Battery dead - Should I relocate it?
Battery dead - Should I relocate it?
Author
Discussion

Tyre Tread

Original Poster:

10,697 posts

247 months

Sunday 31st October 2010
quotequote all
The battery on my Chim has died and I am considering fitting a gel battery and reloacting it either to the boot or one of the cubby holes behind the seats.

I've seen a couple of threads on relocating the battery and sounds reasonably straightforward but does anyone who has done this have any regrets about actually doing it or would you have done it any differently if your were doing it again?

tpowilson

13 posts

202 months

Sunday 31st October 2010
quotequote all
Tyre Tread: I found an alternative way of nurturing my Chim's battery and avoiding the grief of burrowing into the footwell to give remedial treatment; I fitted a battery cut-off switch inside the car and had an Anderson connector wired in to fit on the front top tube under the bonnet.
Actually, the battery disconnector seemed, at one fell swoop, to solve all the problems of the alarms/immobiliser draining most of the current while the car was unused during the week.
Because of the snow last winter I was unable to use the car for five whole weeks.
When the thaw finally allowed me to get into the garage and I switched on the electrics, it started at once. That was vindication!
I keep the Anderson jump leads in the boot as back-up...
Hth.
Tim.

Tyre Tread

Original Poster:

10,697 posts

247 months

Sunday 31st October 2010
quotequote all
I had already fitted the andersen connector and has the car on an optimate charger in a nice warm garage so its not about the battery going flat.

A number of issues: Footroom, Safety (acid on the feet in a crash and shorting) and neatness i.e not having the ecu and relays lying around in the footwell right next to the battery.

Pupp

13,035 posts

303 months

Monday 1st November 2010
quotequote all
Not sure you'll have much success with a gel battery unless you treat it asolutley with kid gloves (they won't tolerate the abuse a regular lead/acid job will). As for location, the oem location has drawbacks as you've mentioned but the place is decideded for weight distribution and sticking it in the boot or whatever goes against that. I also wouldn't want a major potential spark source right next to the fuel tank (especially for those that nick the rubber on the fuel cap) smile

In any crash impact bad enough to displace/disrupt the battery, I think the passenger's legs would have more to worrry about than a bit of acid rash...

Might actually be better to tidy the footwell wiring and relocate the ECU (the latter can go above the 'glovebox' flap with some crafty bracketry - keep meaning to put my Emerald one up there but it now seems pretty cosy next to the battery! wink

Cider Andy

1,889 posts

256 months

Monday 1st November 2010
quotequote all
tpowilson said:
I fitted a battery cut-off switch inside the car
Does that not cause an issue with insurance? My insurer expects the car to be fitted with its factory alarm and immobiliser.

Tyre Tread

Original Poster:

10,697 posts

247 months

Monday 1st November 2010
quotequote all
Pupp said:
Not sure you'll have much success with a gel battery unless you treat it asolutley with kid gloves (they won't tolerate the abuse a regular lead/acid job will). As for location, the oem location has drawbacks as you've mentioned but the place is decideded for weight distribution and sticking it in the boot or whatever goes against that. I also wouldn't want a major potential spark source right next to the fuel tank (especially for those that nick the rubber on the fuel cap) smile

In any crash impact bad enough to displace/disrupt the battery, I think the passenger's legs would have more to worrry about than a bit of acid rash...

Might actually be better to tidy the footwell wiring and relocate the ECU (the latter can go above the 'glovebox' flap with some crafty bracketry - keep meaning to put my Emerald one up there but it now seems pretty cosy next to the battery! wink
From what I've read the gel batteries ( I assume that's what they are - haven't got the link or name with me) are portrayed as being extremely robust and ideal for vehicles likely to be left standing for prolonged period, can be mounted in any orientation other than completely inverted and are much more powerful than a lead acid battery therfore requiring a smaller and lighter alternative. More expensive, obviously.

As for the weight distibution, surely that will change every time I put a bag in the boot/back shelf/passenger seat or even if I put on or lose a few pounds so I don't see that it would make a significant difference for a road car although, every little helps.

As for sparks, I can't imagine there's much in the boot to short the terminals. I was thinking of mounting high up on the n/s wheel arch.

The ECU could well be munted just below the fuse box (Whose idea was it to put the fuse box there?)

Pupp

13,035 posts

303 months

Monday 1st November 2010
quotequote all
Tyre Tread said:
I was thinking of mounting high up on the n/s wheel arch.
Should launch from there quite nicely on any decent frontal impact; just what your passenger wants in the back of their neck... smile

spend

12,581 posts

282 months

Monday 1st November 2010
quotequote all
Think of weight distribution as moments about the roll axis rather than a 2d plan. Going outside the front and rear roll centres is probably the greatest detriment IMHO, low & within the 4 wheels the best as a simplified rule?

