19th October 12:36

HellDiver

5,708 posts

206 months

Tuesday 19th October 2010
quotequote all
Gruber said:
TC - you say the Transit and the Vivaro are "two different kinds of vans" - in what way?
Vivaro is the van you buy yourself when you're doing 10 hours a day behind the wheel.

Transit is the van you buy in multiples of a hundred for other people to drive.

teen_cerbera

7,926 posts

249 months

Wednesday 20th October 2010
quotequote all
I found the Vivaro more car like thats a given, its certainly more comfortable for long journeys etc. However, the Transit just feels more "built for purpose", I am in the construction/grounds maintenance sector my self and I just feel the Transit is a more robust piece of kit. Spares are easily available for the Transit as theres alot more of them about - I am forever replacing wing mirrors & bits of trim etc.

If the two vans were parked side by side in the yard and I wanted to go on a 300 mile round trip, I would probably take the Vivaro, if I was going to carry out the local contracts we have, I would load the Transit and get on with it.

Its hard to define the running costs as nothing went wrong with either, fuel wise, well the Transit was driven by someone who prided him self on MPG and therefore that wasnt a fair comparrison either. I imagine simular spec'd engines will be simular mpg.

As I said, both are very good vans, but I would take the Transit everytime smile This is from someone who run a few of these vans side by side for a year or two. You may feel different.

Gruber

Original Poster:

6,313 posts

238 months

Thursday 21st October 2010
quotequote all
Chaps - thank you.

I'm very grateful for the feedback. Transit and Vivaro seem to be the two main / only contenders.

Given what you say, and given the use of the van will be almost solely for short journeys, the Transit seems to be the leading choice.

Are there any models / specs / engines to avoid?

Oh... and does anyone have any idea how much it would cost to "wrap" a van?


Edited by Gruber on Thursday 21st October 11:30