Religion Vs Quantum Physics
Religion Vs Quantum Physics
Author
Discussion

thinfourth2

Original Poster:

32,414 posts

235 months

Monday 1st November 2010
quotequote all
Both are to me deeply silly when you look into how they explain the universe.


God sayes let there be light and a Universe pops into existence

Where as the physicists say the big bang created the universe which just popped out of nowhere from nothing and there was nothing before this not even time.


So which sounds the most bonkers to you

Murdoc

364 posts

220 months

Monday 1st November 2010
quotequote all
I watched a program a few weeks ago horizon I believe they were discussing multiple theories on what came before the big bang, not everybody subscribes to the "there was nothing" theory. Also I watched a video with Richard Dawkins explaining that the universe is equal parts matter and anti-matter together they equal nothing, so it wasn't something from nothing. Overall it isn't something, it is nothing.

Sorry it was Lawrence Krauss introduced by Dawkins: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7ImvlS8PLIo


Edited by Murdoc on Monday 1st November 20:15

williamssam

733 posts

251 months

Monday 1st November 2010
quotequote all
Have you got a better explanation to the origin of the universe? The big bang seems fairly logical when you look at the reasons for it's existence as a theory. I'm not saying it's fact but it does make some sense and I'm open to the possibility. As for god creating the universe....

Petrolhead_Rich

4,659 posts

223 months

Monday 1st November 2010
quotequote all
thinfourth2 said:
Both are to me deeply silly when you look into how they explain the universe.


God sayes let there be light and a Universe pops into existence

Where as the physicists say the big bang created the universe which just popped out of nowhere from nothing and there was nothing before this not even time.


So which sounds the most bonkers to you?
Your Speeling.... thumbup

thinfourth2

Original Poster:

32,414 posts

235 months

Monday 1st November 2010
quotequote all
Petrolhead_Rich said:
Your Speeling.... thumbup
You sad little man who spends his time looking at others spelling

Hope you find a life soon

Mars

10,169 posts

245 months

Monday 1st November 2010
quotequote all
The universe is observably expanding. It's not a massive leap of faith to track the movements back to a single point source.

The bit about there only being time when there are observable events does my fruit though. This precludes there being any time outside of the universe (it has a finite limit) or before the big bang.

In fact, there's a couple of other statements I can't get my head around, such as:

1. You cannot go "outside" of the universe. You cannot go to the edge of where all matter has reached since moving away from the big bang, and step outside of it. Why?

2. If there was a big bang, shouldn't ALL the matter be the same distance from the point where it all started? Rather like the balloon "skin". However, the entire universe appears to be fairly equally spaced. How?


I don't believe in there being a god/God but I can't help wonder if he's just having a laugh at me. smile

Mars

10,169 posts

245 months

Monday 1st November 2010
quotequote all
By the way, quantum physics is all about atoms and particles and other teeny tiny stuff.

twazzock

1,930 posts

200 months

Monday 1st November 2010
quotequote all
Petrolhead_Rich said:
thinfourth2 said:
Both are to me deeply silly when you look into how they explain the universe.


God sayes let there be light and a Universe pops into existence

Where as the physicists say the big bang created the universe which just popped out of nowhere from nothing and there was nothing before this not even time.


So which sounds the most bonkers to you?
Your Speeling.... thumbup
Physicists is spelt correctly, you dunce.

redtwin

7,518 posts

213 months

Monday 1st November 2010
quotequote all
I have reached the stage in life where I no longer ask questions that no-one has the answers to. It took a while to get here, but I am glad I am here now. This is particularly useful when you realise that knowing the answers to those questions will be of absolutely no practical use to you.

inman999

34,954 posts

204 months

Monday 1st November 2010
quotequote all
Atleast scientists are man enough to admit their ramblings are only theories.

MadOne

821 posts

199 months

Monday 1st November 2010
quotequote all
I think no one will ever know the answer to this question. It's just whatever you believe. Personally, I have never accepted the big bang theory. God sounds such a better option. Nobody knows whether he really does exist and did create the world but given the choices, I would choose to believe that one.

pano amo

814 posts

267 months

Monday 1st November 2010
quotequote all
While I side with the scientists on their theories, there is something tragically sad if we end up finding out once and for all that there is no God or anything like it. I'm not religious but I hope scientists are all wrong. I'd much rather move on after this life to something else, wouldnt you? smile

Good point about God having a laugh with us!

