How to proceed and deal with the situation?
How to proceed and deal with the situation?
Author
Discussion

fizz876

Original Poster:

3,252 posts

241 months

Monday 1st November 2010
quotequote all
This is a little long winded and a slightly difficult to explain but am in a bit of a quandary and pissed off at the same time

What is the the best way to proceed in this situation and how should I deal with it?

With the knowledge through all your vast directorships wink I'm hoping some of you can help resolve the issue.

Anyway last week I called my mobile phone operator (one of the biggest ones) in regards to a replacement phone as mine had developed a fault. They offered me a choice of three different phones as I was suffering from a reoccurring fault with my original phone. As I was not sure which phone I should get out of my choices I decided to do a little research first and the customer services rep said that’s not a problem and put my request on hold. Due to being busy at work and family commitments I didn’t get back to them until two days later.

So I called up customer services again and when I requested the phone I wanted out of the original choice I was given the response of 'Sorry sir, but we cant do that and we wont do that as the phone you want is better than your current one but instead we can offer you these other phones'

Now these other phones are over two years old and there is not a chance I would exchange for them as quite frankly they are ste and I make heavy use of my mobile for work purposes. I explained how I was offered the other phone and was told that I must be making it up as their company wouldn’t do such a thing. I got a little annoyed at this but wasn’t rude or impolite but quite firm that that could this matter be looked into. After huffing and puffing he finally agreed that he will get his superior to call me back later. This was the end of the conversation and roughly took place at 1.00 pm

6 hours later I receive a call from the same customer service rep and he starts of straight saying 'Hi, its Joe Blogs from the phone company, your new replacement phone is on its way and as a gesture of goodwill we can do your upgrade now which we discussed earlier'.

At this point I'm a little confused as I hadn’t ordered a new phone or discussed any sort of upgrade. I ask him what is he talking about as I didn’t order a new phone or even hint at the possibility of an upgrade. He replies 'I spoke to you earlier on today when I called you.'

So I asked him what time did you call me and what happened in this conversation. He then say he called me at about 3.30pm and again a few minutes after that. I asked him are you sure that you dialled my number and he was adamant he did.

I'm thinking something fishy is going on here as I was in a meeting at the time with plenty of other people with my phone lying in front of me and at no time did I take any calls. I quickly check my call log and can see I have definitely not received any calls during the time he said. In fact I had not received any calls since 9.30am that morning. I then asked him did he carry out and security checks and he replied saying of course and he gave the correct address and the password on the account. At this point I'm getting a little angry because I know have never ever written down or given my phone password to anyone yet apparently the person he spoke to gave all the correct information.

At this point I believe the phone company must have broken Data Protection Rules as they seem to have orderd a new phone and were sending it to my registered address. I quickly told him to cancel the delivery of the phone and want this matter investigated. He said its too late to cancel the delivery, which I said fine but I wont accept the delivery as it appears to me you have given my details out to a random stranger. I told him to ask his manager to call me.


A few hours later I receive a call from the manager and I state my case:

1) I have not ordered any replacement phones.
2) I believe your colleague may have broken Data Protection rules by not carrying out the proper security checks and given my person details including home address out to a stranger.
3) I have not received any calls from your company whatsoever.

He agrees to investigate and call me back later.

Fast forward a couple of days and I receive a call from the manger.

To put it simply they wont investigate the matter any further as he has looked at his out going call log list and it shows my number was dialled at the alleged time they stated and believes they would never have broken DPA laws and I must of spoken to someone and I'm making this all up.

I asked him if they had recordings of the call. He replies 'No'. I then asked do they keep a log of call duration. He says 'No'. So basically every house hold and mobile phone owner can get copies of call duration and itemised bills but one of the largest telecommunications companies in the world doesn’t hold this information?

We went around in circles for a little while and basically he said he wont look into the matter further as he believes I spoke to someone when their customer services called me and basically I'm a liar or a little crazy. I asked for a written letter on how they have dealt with my complaint and he refused so I said I want to speak to his manager as I wasn’t satisfied with the outcome of his investigation.

So his manager is calling me tomorrow and am wondering how best to deal with this situation.

I am not looking for any compensation or crap like that but purely concerned that a) my personal info could have been given to anyone and b)who was the actually person they spoke to if indeed they spoke to anyone at all?

