RS5 Test Drive
Author
Discussion

J-P

Original Poster:

4,422 posts

237 months

Sunday 24th October 2010
quotequote all
Had a go in the new RS5 today.

I have to say that bizarrely, I wasn't really looking forward to it and had very low expectations. The reason for this was that I've read a number of lukewarm or downright disappointing reviews (this month's Car Magazine)and thought "I'm not sure I'll like this."

How wrong I was!

The RS5 had a fantastic driver-focused interior and felt like a proper luxury car inside - the engine noise was simply fantastic (especially in dynamic mode), test car had optional sport exhaust and I'd say this was essential as the noise is a little muted at normal pace.

I started off driving down a motorway, and the car behaved impeccably. Put your right foot down and you get instant response as it lunges for the horizon! Back off a bit and it's relatively quiet and comfortable. We then went on some back roads which gave me the opportunity to try out the manual mode and work that lovely sounding engine a bit.

The transmission is awesome, smooth instant upshifts, with none of the foibles that you get on some systems (clumsy when cold etc.) Night and day better than the C63 I drove. Brakes were nice and progressive although pedal not quite as hard as I'd have liked but traction was awesome. The roads were cold and wet this morning but the RS5 was stuck to the tarmac like some sort of super advanced Japanese maglev train. The speed it could take corners and the confidence it gave you in the wet was incredible!

All in all I thought it was fantastic fun to drive and a real "do anything" type of car. No it's nowhere near as fast as a GTR, (but it's much nicer inside and far easier to live with), yes I'm sure an M3 is better on track and in the right conditions probably on the road too but if you're not a "hand" and lets face it most people aren't you'd be loads quicker in this than an M3 and you can truly use it's performance everyday (which in this country is saying something).

Downsides - you have to get all of the right settings on the driveselect system, you really can tailor the car to suit any mood and each mode does have an impact on the way the car drives.
It's not quite as sweet as an RS4 but it's closer than most of the mags would have you believe and as an object to own, to drive around in and to actually sit in, it really does take some beating. My E92 M3 was better to drive on the right day but I went round a wet corner at a fair old lick today; in my M3 that would have seen me in the hedge. And the interior was simply no match for the RS5 which feels properly expensive.

If you've been thinking about one and have been put off by some of the poor reviews, don't worry. Go and test drive it and I'm sure you'll think it's a car you want to own!

J-P

Original Poster:

4,422 posts

237 months

Sunday 7th November 2010
quotequote all
Just had a go in an E63 AMG as it's about the same price as a properly specced RS5.

Hard to believe but I have to say AMG is night and day better. Comfort mode is actually comfortable rather than just acceptable as it is in an M3, GTR (which is really hard work) or RS5 and the transmission is simply stunning - it really does blend the best of auto and DCT style manual transmissions. In comfort mode it's super smooth with barely perceptible upshifts. In manual mode, it's instant, on-demand change, with throttle blips on downchanges but unlike the RS5 if you don't change down and the engine needs to, it won't blip, so isn't tiresome or annoying.

And for a big car, it's extremely quick and surprisingly agile, with fantastic steering. The interior is not quite as nice as the Audi's but it's much more intuitive to use. And the engine.... it's Thor farting!!! Utter V8 nirvana! This car really can do it all!

Palmball

1,294 posts

205 months

Monday 15th November 2010
quotequote all
Your comments on the E63 are interesting...I managed to get an E63 loaned to me for the day yesterday and as a result of that, I've just bought one!

Having had an M3, M6 and two C63's in the last 2-3 years, the E63 is like a fantastic combination of all of them.

The suspension is easily as good as an M3 with EDC (and much better than the way the EDC is calibrated in the M6), the noise is as good as in the C63 and the quality and engineering depth appears to be the match of the M6.

