Winter is coming - the what cheap winter snotter thread!
Winter is coming - the what cheap winter snotter thread!
Author
Discussion

Rollcage

Original Poster:

11,345 posts

215 months

Sunday 7th November 2010
quotequote all
Winter is very nearly upon us, so in the interest of keeping mobile in the event of a repeat of last year's weather what do we think the best winter snotter would be?

It should be four wheel drive and be cheap to run, so sadly rules out Range Rovers and Jeeps!

I was thinking of some sort of Subaru, or a cheap Audi quattro of one form or another. In a perfect world it would be diesel, estate, manual, 4wd and cost less than a bag, and preferably less than £500. It would be used when the weather was bad and I need to get to work, or of course when the weather is bad and I want to have some fun!

In the end I saw a cheap Honda CR-V, and have bought that, but i'm not sure I'll keep it, as I would like something a little more PH.

Any other suggestions?

Deranged Granny

2,322 posts

191 months

Sunday 7th November 2010
quotequote all
I never had a problem with my MK4 Fiesta smile

DAVEVO9

3,469 posts

290 months

Sunday 7th November 2010
quotequote all
Would be a lot cheaper to get some winter tyres fitted?

Rollcage

Original Poster:

11,345 posts

215 months

Sunday 7th November 2010
quotequote all
Deranged Granny said:
I never had a problem with my MK4 Fiesta smile
And neither did I in my Alfa 166 V6 auto, but you just never know!

silver surfer

480 posts

231 months

Sunday 7th November 2010
quotequote all
Any...as long it has winter tyres

SS

Rollcage

Original Poster:

11,345 posts

215 months

Sunday 7th November 2010
quotequote all
DAVEVO9 said:
Would be a lot cheaper to get some winter tyres fitted?
The Honda was £300. I'm not talking about blowing thousands here biggrin

NiceCupOfTea

25,536 posts

274 months

Monday 8th November 2010
quotequote all
Good thread.

I have been thinking about this and torn between something like a Peugeot 306 / Rover 200 diesel (reasonable to drive, economical, cheap, can do distances), or a cheap 4x4 (cope with all the winter weather easily, but could be expensive to run), or go with a subaru forester or something (best of both worlds?).

To be honest though, it's the expense of an extra insurance policy, mot, tax etc. Let's face it, insurance is going to be £500+ on anything if you are starting with no NCB...

Rollcage

Original Poster:

11,345 posts

215 months

Monday 8th November 2010
quotequote all
It is a bit of an extravagance, I'll admit, but just knowing that you are unlikely to be phased by even the most adverse conditions would be worth the cost IMO - and a decent sized estate with a towbar is always useful to have. Anyway, I gave up getting drunk many moons ago - spunking all my spare money on cars has been something of a habit for many years now!

On the diesel 4x4 front, there are a couple of Maverick/Terranos for under £800, and also the odd Pajero - either would still be reasonably juicy I would think, though I have fancied a Paj for some time now. Slightly more durable than a diesel Rangey.


Having looked on ebay as well ,the quest would seem to be quite a difficult one. Not much in the way of 4x4s for less than £1000 - maybe I had better stick with the Honda........

Fabric 2.2

3,821 posts

215 months

Monday 8th November 2010
quotequote all
Always liked the look of these for disposable winter motoring. 1.3 AWD, could be a bit of fun with a decent set of tyres.



http://www.pistonheads.com/sales/2226125.htm

chevy-stu

5,392 posts

251 months

Animal

5,642 posts

291 months

Monday 8th November 2010
quotequote all
It's all very well spending a few quid on some decent winter tyres, but they're not going to stop some tt banging into you!

Giving serious thought to buying myself a little Citroen/Peugeot (ferocious heater!) or something similar for the winter - I'll wait and see if it snows.

N Dentressangle

3,449 posts

245 months

Monday 8th November 2010
quotequote all


Can't think of any other reason to own one of these, but there isn't much which fits all your criteria.