How should I proceed with this? Some people have suggested I should contact the Information Commissioners office who deal with Data Protection Issues?

AndrewW-G

11,968 posts

248 months

Monday 1st November 2010
quotequote all
somebody screwed up, as long as you end up with the phone you wanted out of the original offer, I wouldnt be losing sleep over it smile

Stevenj214

4,941 posts

259 months

Monday 1st November 2010
quotequote all
fizz876 said:
How should I proceed with this?
I think you should definitely speak to the manager who is calling you tomorrow. You never know, they may sort it to your satisfaction.

On the issue of things like data protection, I would miss that out unless you actually know what you're talking about. State facts only. "The customer service rep claimed he spoke to me twice at Time A and Time B. I received no calls at that time." not "If he spoke to someone that wasn't me then he probably likely broke the data disability protection act 1999".

gilla

19,746 posts

221 months

Monday 1st November 2010
quotequote all
swear a lot, shout, scream, threaten the managers family... Mafia style... Tell him you know where he lives, send dead animal parts, shag his wife etc etc.

Or you could just get the phone you want out of it. Be careful that by doing so they don't put you on a new 24 month contract... They tend to do this when they call it an "upgrade"

fizz876

Original Poster:

3,252 posts

241 months

Monday 1st November 2010
quotequote all
I like the suggestion of sending dead animals smile

To be honest though I don't care about the phone now. My contract is up in three months. I'm now more pissed off on how they are blatantly lying or covering something by claiming they called me and spoke to me.

I'm now have my old grumpy hat on and this has turned into one of those 'its the principle that matters'.


TheEnd

15,370 posts

219 months

Monday 1st November 2010
quotequote all
I assume there was no call, the guy just ticked a box and ordered an upgrade on your behalf, his boss is lying to cover it up.

I think that leaves your options just as a like for like replacement as before, and if that doesn't happen, get onto ofmobile or whoever has the job of ass-kicking.


AndrewTait

1,849 posts

225 months

Monday 1st November 2010
quotequote all
If you genuinely believe that they have broken the DPA, then contact the Information Commissioners Office, and let them investigate it. They won't take any BS off them.

Alternatively, just give it up, and move on, get the phone you have been offered, and get on with life!

I Love Lamp

2,664 posts

206 months

Monday 1st November 2010
quotequote all
Hi OP

Firstly, your mobile phone provider is talking bks as 1) They do record all phone calls, 2) Within 24 hours they have a record of all dialled numbers and 3) they are also able to provide information on unanswered and incoming calls.

Cutting a very long explanation short, as this is my industry and full of jargon, which is boring, tell them to Foxtrot Oscar and take your business elsewhere.

They're clearly talking st and hoping you'll just back down. Providing you haven't now been forced into a new contract (even if you have, you'll have a 14 day 'cooling off period' due to long distance selling act) you have nothing to gain and it really won't be worth your time.

HTH

Sonic

4,008 posts

238 months

Monday 1st November 2010
quotequote all
TheEnd said:
I assume there was no call, the guy just ticked a box and ordered an upgrade on your behalf, his boss is lying to cover it up.
+1. Sounds pretty st, i'd follow the advice above.

The Moose

23,709 posts

240 months

Tuesday 2nd November 2010
quotequote all
The problem I've got after reading all your post, it now sounds like you're not really sure what you want out of this phone call etc.

The first time - fair enough - you wanted your selected phone etc etc etc.

Now, what do you actually want to happen. I would imagine it's probably for the best to mention this at some point in the conversation.

Maybe change the phone password also (call and speak to someone independent) to a really random set of numbers and letters. Assuming matey is going to call you, if he 'calls' but you don't speak to him then there is no chance. Write this down and keep it on you and then when all done, change it again.

The other thing you can do is call again and request to speak to the person who made the offer in the first place (should be a time and date log somewhere) and if you're terminally pleasant, they will probably put you through.

Cheers

The Moose

fizz876

Original Poster:

3,252 posts

241 months

Tuesday 2nd November 2010
quotequote all
The Moose said:
The problem I've got after reading all your post, it now sounds like you're not really sure what you want out of this phone call etc.

The first time - fair enough - you wanted your selected phone etc etc etc.

Now, what do you actually want to happen. I would imagine it's probably for the best to mention this at some point in the conversation.