J-P

Original Poster:

4,422 posts

237 months

Monday 15th November 2010
quotequote all
Never driven and M6 but I'd totally agree with your other comments. I'm just waiting until March to see if I'll be able to get one (an E63) but I think it's awesome and quite subtle too!

lowndes

839 posts

245 months

Monday 3rd January 2011
quotequote all
After 4 years with an RS4, which I thought was excellent, I collected an RS5 on Sunday. First impressions are quite favourable and in my view it moves on several steps from where the RS4 left off. Road conditions just now are simply not suitable for anything other than careful progress but the performance such as I used was effortless and smooth as double cream.








V10P0W3R

22 posts

191 months

Monday 3rd January 2011
quotequote all
lowndes said:
After 4 years with an RS4, which I thought was excellent, I collected an RS5 on Sunday. First impressions are quite favourable and in my view it moves on several steps from where the RS4 left off. Road conditions just now are simply not suitable for anything other than careful progress but the performance such as I used was effortless and smooth as double cream.





...hi i just wanted to let you know if your interested the private plate RS58 OSS or RS5 8OSS, is available in the classifieds section under Audi RS5...

Cupramax

11,007 posts

283 months

Monday 3rd January 2011
quotequote all
Thats looks absolutely stunning, Sepang is the best colour ever!

Dr G

16,017 posts

273 months

Monday 3rd January 2011
quotequote all
That's a seriously nice looking car smile

Andyuk911

1,979 posts

240 months

Monday 3rd January 2011
quotequote all
lowndes said:
After 4 years with an RS4, which I thought was excellent, I collected an RS5 on Sunday. First impressions are quite favourable and in my view it moves on several steps from where the RS4 left off. Road conditions just now are simply not suitable for anything other than careful progress but the performance such as I used was effortless and smooth as double cream.
I have a Dyno 'Credit' with Surrey Rolling Road as I keen to understand what a production car outputs ... my RS4 was 390bhp which is consider high for a standard RS4.

How good is a RS5?

Only condition, you must be running it on Super unleaded ...

chrissyr32

736 posts

214 months

Tuesday 4th January 2011
quotequote all
Love my RS4 gonna keep it maybe another 18months...hopefully these beautys will be in my price range then???

That RS5 above looks great..love the wheels also...bet there a piece of piss to clean UNLIKE my RS4,s!!!!

DSLiverpool

16,577 posts

233 months

Wednesday 5th January 2011
quotequote all
Easy 10% off new E63 at the moment saloon or estate and low rate finance, quite tempting but Im not quite old enough to run one yet

B.J.W

5,877 posts

246 months

Wednesday 5th January 2011
quotequote all
Right, firstly I am not having a pop at the chap who has just bought a new RS5. Lovely motor in a great colour.

However, checking the prices on PH it would appear that well specced RS5's are currently changing hands for just shy of £70k!!!

Compare that to the circa £60k for a similarly well specced, low mileage 3 year old R8 V8.

Completely understand that having a brand new car parked on the drive appeals to some (each to their own etc), but I'd personally struggle to justify spending 10k more on a RS5 when I could have the R8.

Out of interest, what prompted the new purchase of the RS5? Was it a must have for you, or did you compare it to other vehicles (test drives etc)?

iluvmercs

7,541 posts

258 months

Wednesday 5th January 2011
quotequote all
Tha, Sir, is a beautiful motor car, in a stunning colour!
I agree with chrissyr32 on the alloy wheel cleaning! They do look a doddle.

Darren

Lostprophet

2,549 posts

200 months

Wednesday 5th January 2011
quotequote all
Not so sure about the RS5. Maybe it's the colour. It might look better in black?

lowndes

839 posts

245 months

Wednesday 5th January 2011
quotequote all
B.J.W said:
Right, firstly I am not having a pop at the chap who has just bought a new RS5. Lovely motor in a great colour.

However, checking the prices on PH it would appear that well specced RS5's are currently changing hands for just shy of £70k!!!

Compare that to the circa £60k for a similarly well specced, low mileage 3 year old R8 V8.

Completely understand that having a brand new car parked on the drive appeals to some (each to their own etc), but I'd personally struggle to justify spending 10k more on a RS5 when I could have the R8.

Out of interest, what prompted the new purchase of the RS5? Was it a must have for you, or did you compare it to other vehicles (test drives etc)?
No worries, quite understand the question.