Can't think of many other diesel 4wd manual estates available for less than 1k.

As a nasty piece of Vauxhall crap which I didn't care about, was happy to dump anywhere and get bashed in, I rather like it!

300bhp/ton

41,030 posts

213 months

Monday 8th November 2010
quotequote all
Rollcage said:
Winter is very nearly upon us, so in the interest of keeping mobile in the event of a repeat of last year's weather what do we think the best winter snotter would be?

It should be four wheel drive and be cheap to run, so sadly rules out Range Rovers and Jeeps!

I was thinking of some sort of Subaru, or a cheap Audi quattro of one form or another. In a perfect world it would be diesel, estate, manual, 4wd and cost less than a bag, and preferably less than £500. It would be used when the weather was bad and I need to get to work, or of course when the weather is bad and I want to have some fun!

In the end I saw a cheap Honda CR-V, and have bought that, but i'm not sure I'll keep it, as I would like something a little more PH.

Any other suggestions?
I think an understanding of 4wd systems, differentials and driving in slippery conditions would help inform you about what would be suitable more than any recommendations anyone will make.

smile

Rollcage

Original Poster:

11,345 posts

215 months

Monday 8th November 2010
quotequote all
300bhp/ton said:
Rollcage said:
Winter is very nearly upon us, so in the interest of keeping mobile in the event of a repeat of last year's weather what do we think the best winter snotter would be?

It should be four wheel drive and be cheap to run, so sadly rules out Range Rovers and Jeeps!

I was thinking of some sort of Subaru, or a cheap Audi quattro of one form or another. In a perfect world it would be diesel, estate, manual, 4wd and cost less than a bag, and preferably less than £500. It would be used when the weather was bad and I need to get to work, or of course when the weather is bad and I want to have some fun!

In the end I saw a cheap Honda CR-V, and have bought that, but i'm not sure I'll keep it, as I would like something a little more PH.

Any other suggestions?
I think an understanding of 4wd systems, differentials and driving in slippery conditions would help inform you about what would be suitable more than any recommendations anyone will make.

smile
Got all that thanks, and managed fine last year, and also have managed fine in the many off road exploits I have undertaken in the various Range Rovers I have previously owned, as well as the odd Subaru, Toyota 4x4, etc. wink (Although I'll admit to being defeated in the Z3 by the conditions earlier in the year and having to turn around on a hill that a FWD hatch had earlier sailed up - maybe I cant drive after all!)


boomboompow

6,956 posts

207 months

Monday 8th November 2010
quotequote all
Saw a Mrk1 Range Rover for sale in the local rag for £350 (apparently fully functional/no running issues)... tempted, however I'd still approach with caution.

irodger

1,143 posts

241 months

Monday 8th November 2010
quotequote all
Rollcage said:
DAVEVO9 said:
Would be a lot cheaper to get some winter tyres fitted?
The Honda was £300. I'm not talking about blowing thousands here biggrin
Where, pray tell, did you find a CRV for £300?????? I've been looking for something cheap to use for a few months over winter. All I've found is that even the worst sheds (106s, Corsas, Micras etc) go for £500ish if they're running and have a few months T&T!

I know cars are cheaper down south, but c'mon...thats ridiculous!

Rollcage

Original Poster:

11,345 posts

215 months

Monday 8th November 2010
quotequote all
irodger said:
Rollcage said:
DAVEVO9 said:
Would be a lot cheaper to get some winter tyres fitted?
The Honda was £300. I'm not talking about blowing thousands here biggrin
Where, pray tell, did you find a CRV for £300?????? I've been looking for something cheap to use for a few months over winter. All I've found is that even the worst sheds (106s, Corsas, Micras etc) go for £500ish if they're running and have a few months T&T!