It also makes sense when you have to pack up the car in where you choose to locate heavy/light items wink

Tyre Tread

Original Poster:

10,697 posts

247 months

Monday 1st November 2010
quotequote all
Pupp said:
Tyre Tread said:
I was thinking of mounting high up on the n/s wheel arch.
Should launch from there quite nicely on any decent frontal impact; just what your passenger wants in the back of their neck... smile
From being contained within the boot I think that's pretty unlikely.

link to batteries: http://www.odysseybatteriesonline.co.uk/index.php?...

Milky400

1,960 posts

209 months

Monday 1st November 2010
quotequote all
So which would be suitable? my batt just died 4 months after warrenty

Tyre Tread

Original Poster:

10,697 posts

247 months

Monday 1st November 2010
quotequote all
I was looking at this topic : http://www.pistonheads.com/gassing/topic.asp?h=0&a...

recommends a PC925

Belchy

89 posts

204 months

Monday 1st November 2010
quotequote all
Hi,

Relocated a full sized 072 lead acid battery to behind the passenger seat in my griff this summer.Mainly for leg room on the run up from Hants to Blackpool for the BNG! with a 6'4" co driver.
made a little shelf extension in folded alu .Bolted this to the floor and secured the batt to the shelf with a tie down type strap.Extended the batt and starter cables,fitted ecu below the fuse panel.The seat had to go a couple of clicks foward but i gained alot more than i lost and lanky co driver could stretch his legs out in comfort(im 5'10" and my feet don't reach the end now).Could fit a decent 075 batt in future and gain even more space.
Didn't put it in boot for possible rear impact safety, weight distribution and cos griff boot is small enough already!
Stayed with lead acid cos they can be charged from fully flat if aciddently discharged and cos well i had one already and im a cheap skate!

Shout if anyone wants pics!!

hope this helps,


Belchy

Pupp

13,035 posts

303 months

Monday 1st November 2010
quotequote all
Tyre Tread said:
Pupp said:
Tyre Tread said:
I was thinking of mounting high up on the n/s wheel arch.
Should launch from there quite nicely on any decent frontal impact; just what your passenger wants in the back of their neck... smile
From being contained within the boot I think that's pretty unlikely.
Your stated battery is stated to weigh 12kg; in only a 30mph impact with something fairly solid it will have momentum that will impart something like 40 times that force.... still trust that boot? smile

Milky400

1,960 posts

209 months

Monday 1st November 2010
quotequote all

A tissue box on the parcel shelf at 40mph can hit you with the eqiv weight/force of a brick, personally i would leave it be!!!!

Tyre Tread

Original Poster:

10,697 posts

247 months

Monday 1st November 2010
quotequote all
Not trying to be pedantic here but surely if its secured (i.e. Bolted on a bracket behind the rear wheel in the arch in the boot its less likely to hit me than the petrol tank or the speakers?

Pupp

13,035 posts

303 months

Tuesday 2nd November 2010
quotequote all
Tyre Tread said:
Not trying to be pedantic here but surely if its secured (i.e. Bolted on a bracket behind the rear wheel in the arch in the boot its less likely to hit me than the petrol tank or the speakers?
Not sure there's that much there to bolt it to Alan. It's a (relatively) massive (in the physical sense) object that will have enormous inertia of its own if the car comes to crunching stop. Speakers are tiny in comparison and relatively well supported by the bulkhead (although you're right, I wouldn't want to be clouted by a typical 6x9 if it managed to come through). The fuel tank, even full, is much less dense and has a much larger area supported by the bulkhead to absorb impact loadings. An object of the size and mass of a typical car battery from that location might well come out upwards (through the boot lid) and forward (through the rear screen); think about Spend's comments earlier about roll centres and visualise what the car will do on direct frontal impact. Not saying it cannot be done effectively but there's loads more to it than managing to glue a bracket that can take the static load to the boot side. It's a fundamentally flawed location for that reason and the fact it's additional mass behind the rear axle but that's not to say the footwell is perfect for the reasons we all know.

BenRelle

1,796 posts

205 months

Tuesday 2nd November 2010
quotequote all
see the bottom of this page: http://www.dulfordauto.co.uk/content/latest-tvr-ne...

Don't know how solidly this is mounted, but might be worth asking these guys a couple of questions.