But as my original post says, the RS5 replaces an RS4, which is no longer made. (An R8 is not really an option if you want a car that has 4 seats. And just on the R8 point it is in competition with a number of interesting 2 seat coupes at that price point and when push came to shove I went elsewhere to satisfy that particular requirement.)

Back to the RS5. As I said, I needed to replace the RS4, which was out of warranty and starting to develop niggling faults. Nothing too serious (DRC suspension, DRC headlights, clutch actuator etc,) but after 4 years I judged it time to move on. Absent a replacement RS4 the RS5 seemed the next nearest option. M3 a bit dated. AMG Merc not my style and I'm not sure whether either of them has double clutch and 4WD.

So not really a must have but rather a limited choice in a fairly thin field.

As for a new car on the drive, well someone has to take the hit on depreciation otherwise there would be no second hand bargains, and anyway it's tucked away in a garage out of sight most of the time.

Cheers

Edited by lowndes on Wednesday 5th January 17:57

B.J.W

5,877 posts

246 months

Wednesday 5th January 2011
quotequote all
lowndes said:
B.J.W said:
Right, firstly I am not having a pop at the chap who has just bought a new RS5. Lovely motor in a great colour.

However, checking the prices on PH it would appear that well specced RS5's are currently changing hands for just shy of £70k!!!

Compare that to the circa £60k for a similarly well specced, low mileage 3 year old R8 V8.

Completely understand that having a brand new car parked on the drive appeals to some (each to their own etc), but I'd personally struggle to justify spending 10k more on a RS5 when I could have the R8.

Out of interest, what prompted the new purchase of the RS5? Was it a must have for you, or did you compare it to other vehicles (test drives etc)?
No worries, quite understand the question.

But as my original post says, the RS5 replaces an RS4, which is no longer made. (An R8 is not really an option if you want a car that has 4 seats. And just on the R8 point it is in competition with a number of interesting 2 seat coupes at that price point and when push came to shove I went elsewhere to satisfy that particular requirement.)

Back to the RS5. As I said, I needed to replace the RS4, which was out of warranty and starting to develop niggling faults. Nothing too serious (DRC suspension, DRC headlights, clutch actuator etc,) but after 4 years I judged it time to move on. Absent a replacement RS4 the RS5 seemed the next nearest option. M3 a bit dated. AMG Merc not my style and I'm not sure whether either of them has double clutch and 4WD.

So not really a must have but rather a limited choice in a fairly thin field.

As for a new car on the drive, well someone has to take the hit on depreciation otherwise there would be no second hand bargains, and anyway it's tucked away in a garage out of sight most of the time.

Cheers

Edited by lowndes on Wednesday 5th January 17:57
Glad you took my post in the spirit in which it was intended. Let me know how you get on with the RS5. I have to say the reviews have turned me off the car a little, but I tend to be more interested in 'real life' ownership experiences, as opposed to magazine articles which can be a bit blinkered. I love the shape of the A5, so the RS5 would be a contender for me (as a daily driver) in a couple of years time if the extra practicality of the rear seats are required. Hope you enjoy the new car. As stated, it is a lovely motor.

scottyr

211 posts

269 months

Wednesday 5th January 2011
quotequote all
As you say, someone has to take the initial hit on new cars....

However, I've just paid 30k for a well spec'd 08 S5....for me....there is definitely no justification for spending another 30-40k on a new RS5.

The extra performance is minimal (and can be sorted for about 4k on the S5) and the handling isn't what it should be to make it worthwhile (and we're only talking track slinging here too).

But....if money was no object....it's always nice to have the King of the Ring so to speak :-)....

CJAldo

10 posts

193 months

Thursday 6th January 2011
quotequote all
Had my RS5 since early December, got to say having had twelve previous Audi's of which there have been two S3's, two S4's (both V8 and V6) and one S5 (V8)... the RS5 is awesome, by far the best car I have owned, I travel between East Yorkshire and Norfolk on a weekly basis, running through the roads from Caistor to Horncastle, great great fun!! The blue looks great, I was more in your face with the "discreet" red...