Nerd or Geek?
Author
Discussion

Jumpy Guy

Original Poster:

449 posts

250 months

Friday 29th October 2010
quotequote all
To settle an office debate, (I know, but it’s a Friday) have a think about two words, and their meanings;

Nerd
Geek

Which term is more positive, which is more ‘technical’, and could either be considered a compliment?

Cup of coffee rests on the answer....

Bibbs

3,754 posts

241 months

Friday 29th October 2010
quotequote all


ZOLLAR

19,920 posts

204 months

Friday 29th October 2010
quotequote all
Nerd i think is more computer technical etc.

Geek is somebody i think who has an obscure or perhaps a non obsure hobby but obsess over it i.e. people have called me a car geek because i have a slight obsession with them and know lot of information regarding the topic that the average person wouldn't biggrin

Edited by ZOLLAR on Friday 29th October 09:14

cal72

7,839 posts

201 months

Friday 29th October 2010
quotequote all
Nerd. glasses,lives with mummy,wears clothes his mum bought and into role playing games,carries a ruksack every where and wears a green parker.

Geek. into IT,Computers,models(trains,planes)has posters on bedroom of hot interlectual star trek stars(female)as no geek would be gay,lives in shared house with other geek type people and drinks dr pepper.

marshalla

15,902 posts

232 months

Friday 29th October 2010
quotequote all
A geek is a nerd with social skills.


An extrovert geek looks at your shoes when he's talking to you.

Sheets Tabuer

21,543 posts

246 months

Friday 29th October 2010
quotequote all
I thought the essentially meant the same thing, however I'd expect a geek to be in to electronics whilst enjoying warhammer and a nerd would be in to physics whilst enjoying dungeons and dragons hehe

briSk

14,291 posts

257 months

Friday 29th October 2010
quotequote all
I have always believed broadly the same as one or two others:

a nerd has some sort of technical proficiency / is 'brighter'
a geek is someone who online games too much, never opens the curtains, and in extremis has a samurai sword on the wall etc if they end up consuming the wrong chemicals might end up going into a school with a rifle.

but the reality is that they're interchangeable terms.

The Black Flash

13,735 posts

229 months

Friday 29th October 2010
quotequote all
Nerd is more of an insult IMO, whereas geek is often a bit of a compliment these days ("car geek" etc). I guess they were originally interchangeable, but you don't hear nerd much anymore.


Eric Mc

125,936 posts

296 months

Friday 29th October 2010
quotequote all
I am a nerd and a geek.

That should explain the two terms adequately.

Jumpy Guy

Original Poster:

449 posts

250 months

Friday 29th October 2010
quotequote all
hmmmm, no definitives there....

OK, put another way; if you are in one of these camps, which would you rather a hot female described you as?

Or male, obviously, depending on gender/orientation etc etc

(I know that PH has no real nerds or geeks, so you will all have to imagine..)

Dupont666

22,974 posts

223 months

Friday 29th October 2010
quotequote all
I always thought it was:

Nerd = intense interest and or fascination in an academic field.

aka



Geek = someone whos lifestyle or work has a niche aspect to it like IT.

easier way to see it would be:



HTH

Jumpy Guy

Original Poster:

449 posts

250 months

Friday 29th October 2010
quotequote all
That has to be the definitive Geek way of answering- the Venn diagram...

Or is it the Nerd way of answering?

Dupont666

22,974 posts

223 months

Friday 29th October 2010
quotequote all
Jumpy Guy said:
hmmmm, no definitives there....

OK, put another way; if you are in one of these camps, which would you rather a hot female described you as?

Or male, obviously, depending on gender/orientation etc etc

(I know that PH has no real nerds or geeks, so you will all have to imagine..)
My OH calls me her financial geek... I would mind, but she is a sexy nordic/scandinavian so I let her off...

Dupont666

22,974 posts

223 months

Friday 29th October 2010
quotequote all
Jumpy Guy said:
That has to be the definitive Geek way of answering- the Venn diagram...

Or is it the Nerd way of answering?
It was such an easy answer... you expected something different?

Original Poster

5,429 posts

207 months

Friday 29th October 2010
quotequote all
A nerd tends to be brighter.

Dupont666

22,974 posts

223 months

Friday 29th October 2010
quotequote all
Original Poster said:
A nerd tends to be brighter more anal about everything.
EFA

Justayellowbadge

37,057 posts

273 months

Friday 29th October 2010
quotequote all
Original Poster said:
A nerd tends to be brighter.
Geek girls are hotter.

Riknos

4,701 posts

235 months

Friday 29th October 2010
quotequote all
Dupont666 said:
'nuff said to be honest. Although the website is a 'geek' site (according to the url).. so may be a bit bias wink

onomatopoeia

3,526 posts

248 months

Friday 29th October 2010
quotequote all
cal72 said:
Nerd. glasses,lives with mummy,wears clothes his mum bought and into role playing games,carries a ruksack every where and wears a green parker.

Geek. into IT,Computers,models(trains,planes)has posters on bedroom of hot interlectual star trek stars(female)as no geek would be gay,lives in shared house with other geek type people and drinks dr pepper.
Lets see.

Nerd:
glasses - yes. I am intrigued as to why having defective vision is a qualification
lives with mummy - left home when I was 19, which is over 20 years ago, so no
wears clothes his mum bought - no
into role playing games - used to be, wouldn't rule it out in future
carries a ruksack every where - no
wears a green parker - no

Geek.
into IT,Computers - yes
models(trains,planes) - yes. OO/HO gauge, although I don't have a layout at present.
has posters on bedroom of hot interlectual star trek stars(female) - No. In my study I have posters from the films "Blue" (Juliette Binoche) and "Paris, Texas" (Nastassja Kinski). Neither were in Star Trek, as far as I know.
lives in shared house with other geek type people - no, I have a mortgage so I can live on my own
drinks dr pepper - drinks tea

So I seem to not qualify as either, even though I use both to describe myself.

Gaspode

4,167 posts

227 months

Friday 29th October 2010
quotequote all
I would say that 'Nerd' is usually used in a pejorative sense, whereas 'Geek' implies some sort of respect for the skills/abilities of the subject.