S4 V8 not starting (starter motor not engaging)..thoughts?!
S4 V8 not starting (starter motor not engaging)..thoughts?!
Author
Discussion

TonyHetherington

Original Poster:

32,091 posts

281 months

Monday 8th November 2010
quotequote all
Morning all

Bit of a weird one on my car this weekend, and would appreciate some technical ideas!

Went to start car yesterday morning, unlock, get in, key to pre-ignition, everything fine, turn key and nothing. Lights on dash all ok, so it's not car battery. But turn key and nothing happens.

Tried key out, lock, unlock, wondering if it was immobiliser, but same problem. Tried starting it maybe 7 or 8 times, nothing, so 2 seconds away from calling the AA tried it again and it started. Result!

Same problem this morning, but it started after 5 or 6 goes. Got to work, turned off, turned on again instatly and it starts with no problems at all. This points to immobiliser I assume (as that would not have been on because I hadn't locked the car).

Not sure if it will affect it - but it chucked it down saturday night (and last night) and the car is kept outside...however it's been fine for 18months that I've owned it in much heavier rain.

Is it immobiliser related, and if so - how?! It seems very odd and I can't work it out!?

Thanks all for any thoughts/advice/experiences!
Tony

Edited by TonyHetherington on Monday 8th November 09:22

Dr G

16,017 posts

273 months

Monday 8th November 2010
quotequote all
Not likely to be the immobiliser, sounds simply like your starter motor has died a death. It's reasonably common on S4s.

TonyHetherington

Original Poster:

32,091 posts

281 months

Monday 8th November 2010
quotequote all
The starter motor doesn't even try to engage when it's not starting, and then does. But when I got to work it turned over every click. Assume just because it got freed?!

If they're common to go though, sounds good enough to me! Will get it looked at. Thanks smile

danyeates

7,248 posts

253 months

Monday 8th November 2010
quotequote all
I know the immobiliser is a bit of a weak point on the B5 S4’s, but it will turn the engine over, it just won’t fire, or it does fire but stalls straight away. You will have an orange light in the shape of a key on if it is the immobiliser, but it doesn’t sound likely it it isn’t even turning over.

It's actually the contacts in the ignition barrel that play up, usually find if you remove the key and put it in again it's ok.

Edited by danyeates on Monday 8th November 10:33

TonyHetherington

Original Poster:

32,091 posts

281 months

Monday 8th November 2010
quotequote all
Ah I see - definitely not the immobiliser then. I turn the key and zero happens, rather than the starter kicking in/clicking etc.

marctwo

3,666 posts

291 months

Monday 8th November 2010
quotequote all
When my battery died I just got a fast clicking sound when I turned the ignition. I thought it was the starter motor but it wasn't. In my S3, when the battery went, the starter motor just turned the engine over very slowly. I don't know why the S4 is different.

TonyHetherington

Original Poster:

32,091 posts

281 months

Monday 8th November 2010
quotequote all
Just found this...

http://www.audiforums.com/forum/showthread.php?t=1...

they seem to question the battery, but lights turn on and everything with no problems?!

Yertis

19,745 posts

297 months

Monday 8th November 2010
quotequote all
I used to get this "dead man's click" in my urS4 when the battery went dead. Like yours, everything else (lights etc) seemed OK. But the amps (or whatever it is) simply weren't there to kick in the starter. New battery cured it.

TonyHetherington

Original Poster:

32,091 posts

281 months

Monday 8th November 2010
quotequote all
No no, I don't get the clicking either (quite used to that with my Lotuses hehe ) - I simply get nothing.

Found a couple of sites that agree with DrG that a new starter seemed to cure the problem - so think I will go for that first.

Pvapour

8,981 posts

284 months

Monday 8th November 2010
quotequote all
if its manual it may be worth a bump to see if it starts, turn off and try to start again?

jeremyc

28,410 posts

315 months

Monday 8th November 2010
quotequote all
You can quickly check whether it is battery or starter motor by trying a jump start next time you see the symptoms.

Connect jump leads to a known good battery - if it still doesn't start then it's the starter motor that is the problem, otherwise the battery. smile

Pvapour

8,981 posts

284 months

Monday 8th November 2010
quotequote all
tongue out

TonyHetherington

Original Poster:

32,091 posts

281 months

Monday 8th November 2010
quotequote all
Great minds - good idea smile Will put some leads in the boot!

E24man

8,187 posts

210 months

Monday 8th November 2010
quotequote all
Sounds like a dying starter motor - the failure mechanism with these is a slow fail over time rather than an abrupt and quick ending.

HTH

E24man

TonyHetherington

Original Poster:

32,091 posts

281 months

Tuesday 9th November 2010
quotequote all
It's very odd. Worked first time on the 6 or so occasions I had to start during the rest of the day yesterday. Then first thing this morning, turn key, hold it in the "start" position and after maybe 3 seconds, then the start motor starts doing it's thing and the engine starts.

Seems it's the motor, then smile

Dr G

16,017 posts

273 months

Tuesday 9th November 2010
quotequote all
Yes, they do that wink

TonyHetherington

Original Poster:

32,091 posts

281 months

Tuesday 9th November 2010
quotequote all
Top man, thanks

ScottBN3

33 posts

260 months

Tuesday 9th November 2010
quotequote all
Hi

I had exactly the same thing - impossible to predict when it would or wouldn't start! I had no "clicking" from the relay to the right (and down a bit..) of the steering wheel so replaced the starter switch. This brought back the clicking but still didn't solve the problem. Bit the bullet and replaced the starter motor and has been absolutely fine since.

Not a cheap fix but being stranded for 45 minutes in the snow trying to start the car wasn't much fun either rolleyes

TonyHetherington

Original Poster:

32,091 posts

281 months

Tuesday 9th November 2010
quotequote all
May I ask what sort of cost the starter motor was?

Dr G

16,017 posts

273 months

Wednesday 10th November 2010
quotequote all
From the last one I was billed for the starter is aproximately 230+ VAT exchange for a genuine one and 2 hours of labour to swap.