s4 or M3
Author
Discussion

iaiin

Original Poster:

406 posts

280 months

Sunday 14th November 2010
quotequote all
Hi guys
Need change of car & have about enough money to get 05 s4, or M3. Is there enough room in back for 3 kids (seat belts?) Anyone had both cars as cant make my mind up? I love the thought that the s4 has a v8 (do they still do the v6 2.7 turbo in s4 or is this only older model?)
Also manual or auto , have they all got paddle shift if auto?
Is auto or manual better for re sale, as wife has dsg golf & hate it, when you are at junction , you step on it, it takes about 3 secs to engage gear then takes of with wheels on fire, but by then its to late!!!
Anyone had both & give me a few pointers as cars seem about then same money?
cheers

Edited by iaiin on Sunday 14th November 10:06

matts4

2,117 posts

222 months

Sunday 14th November 2010
quotequote all
I went for the S4 over the M3 due to:

4 doors (not 2) is easier to get kids into
4 wheel drive means you can enjoy the power more safely in all conditions
The V8 is aural pleasure (not as good as oral pleasure though) and you'll always smile when you put your foot down
Servicing is cheaper on the S4
Tyres are cheaper on the S4
The S4 was just as quick around the TG test track when they tested them both many years ago
The S4 is a bit more of a sleeper then the M3
The interior is a nice place to be in the S4




FamilyDub

3,587 posts

196 months

Sunday 14th November 2010
quotequote all
Well, either the softer, but a LOT more discreet S4 or the arguably more 'pure' M3.

The image and the unavoidable attention from the Saxo brigade, would put me off the M3 personally.

You are asking this in the VAG section though -- bias, much! smile

Dr G

16,017 posts

273 months

Monday 15th November 2010
quotequote all
M3 has nicer steering and will go sideways, as far as I see it the advantages end there.

S4 has good (rather than great) steering and I have zero interest in power sliding on the road. They have a lovely cabin (with a few toys), truly superb seats, excellent Q car appeal, a really characterful (and strong) engine, huge boot, sensible running costs, good reliabilty record...

Only downside you might find is the back seat - leg room is pretty crap.

iaiin

Original Poster:

406 posts

280 months

Monday 15th November 2010
quotequote all
matts4 said:
I went for the S4 over the M3 due to:

4 doors (not 2) is easier to get kids into
4 wheel drive means you can enjoy the power more safely in all conditions
The V8 is aural pleasure (not as good as oral pleasure though) and you'll always smile when you put your foot down
Servicing is cheaper on the S4
Tyres are cheaper on the S4
The S4 was just as quick around the TG test track when they tested them both many years ago
The S4 is a bit more of a sleeper then the M3
The interior is a nice place to be in the S4
Ha Ha i like oral pleasure , but i also like the sound of a v8, i must say they are both nice & tend to eh on the s4 side, bit didsapointed with the extras on s4 compared with a lot of M3 very good spec!
Is there a good exhaust to put on these to make them sound nice (miltec or something?)
cheers

iaiin

Original Poster:

406 posts

280 months

Monday 15th November 2010
quotequote all
FamilyDub said:
Well, either the softer, but a LOT more discreet S4 or the arguably more 'pure' M3.

The image and the unavoidable attention from the Saxo brigade, would put me off the M3 personally.

You are asking this in the VAG section though -- bias, much! smile
Yes its a nice bias though!!
Is the auto on 05 model dsg? is it any good?do you get paddles for gear change? whats manual like?
cheers

iaiin

Original Poster:

406 posts

280 months

Monday 15th November 2010
quotequote all
Dr G said:
M3 has nicer steering and will go sideways, as far as I see it the advantages end there.

S4 has good (rather than great) steering and I have zero interest in power sliding on the road. They have a lovely cabin (with a few toys), truly superb seats, excellent Q car appeal, a really characterful (and strong) engine, huge boot, sensible running costs, good reliabilty record...

Only downside you might find is the back seat - leg room is pretty crap.
Leg room is crap in m3 as well, in fact the soft top has only 2 rear seats (small & windowless)
Are gearbox any good in these? what is best gearbox to go for?
cheers for help

Dr G

16,017 posts

273 months

Monday 15th November 2010
quotequote all
Audi's options list is a very expensive toy box but take your time and you'll find a car with a proper list of kit.