Maybe change the phone password also (call and speak to someone independent) to a really random set of numbers and letters. Assuming matey is going to call you, if he 'calls' but you don't speak to him then there is no chance. Write this down and keep it on you and then when all done, change it again.

The other thing you can do is call again and request to speak to the person who made the offer in the first place (should be a time and date log somewhere) and if you're terminally pleasant, they will probably put you through.

Cheers

The Moose
You are right ..I'm not entirly sure now and if I was giving this advice to anyone else I would say forget about it and move on but this has really got on my nerves that such a big company can come up with such blatant rubbish and then try and cover it up.

I just now want to get on to the bottom of this and know are they either A) covering up the fact they didnt call me or B) they did call someone but a total random stranger and dont want to admit their mistake. What gets me the most is they keep implying that I'm making this up and the more they say it the more I want to get to the bottom of this.


pits

6,704 posts

221 months

Tuesday 2nd November 2010
quotequote all
Customer service akin to that of the mobile phone provider whose colour is orange.

Although the other similar colour one tried ringing me the other day, I have 5 phones on the package.
Ring house get my mum, the guy is really stty asking which number on the package is mine, mum tells her no, not handing out numbers over the phone, the guy then replies, he will ring every phone on the package and discover whose phone is who.


fizz876

Original Poster:

3,252 posts

241 months

Tuesday 2nd November 2010
quotequote all
pits said:
Customer service akin to that of the mobile phone provider whose colour is orange.
They are useless and for a household who spends over £700 per month on mobile phone bills from them it's not great that they start making up their own stories....

Parrot of Doom

23,075 posts

265 months

Tuesday 2nd November 2010
quotequote all
You should do what I did. Buy the phone you want, unlocked, SIM-free. Then get a rolling 30-day contract with a provider of your choice.

pits

6,704 posts

221 months

Tuesday 2nd November 2010
quotequote all
Or just not deal with the company whose main logo is the colour orange, they are one of the most vile companies I have ever had the misfortune to deal with, nearly up there with Close motor finance actually any Close finance company

hairyben

8,516 posts

214 months

Tuesday 2nd November 2010
quotequote all
Parrot of Doom said:
You should do what I did. Buy the phone you want, unlocked, SIM-free. Then get a rolling 30-day contract with a provider of your choice.
^this.

o2 gave me BS about replacing an out-of-contract in-warrentee monthly-insurance-paid not-particularly-expensive phone.

Later that day my £40/month became £10/month. The balence buys you a) a lot of phone or b) a nice phone + lots of beer.

If your provider is orange, they have external resellers who can offer deals/phones etc orange themselves can't, who routinely pretend to represent orange which is something they don't seem bothered by. I daresay you've spoken to one of these.

fizz876

Original Poster:

3,252 posts

241 months

Tuesday 2nd November 2010
quotequote all
hairyben said:
Parrot of Doom said:
You should do what I did. Buy the phone you want, unlocked, SIM-free. Then get a rolling 30-day contract with a provider of your choice.
^this.

o2 gave me BS about replacing an out-of-contract in-warrentee monthly-insurance-paid not-particularly-expensive phone.

Later that day my £40/month became £10/month. The balence buys you a) a lot of phone or b) a nice phone + lots of beer.

If your provider is orange, they have external resellers who can offer deals/phones etc orange themselves can't, who routinely pretend to represent orange which is something they don't seem bothered by. I daresay you've spoken to one of these.
No fortunately they are not a reseller and I spoke to customer services direct and thankfully someone in the UK- however I am now think they are just as useless and like to make up things as they go along.

freecar

4,249 posts

218 months

Tuesday 2nd November 2010
quotequote all
This is simple.

If an upgrade or new contract, they are subject to a cooling off period.

Cancel any phone that arrives and take your business elsewhere.

After cancellation, send a letter to the customer complaint dept, then ofcom.

Zod

35,295 posts

289 months

Tuesday 2nd November 2010
quotequote all
Learn to precis or nobody will take any notice.

MacW

1,352 posts

207 months

Tuesday 2nd November 2010
quotequote all
If they're telling the truth about not having duration/recording of the conversations I suspect they are getting the data from their call centre management software, ask them to check the received calls to your mobile number on their network management software.

If you tell them where you were at those times they will be able to (at the very least) confirm or deny that your number was answered at those times, was connected to a mast nearby your location and what the duration of those calls was.