Does birth order make you who you are?
Does birth order make you who you are?
Author
Discussion

Shay HTFC

Original Poster:

3,588 posts

220 months

Tuesday 9th November 2010
quotequote all
I read something the other day about birth order being linked to personality type.

The survey said that the eldest was usually more intelligent, conservative, conscientious and that the youngest was the rebel who would be more likely to go down the 'alternative' path and become a drug taking rock star for example. the middle children would be somewhere inbetween, but usually more reserved.

http://www.time.com/time/health/article/0,8599,167...

I'm the eldest of 4 (3 of us boys and a sister) and am a bit of a nutcase really who gets up to all sorts, so hardly the conservative, conscientious person the studies expect. My next brother is much quieter and does his work properly for example and then my youngest brother is a real rebel.

Is it all just a load of ste though? I think there must be some truth to things like this. There are certain situations and psychological positions that all first borns experience as is the case with last borns etc and those experiences will effect the way you approach the world.

cal72

7,839 posts

201 months

Tuesday 9th November 2010
quotequote all
Youngest of 5.
I am the more intelligent of the rest, also to add that my brothers and sister are naturally lazy and greedy, none of them have ever had a job that lasted longer than 6 months and i have to they are dead beat chavs.

So maybe either the first or last in line is equal to weakest and strongest.

Martial Arts Man

6,703 posts

217 months

Tuesday 9th November 2010
quotequote all
I read a book on this years ago; can't remember its name though, sadly.

I do remember thinking at the time that, on the whole, it was fairly accurate when applied to most of the families I know well enough to compare siblings.

Perhaps though I was a biased reader in that I'm the eldest of four and think myself to be the most intelligent etc biggrin

Frankeh

12,558 posts

216 months

Tuesday 9th November 2010
quotequote all
Judging from my own experience I'd say it's the exact opposite to what you said, OP.

bexVN

14,698 posts

242 months

Tuesday 9th November 2010
quotequote all
My sister is younger by three years and was defintely more rebellious than me she'll admit to that (my parents worried that I wasn't rebellious enough!!). She is not less intelligent though, she has made a career as a qualified Nursery Nurse and been managerial in the role. I became a head veterinary nurse so we went down very similar routes in a way.

However my sisters rebellion was actually very minor compared to many, she was lazier when younger but I now think I'm the lazier of the two of us smile

We are very different chracters which has caused conflict but never to the point of any real issues, she is now married with a baby and living in Oz, they're coming home for Christmas can't wait biggrin

My hubby is the younger brother, it is the complete opposite for him, his older brother was lazier, didn't achieve anything for years, hubby was too bright for his own good in his younger years and was always busy etc. His brother is now a very hard worker and doing well. (He also live in Oz, married with a kid!!)

So in conclusion I'm not convinced with the birth order thing

Edited by bexVN on Tuesday 9th November 11:00

Shay HTFC

Original Poster:

3,588 posts

220 months

Tuesday 9th November 2010
quotequote all
Frankeh said:
Judging from my own experience I'd say it's the exact opposite to what you said, OP.
The general gist is that when some major event happens during childhood that it can affect it.
My father died when I was 11 and I would be interested to know if maybe that threw me into a different way of life from that point on?

I think about friends I know who had a 'normal' family upbringing and they all seem to fit what the article says.
But I know a lot of people who had troubled childhoods and lost parents etc that end up being different to what the research suggests.

Mx_Stu

837 posts

254 months

Tuesday 9th November 2010
quotequote all
Shay HTFC said:
I read something the other day about birth order being linked to personality type.

The survey said that the eldest was usually more intelligent, conservative, conscientious and that the youngest was the rebel who would be more likely to go down the 'alternative' path and become a drug taking rock star for example. the middle children would be somewhere inbetween, but usually more reserved.

Is it all just a load of ste though?
I'd say yes (to it being a load of ste)

My sister is 4 years older than me. She left school at 16, lacks any form of common sense and has drifted from job to job.

I on the other hand did sixth form, then uni and had a graduate job in big 4 accountancy firm lined up before finished uni.

Austin.J

888 posts

223 months

Tuesday 9th November 2010
quotequote all
I'm the youngest, have an older sister who got A's constantly, 2.1 in university & now doing a PHD in some complicated thing.

I left school at 16 with toss all, worked in a machine shop for a year, drank a lot, crashed a couple of motorbikes, took all sorts of things, been arrested a few times, now in an office job which I quite like.