Milltek is the system of choice for better sound effects.

None of the V8 cars get DSG/S-Tronic, they're all 'tiptronic' which is a conventional torque convertor auto. It's pretty good as autos go, it does get paddle shift and has a taller 6th than the manual for a marginal improvement in motorway economy. Manual would be the one for me (for no other reason than my liking manuals) but you're not shooting yourself in the foot plumping for an auto and both sell well.

iaiin

Original Poster:

406 posts

280 months

Tuesday 16th November 2010
quotequote all
Dr G said:
Audi's options list is a very expensive toy box but take your time and you'll find a car with a proper list of kit.

Milltek is the system of choice for better sound effects.

None of the V8 cars get DSG/S-Tronic, they're all 'tiptronic' which is a conventional torque convertor auto. It's pretty good as autos go, it does get paddle shift and has a taller 6th than the manual for a marginal improvement in motorway economy. Manual would be the one for me (for no other reason than my liking manuals) but you're not shooting yourself in the foot plumping for an auto and both sell well.
Many thanks, will have a look & see what comes up, if i saw the right one i would get it over m3 as extra doors good + i do like v8's !!!!!

E24man

8,187 posts

210 months

Wednesday 17th November 2010
quotequote all
We were choosing between a (B6) Audi S4 cabriolet and an (E46) M3 Cabriolet as a replacement for the TVR Griffith when 'we' two became three.

The M3 is an amazing car (I am traditionally a BM enthusiast) but as is common with modern M cars does need the engine to be pushed to the limits to release all the power and the suspension, especially on 19" rims, was crashingly hard.

The Audi was that bit softer riding, 4-wheel drive (for the winters) and the V8 is lovely engine (albeit a little muted) with good usable power available through the range. We opted for the Tiptronic as Mrs E24man does spend a fair time commuting it and auto's make life significantly easier than a manual or DSG/whatever manual gearbox.

The Audi won the day and we love it's ease of use.

For reference; Mrs E24man's other car is a Prodrive Scooby and my chariots are a 1985 BMW M635CSi and I have just replaced my dead E34 M5 Touring with a 2001 Alpina B10 V8 Touring.


iaiin

Original Poster:

406 posts

280 months

Thursday 18th November 2010
quotequote all
E24man said:
We were choosing between a (B6) Audi S4 cabriolet and an (E46) M3 Cabriolet as a replacement for the TVR Griffith when 'we' two became three.

The M3 is an amazing car (I am traditionally a BM enthusiast) but as is common with modern M cars does need the engine to be pushed to the limits to release all the power and the suspension, especially on 19" rims, was crashingly hard.

The Audi was that bit softer riding, 4-wheel drive (for the winters) and the V8 is lovely engine (albeit a little muted) with good usable power available through the range. We opted for the Tiptronic as Mrs E24man does spend a fair time commuting it and auto's make life significantly easier than a manual or DSG/whatever manual gearbox.

The Audi won the day and we love it's ease of use.

For reference; Mrs E24man's other car is a Prodrive Scooby and my chariots are a 1985 BMW M635CSi and I have just replaced my dead E34 M5 Touring with a 2001 Alpina B10 V8 Touring.
Many thanks for view! Everyone seems to say that s4 bit more real world use apposed to m3 , very good but bit hard core for everyday use.
cheers Ian

FamilyDub

3,587 posts

196 months

Thursday 18th November 2010
quotequote all
^^^ is that a decision...? biggrin

E24man

8,187 posts

210 months

Friday 19th November 2010
quotequote all
iaiin said:
E24man said:
We were choosing between a (B6) Audi S4 cabriolet and an (E46) M3 Cabriolet as a replacement for the TVR Griffith when 'we' two became three.

The M3 is an amazing car (I am traditionally a BM enthusiast) but as is common with modern M cars does need the engine to be pushed to the limits to release all the power and the suspension, especially on 19" rims, was crashingly hard.

The Audi was that bit softer riding, 4-wheel drive (for the winters) and the V8 is lovely engine (albeit a little muted) with good usable power available through the range. We opted for the Tiptronic as Mrs E24man does spend a fair time commuting it and auto's make life significantly easier than a manual or DSG/whatever manual gearbox.

