CSA Advice
Author
Discussion

Greeny

Original Poster:

1,423 posts

290 months

Monday 22nd November 2010
quotequote all
Just recieved a form from the CSA to fill in, do not want to do so without advice first. Any suggestion as to who to approach?
Been making regular payments to X wife, if not made on time, I catch up asap.
I am self employed, and my last accounts, 2009, show a trading loss.
Any ideas what to expect?


Plotloss

67,280 posts

301 months

Monday 22nd November 2010
quotequote all
Speak to your accountant, he will have been through the process previously.

Soovy

35,829 posts

302 months

Monday 22nd November 2010
quotequote all
Greeny said:
Just recieved a form from the CSA to fill in, do not want to do so without advice first. Any suggestion as to who to approach?
Been making regular payments to X wife, if not made on time, I catch up asap.
I am self employed, and my last accounts, 2009, show a trading loss.
Any ideas what to expect?

An ar5eraping, sadly.

RJDM3

1,441 posts

236 months

Monday 22nd November 2010
quotequote all
Greeny said:
Just recieved a form from the CSA to fill in, do not want to do so without advice first. Any suggestion as to who to approach?
Been making regular payments to X wife, if not made on time, I catch up asap.
I am self employed, and my last accounts, 2009, show a trading loss.
Any ideas what to expect?

First question i would ask is why the CSA is involved?

Cant a mutual agreement be made between you and the EX?

If at all possible get a mutual agreement that works for both of you as CSA are a bunch of sts, and if they deem you have not paid enough previously they can ask for back payments.

Why are the CSA involved now and not before?

Greeny

Original Poster:

1,423 posts

290 months

Monday 22nd November 2010
quotequote all
We did have a mutual agreement, but I fell behind a couple of months while waiting for payments for work to come in. She seemed ok with this, but has now changed her mind

Plotloss

67,280 posts

301 months

Monday 22nd November 2010
quotequote all
For one child it's 15% less the proportion of time they spend with you, there's a calculator on the website.

So if you've been paying more than that she'll end up worse off.

RJDM3

1,441 posts

236 months

Monday 22nd November 2010
quotequote all
Greeny said:
We did have a mutual agreement, but I fell behind a couple of months while waiting for payments for work to come in. She seemed ok with this, but has now changed her mind
Been in your situation before.

Shame they cant understand that if the money has not been earnt or waiting for it then where are you supposed to pull it from.

How did you pay previously? Does the ex work or benefits etc?

johnvthe2nd

1,292 posts

228 months

Monday 22nd November 2010
quotequote all
Greeny said:
Just recieved a form from the CSA to fill in, do not want to do so without advice first. Any suggestion as to who to approach?
Been making regular payments to X wife, if not made on time, I catch up asap.
I am self employed, and my last accounts, 2009, show a trading loss.
Any ideas what to expect?

sounds like she's shot herself in the foot

Greeny

Original Poster:

1,423 posts

290 months

Monday 22nd November 2010
quotequote all
RJDM3 said:
Greeny said:
We did have a mutual agreement, but I fell behind a couple of months while waiting for payments for work to come in. She seemed ok with this, but has now changed her mind
Been in your situation before.

Shame they cant understand that if the money has not been earnt or waiting for it then where are you supposed to pull it from.

How did you pay previously? Does the ex work or benefits etc?
Paid monthly direct into her bank. She does work.

Kaelic

2,723 posts

232 months

Monday 22nd November 2010
quotequote all
Mine has done the same

was getting 550 a month for my child in an agreement

Some asshat convinced her that she would get more if she went down the CSA route....


Sadly she now sees quite a bit less and the rest I am banking for my daughters use when she is old enough. And that is before I start having my daughter 3 nights a week biggrin




CSA are a bunch of incompetent pricks who even when they had my full details still denied having them and denied taking money from my bank account even when I sent them a copy of my statement to show they had begun taking payments from me.