So in my opinion I'd say yes, the younger one (me) is a bit of a tt essentially.

Zod

35,295 posts

289 months

Tuesday 9th November 2010
quotequote all
I'm the eldest of four brothers and I fit this theory (though I say so myself). My brothers, however do not. The rebels are the middle two, both of whom are recovered alcoholics who quite literally pissed away their 20s thinking they were cool rebels. One is a successful GP now, the other, younger one is just starting to get back on his feet. The youngest, like me is a City lawyer and more conservative than me, perhaps as a reaction to the middle two.

It all makes me concerned to nurture my two (soon to be three) kids to try to help them all find their own path, but without any of them falling off it.

Mazda Baiter

37,069 posts

219 months

Tuesday 9th November 2010
quotequote all
I don't think it works at all.

FamilyGuy

850 posts

221 months

Tuesday 9th November 2010
quotequote all
I definitely think there's something to it. Although none of my 3 siblings or I turned out to be rebels - the second child syndrome did happen. Although successful, educated and employed the second amongst my lot is the least well paid and with the worst relationship record.

I was the youngest. I suspect the first child and the last child to leave benefit from being "the only one" for a while. I was determined not to let the second child thing happen to our children (we have 4) but it's simply not possible - the first child gets all the attention of 2 parents (as a rule) for a few years but the second gets half that etc. You can compensate a bit but if you're already putting everything into child #1 then there's no room for upping the effort to compensate for there being 2, 3 or 4 - they all have to do with less as attention gets shared around.

speedchick

5,291 posts

253 months

Tuesday 9th November 2010
quotequote all
Eldest of three, spent most of the time being told I am the oldest so should know better. (Know better about what, I have yet to find out)

Middle child male, so was the blue eyed boy, is a very strange, rude, bigoted person, but still the blue eyed boy.

Youngest is female, and as she is the baby of the family, she gets away with everything and it in line for a sainthood.

I'm still waiting to be told that I was actually adopted into the family, as I refuse to believe that I share the same genes as them.

parakitaMol.

11,876 posts

282 months

Tuesday 9th November 2010
quotequote all
Does this apply to triplets born minutes apart?


Cogcog

11,838 posts

266 months

Tuesday 9th November 2010
quotequote all
Martial Arts Man said:
I read a book on this years ago; can't remember its name though, sadly.

I do remember thinking at the time that, on the whole, it was fairly accurate when applied to most of the families I know well enough to compare siblings.

Perhaps though I was a biased reader in that I'm the eldest of four and think myself to be the most intelligent etc biggrin
It is part of Outliers too, but that is more about birth month.

Robatr0n

12,362 posts

247 months

Tuesday 9th November 2010
quotequote all
I'm the second youngest out of 4.

The eldest (my sister) is pretty out going although not entirely confident. Was abit of a rebel in her younger days.

The next eldest (my brother) is extremely intelligent, quietly confident, level headed and one of my closest friends. smile

The youngest (my other sister) used to be so shy but is now very outgoing, rebellious when she was younger but has settled down and grown up a lot in the past 2/3 years.

Then there's me! I'm by no means perfect but I'm a mix of all 3 of them but was always very protective over all 3 of them, especially my brother and youngest sister as they were so shy and quiet when they were younger which made them prone to being picked on.

Shay HTFC

Original Poster:

3,588 posts

220 months

Tuesday 9th November 2010
quotequote all
parakitaMol. said:
Does this apply to triplets born minutes apart?
Funnily enough, my youngest brothers and sisters are triplets, but there still a definite understanding about who was the youngest, in the sense of being the baby of the family.

Jimski

275 posts

198 months

Tuesday 9th November 2010
quotequote all
I am the youngest not only in my family but out of my cousins on both sides of the family and I turned out ok

I would like to point out that I am smarter than my sister and I can get away with this as she doesn't come on pisotn heads biggrin

cazzer

8,883 posts

279 months

Tuesday 9th November 2010
quotequote all
speedchick said:
Eldest of three, spent most of the time being told I am the oldest so should know better. (Know better about what, I have yet to find out)

Middle child male, so was the blue eyed boy, is a very strange, rude, bigoted person, but still the blue eyed boy.

Youngest is female, and as she is the baby of the family, she gets away with everything and it in line for a sainthood.

I'm still waiting to be told that I was actually adopted into the family, as I refuse to believe that I share the same genes as them.
Ooo, that is so written by an eldest smile

That could have been my missus speaking word for word.