I know cars are cheaper down south, but c'mon...thats ridiculous!
It's not what you know, but who you know........biggrin

X reg as well!

irodger

1,143 posts

241 months

Monday 8th November 2010
quotequote all
Rollcage said:
irodger said:
Rollcage said:
DAVEVO9 said:
Would be a lot cheaper to get some winter tyres fitted?
The Honda was £300. I'm not talking about blowing thousands here biggrin
Where, pray tell, did you find a CRV for £300?????? I've been looking for something cheap to use for a few months over winter. All I've found is that even the worst sheds (106s, Corsas, Micras etc) go for £500ish if they're running and have a few months T&T!

I know cars are cheaper down south, but c'mon...thats ridiculous!
It's not what you know, but who you know........biggrin

X reg as well!
Well done, that man! clap

TBH I do see the odd "wonder buy" available, but they're always hundereds of miles away, and by the time I factor in a flight/train and return fuel costs, its not worth it. Saw a V6 Mondeo go for £270 the other week...would've cost about £200 to collect it!

I'll get lucky one day!

Mars

9,894 posts

237 months

Monday 8th November 2010
quotequote all
Rollcage said:
300bhp/ton said:
Rollcage said:
Winter is very nearly upon us, so in the interest of keeping mobile in the event of a repeat of last year's weather what do we think the best winter snotter would be?

It should be four wheel drive and be cheap to run, so sadly rules out Range Rovers and Jeeps!

I was thinking of some sort of Subaru, or a cheap Audi quattro of one form or another. In a perfect world it would be diesel, estate, manual, 4wd and cost less than a bag, and preferably less than £500. It would be used when the weather was bad and I need to get to work, or of course when the weather is bad and I want to have some fun!

In the end I saw a cheap Honda CR-V, and have bought that, but i'm not sure I'll keep it, as I would like something a little more PH.

Any other suggestions?
I think an understanding of 4wd systems, differentials and driving in slippery conditions would help inform you about what would be suitable more than any recommendations anyone will make.

smile
Got all that thanks, and managed fine last year, and also have managed fine in the many off road exploits I have undertaken in the various Range Rovers I have previously owned, as well as the odd Subaru, Toyota 4x4, etc. wink (Although I'll admit to being defeated in the Z3 by the conditions earlier in the year and having to turn around on a hill that a FWD hatch had earlier sailed up - maybe I cant drive after all!)
I hope I don't come across as sounding "superior" or anything - not my intention - but 300bhp/ton has a point. This video is rather Subaru-centric but it does show how limited some rear-drives can be in AWD/4x4 systems.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ooQRxlChvMw

It does a specific comparison with a modeern CRV too.

300bhp/ton

41,030 posts

213 months

Monday 8th November 2010
quotequote all
Rollcage said:
300bhp/ton said:
Rollcage said:
Winter is very nearly upon us, so in the interest of keeping mobile in the event of a repeat of last year's weather what do we think the best winter snotter would be?

It should be four wheel drive and be cheap to run, so sadly rules out Range Rovers and Jeeps!

I was thinking of some sort of Subaru, or a cheap Audi quattro of one form or another. In a perfect world it would be diesel, estate, manual, 4wd and cost less than a bag, and preferably less than £500. It would be used when the weather was bad and I need to get to work, or of course when the weather is bad and I want to have some fun!

In the end I saw a cheap Honda CR-V, and have bought that, but i'm not sure I'll keep it, as I would like something a little more PH.

Any other suggestions?
I think an understanding of 4wd systems, differentials and driving in slippery conditions would help inform you about what would be suitable more than any recommendations anyone will make.

smile
Got all that thanks, and managed fine last year, and also have managed fine in the many off road exploits I have undertaken in the various Range Rovers I have previously owned, as well as the odd Subaru, Toyota 4x4, etc. wink (Although I'll admit to being defeated in the Z3 by the conditions earlier in the year and having to turn around on a hill that a FWD hatch had earlier sailed up - maybe I cant drive after all!)
if so, then confused why are you asking?