The Audi won the day and we love it's ease of use.

For reference; Mrs E24man's other car is a Prodrive Scooby and my chariots are a 1985 BMW M635CSi and I have just replaced my dead E34 M5 Touring with a 2001 Alpina B10 V8 Touring.
Many thanks for view! Everyone seems to say that s4 bit more real world use apposed to m3 , very good but bit hard core for everyday use.
cheers Ian
Glad to help.

Another thing that might be worth considering is that S4 parts/maintenance costs will be cheaper than M3 costs - the RS4 and M3 costs are similar due to their similar complexity (brakes/suspension/engine, etc)- the S4 costs are more simlar to a 330i.

Lastly the ride - we find the S4 ride just about right - it's just firm enough to allow you to travel smoothly and rapidly but visits to the dentist and osteopath aren't needed - the S4 ride is actually pretty similar to the E39 Alpina B10's; although how Alpina manage to sort it out whilst still sitting the car on 19" rims is a marvellous mystery.

iaiin

Original Poster:

406 posts

280 months

Friday 19th November 2010
quotequote all
E24man said:
iaiin said:
E24man said:
We were choosing between a (B6) Audi S4 cabriolet and an (E46) M3 Cabriolet as a replacement for the TVR Griffith when 'we' two became three.

The M3 is an amazing car (I am traditionally a BM enthusiast) but as is common with modern M cars does need the engine to be pushed to the limits to release all the power and the suspension, especially on 19" rims, was crashingly hard.

The Audi was that bit softer riding, 4-wheel drive (for the winters) and the V8 is lovely engine (albeit a little muted) with good usable power available through the range. We opted for the Tiptronic as Mrs E24man does spend a fair time commuting it and auto's make life significantly easier than a manual or DSG/whatever manual gearbox.

The Audi won the day and we love it's ease of use.

For reference; Mrs E24man's other car is a Prodrive Scooby and my chariots are a 1985 BMW M635CSi and I have just replaced my dead E34 M5 Touring with a 2001 Alpina B10 V8 Touring.
Many thanks for view! Everyone seems to say that s4 bit more real world use apposed to m3 , very good but bit hard core for everyday use.
cheers Ian
Glad to help.

Another thing that might be worth considering is that S4 parts/maintenance costs will be cheaper than M3 costs - the RS4 and M3 costs are similar due to their similar complexity (brakes/suspension/engine, etc)- the S4 costs are more simlar to a 330i.

Lastly the ride - we find the S4 ride just about right - it's just firm enough to allow you to travel smoothly and rapidly but visits to the dentist and osteopath aren't needed - the S4 ride is actually pretty similar to the E39 Alpina B10's; although how Alpina manage to sort it out whilst still sitting the car on 19" rims is a marvellous mystery.
I wont be going on race track & i get enough grief with back as it is!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

nail_it

968 posts

239 months

Saturday 27th November 2010
quotequote all
Still looking for a s4?
Could have one for sale

grum71

21 posts

230 months

Thursday 2nd December 2010
quotequote all
I've had 4 M3's (E46 - cab and coupes) and 2 S4's (cab and an avant). I currently still have the S4 avant (B6) and an M3 (E92) and have to say, although the M3's are excellent cars the S4 seems to win it everytime (especially in the snow).
Going back 6 years ago I traded a 52 plate M3 for an 04 S4 cab and knew I had made a grave error. I couldn't justify the terrible fuel consumption of the Audi for the return in performance over the M3. That said, 6 years later I bought the S4 avant, added full millteks etc and it just makes me smile everytime I start the thing up. Linked with the 4 wheel drive it gets you where you want to go without any dramas. It took me 25 minutes to get out of the street in the M3 on Monday. Nightmare.

If you go into the purchase realising you will need a season ticket for the local petrol station then I would advise the S4 (with Millteks)

If fuel economy is an issue and you want one of the best 4 seater coupes on a budget then opt for the M3 - make sure it has sat nav though otherwise you may struggle upon resale.

Both are excellent

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bYF0Zmtf8b8

Although He's a cock, he's a damn good journalist.

Hope this helps confused