Poppies

Poll: Poppies

Total Members Polled: 484

Yes: 93%
No: 7%
Author
Discussion

joe_90

Original Poster:

4,206 posts

262 months

Wednesday 3rd November 2010
quotequote all
I have noticed that Im the only one in the office with a Poppy, then seem to get less and less each year.. Even though Im totally against the wars, I still want to give money to support all the troops, especially the ones that fought/died in the the 2 great real wars (for what I consider fighting for country, not fighting on some tard politician whim/sexed up intel).

Its a mark of respect, and to show that you remember what they gave for our freedom.

/edited as someone put it better.

Just interested in thoughts really.

Edited by joe_90 on Wednesday 3rd November 10:52

sday12

5,068 posts

242 months

Wednesday 3rd November 2010
quotequote all
[troll]That will be the western war machine and it's hatred of islam[/troll]

bigmac146

184 posts

219 months

Wednesday 3rd November 2010
quotequote all
I think the poppies mean a lot to the older generation and show respect for what they helped to avoid. i cant see how our country would cope if something like that ever happened again

kambites

71,713 posts

252 months

Wednesday 3rd November 2010
quotequote all
I don't see the point in poppies, really. If I want to give money to a charity then I will give money to a charity. Buying a stupid plastic flower just means that less of my money goes to the charity and more of it goes to stupid plastic flower makers.

Countdown

49,579 posts

227 months

Wednesday 3rd November 2010
quotequote all
Kambites - I think the "standard" poppies are made by the Royal British Legion, so the money does go back to where its intended. However apparently there are some poppies (jewellery encrusted ones) selling for £85 - I do think that's a bit over the top smile

Definitely in favour of wearing poppies - the school that I went to was the old fashioned type and every Friday before Remembrance Day there was a special assembly where they read out the names of former pupils who had died in the 2 world wars. Future generations should be reminded of the sacrifices of our predecessors.

Mr MoJo

4,698 posts

247 months

Wednesday 3rd November 2010
quotequote all
yes

Galileo

3,147 posts

249 months

Wednesday 3rd November 2010
quotequote all
olly22n said:
kambites said:
I don't see the point in poppies, really. If I want to give money to a charity then I will give money to a charity. Buying a stupid plastic flower just means that less of my money goes to the charity and more of it goes to stupid plastic flower makers.
Its a mark of respect, and to show that you remember what they gave for our freedom.

I wear mine very proudly.
Well said.

Tow Vehicle Rqrd

1,217 posts

214 months

Wednesday 3rd November 2010
quotequote all
Galileo said:
olly22n said:
kambites said:
I don't see the point in poppies, really. If I want to give money to a charity then I will give money to a charity. Buying a stupid plastic flower just means that less of my money goes to the charity and more of it goes to stupid plastic flower makers.
Its a mark of respect, and to show that you remember what they gave for our freedom.

I wear mine very proudly.
Well said.
My Dad did some work in the Star & Garter home in Richmond a few years ago, and came home each night both traumatised and inspired. Anyone who questions the point of poppies should take a long, hard look at that place!

kambites

71,713 posts

252 months

Wednesday 3rd November 2010
quotequote all
I make no comments on the validity of the cause, just the purpose of showing an outward "mark of respect" once a year on a particular date. Having a "day to show respect" seems to imply to me that you shouldn't at other times of year, which rather trivialises the whole thing and seems rather sad to me.

ETA: I have nothing against other people wearing them, obviously, but I wont myself.

Edited by kambites on Wednesday 3rd November 11:07

Doniger

1,975 posts

197 months

Wednesday 3rd November 2010
quotequote all
I think a lot of people under the age of 40 who wouldn't be alive today but for the efforts of those who fought the WWs are either unaware of the fact or just don't care as they think it could never happen again.

Either way, I wouldn't have been born and I never forget that. Proud poppy wearer right here.

joe_90

Original Poster:

4,206 posts

262 months

Wednesday 3rd November 2010
quotequote all
bigmac146 said:
I think the poppies mean a lot to the older generation and show respect for what they helped to avoid. i cant see how our country would cope if something like that ever happened again
Chav/pikey cannon fodder as the first wave.. Or would it be against their Human Rights..

swiftpete

1,894 posts

224 months

Wednesday 3rd November 2010
quotequote all
kambites said:
I make no comments on the validity of the cause, just the purpose of showing an outward "mark of respect" once a year on a particular date. Having a "day to show respect" seems to imply to me that you shouldn't at other times of year, which rather trivialises the whole thing and seems rather sad to me.

ETA: I have nothing against other people wearing them, obviously, but I wont myself.

Edited by kambites on Wednesday 3rd November 11:07
Wearing the poppy also helps to remind other people that it's remembrance day and probably inspires/reminds them to contribute a bit by buying poppies themselves.

MonkeyBusiness

4,264 posts

218 months

Wednesday 3rd November 2010
quotequote all
Absolutely. Never, ever, ever, forget.

goforbroke

937 posts

249 months

Wednesday 3rd November 2010
quotequote all
My son has a poppy, he found it in Asda car park. He is only 3, and doesnt understand what it is for yet, but he wouldnt let me have it to wear as he wanted to show it to his friends this afternoon. He was very protective of it, and told me to buy my own one...which I duly have.

Neil1300R

5,787 posts

209 months

Wednesday 3rd November 2010
quotequote all
Always wear a poppy. Not currently as its too early. ONLY supposed to be worn from the start of the week before Remembrance Day. Bloody stupid BBC staff been wearing them for weeks.

carmadgaz

3,204 posts

214 months

Wednesday 3rd November 2010
quotequote all
I have one but I don't tend to wear it, last year I managed to get through 4 or 5 as they keep falling off / forgetting to move them from shirt to shirt (yes I'm a 'tard like that).

I do have a car sticker on the truck (and will have another for the Escort tomorrow) and in 13years I have only missed 1 Parade.

We should never forget.

Groober

775 posts

211 months

Wednesday 3rd November 2010
quotequote all
I don't tend to wear one tbh but I always donate to the cause.

MixxyMatosis

388 posts

200 months

Wednesday 3rd November 2010
quotequote all
I always wear a poppy and I always will. I'm only 24 and I understand and I encourage others to have the same respect.

King David

732 posts

217 months

Wednesday 3rd November 2010
quotequote all
I think it is very important, not only giving to the charity but also as a sign of remembrance. Having said that the silly stickers they have on them this year mean they keep falling off. I need to find one with a proper pin!

The sacrifices that were (and are still being) made are worthy of our respect.

aclivity

4,072 posts

219 months

Wednesday 3rd November 2010
quotequote all
they gave their all,
And giving, won
The Peace of Heaven and Immortality.
Our hearts go out to them in boundless gratitude:
If ours – then God’s: for his vast charity
All sees, All knows, All comprehends – save bounds.
He has repaid their sacrifice – and we – ?
God help us if we fail to pay our debt
In fullest full and all unstintingly.


John Oxenham