AlfaFoxtrot

407 posts

229 months

Monday 1st November 2010
quotequote all
Murdoc said:
I watched a program a few weeks ago horizon I believe they were discussing multiple theories on what came before the big bang, not everybody subscribes to the "there was nothing" theory. Also I watched a video with Richard Dawkins explaining that the universe is equal parts matter and anti-matter together they equal nothing, so it wasn't something from nothing. Overall it isn't something, it is nothing.

Sorry it was Lawrence Krauss introduced by Dawkins: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7ImvlS8PLIo


Edited by Murdoc on Monday 1st November 20:15
From what is currently known, there is today a massive imbalance of matter:antimatter. At the big bang it is theorised that they were present in equal quantities to begin with, but something happened to favour normal matter...Look up CP violation.

Tadite

560 posts

215 months

Monday 1st November 2010
quotequote all
You're trying to prove theoretical physics.

You can't prove god.


branflakes

2,039 posts

269 months

Monday 1st November 2010
quotequote all
pano amo said:
I'd much rather move on after this life to something else, wouldnt you? smile
I'd rather make something of this life than waste time worrying about fairy tales of an afterlife.

zollburgers

1,285 posts

214 months

Monday 1st November 2010
quotequote all
Who created God? Same problem with both theories - something from nothing.

I prefer to believe the ever evolving theory of scientists rather than the ramblings of people some 2000 years ago (or older depending on which fantasy you subscribe to). We were still burning witches just a few hundred years ago don't forget. Did we manage to kill all witches or were the people just fking idiots for believing in primitive crap? I can see similarities with believing in God. Probably because it's exactly the same!

williamssam

733 posts

251 months

Monday 1st November 2010
quotequote all
MadOne said:
I think no one will ever know the answer to this question. It's just whatever you believe. Personally, I have never accepted the big bang theory. God sounds such a better option. Nobody knows whether he really does exist and did create the world but given the choices, I would choose to believe that one.
Out of interest, why do you not accept the big bang theory? At what point does the theory break down, and what do you know that the physicists don't? Or do you disagree with it because you have 'faith'? I'd personally rather open my mind to the wonderful possibilities that scientific theories offer us and where it might take us in the future than just resign myself to believing in god - that's just too easy.


Edited by williamssam on Monday 1st November 21:42

cymtriks

4,561 posts

276 months

Monday 1st November 2010
quotequote all
thinfourth2 said:
Both are to me deeply silly when you look into how they explain the universe.
Or perhaps they are both very good theories given the context in which they are stated.

The big bang does sound a bit contrived. Nothing becoming everything which, for some unknown reason, then explodes. However it is the best fit to the observations we've made.

Creation was a perfectly reasonable explanation in circa 1000 BC. The events happen in roughly the right order;

1 verse 1 to 5 : the solar system forms
1 verse 6 to 10 : the primordial Earth
1 verse 11 to 13 : plant life
1 verse 14 to 19 : the solar systen now noted as complete and celestial bodies as markers of time
1 verse 20 to 23 : fish and birds
1 verse 24, 25 : land animals
1 verse 26, 27, 28 : people
2 verse 8 to 22 : the founders of the tribe make their first settlement (note that they are the first people from a tribal point of view)
2 verse 23 to 24 : the first settlement is abandoned (the angel with a sword of fire could be volcanic activity)

Considering the knowledge they had at the time the order they ended up with is not a bad attempt.

ewenm

28,506 posts

276 months

Monday 1st November 2010
quotequote all
thinfourth2 said:
Both are to me deeply silly when you look into how they explain the universe.

God sayes let there be light and a Universe pops into existence
A statement that cannot be tested - not something to rely on to explain the universe, but a very easy "out" for those who want it.

thinfourth2 said:
Where as the physicists say the big bang created the universe which just popped out of nowhere from nothing and there was nothing before this not even time.
Is one theory. There are others, all of which people are trying to test, trying to refine and trying to tie the very small (quantum physics) with the very large (gravity) into a single theory. Not easy, not simple, not surprisingly difficult to understand.

Key for me is progression, development, refinement, refutation, debate, method, testable predictions.

NismoGT

1,634 posts

221 months

Monday 1st November 2010
quotequote all
thinfourth2 said:
Where as the physicists say the big bang created the universe which just popped out of nowhere from nothing and there was nothing before this not even time.
How much do you know about Quantum Physics?