Greeny

Original Poster:

1,423 posts

290 months

Monday 22nd November 2010
quotequote all
Plotloss said:
For one child it's 15% less the proportion of time they spend with you, there's a calculator on the website.

So if you've been paying more than that she'll end up worse off.
So 15% of nothing is not that much then! I will just keep paying what I have been though if that is the case.

johnvthe2nd

1,292 posts

228 months

Monday 22nd November 2010
quotequote all
Greeny said:
Plotloss said:
For one child it's 15% less the proportion of time they spend with you, there's a calculator on the website.

So if you've been paying more than that she'll end up worse off.
So 15% of nothing is not that much then! I will just keep paying what I have been though if that is the case.
that's right .. my OH got awarded £5 per month by the CSA for her 2 boys

1598

770 posts

194 months

Monday 22nd November 2010
quotequote all
It's a shame some of the parents caught up in this muddle do not remember that the money is there to help raise the child/ren, and not to fund the resident partners lifestyle.

I am also one caught in this muddle and give as much as I can to my kids and go without myself. If they need clothes/shoes/money for clubs or outings, they get it.

Amused2death

2,526 posts

227 months

Monday 22nd November 2010
quotequote all
1598 said:
It's a shame some of the parents caught up in this muddle do not remember that the money is there to help raise the child/ren, and not to fund the resident partners lifestyle.

I am also one caught in this muddle and give as much as I can to my kids and go without myself. If they need clothes/shoes/money for clubs or outings, they get it.
It used to be that any money taken from the non resident parent in the form of a CSA demand would be taken from the resident parent's benefits pound for pound.(If being claimed)

SystemParanoia

14,343 posts

229 months

Monday 22nd November 2010
quotequote all
if you're self employed...

stop paying yourself a wage and claim job seekers

you will be assessed at £5 p/wk

everybody's a winner as you can then just continue "as you were" and pull a wage again.


every time CSA catch up with you.. pull the same trick again.. and again.. and again

MrPeters

371 posts

194 months

Monday 22nd November 2010
quotequote all
SystemParanoia said:
if you're self employed...

stop paying yourself a wage and claim job seekers

you will be assessed at £5 p/wk

everybody's a winner as you can then just continue "as you were" and pull a wage again.


every time CSA catch up with you.. pull the same trick again.. and again.. and again
I thought if you were self employed it's all technically 'your money' so even if your business account shows money in it's 'a wage'.

If you're an employee of your own limited company, however...

Greeny

Original Poster:

1,423 posts

290 months

Monday 22nd November 2010
quotequote all
MrPeters said:
SystemParanoia said:
if you're self employed...

stop paying yourself a wage and claim job seekers

you will be assessed at £5 p/wk

everybody's a winner as you can then just continue "as you were" and pull a wage again.


every time CSA catch up with you.. pull the same trick again.. and again.. and again
I thought if you were self employed it's all technically 'your money' so even if your business account shows money in it's 'a wage'.

If you're an employee of your own limited company, however...
I am working toward the limited company option, as I may not be able to make a loss every year, as much as I try. Dividends are, or were outside of the CSA grasp, is this still the case? Just to reiterate, I am not trying to shirk responsability, I am happy to pay a reasanoble amount, and then some, but as soovy hinted earlier, I do not want to get ar5eraped!!!

davido140

9,617 posts

257 months

Monday 22nd November 2010
quotequote all
Kaelic said:
Mine has done the same

was getting 550 a month for my child in an agreement

Some asshat convinced her that she would get more if she went down the CSA route....


Sadly she now sees quite a bit less and the rest I am banking for my daughters use when she is old enough. And that is before I start having my daughter 3 nights a week biggrin




CSA are a bunch of incompetent pricks who even when they had my full details still denied having them and denied taking money from my bank account even when I sent them a copy of my statement to show they had begun taking payments from me.
Similar story here, it's a bit of a loophole, self employed, particularly company directors who take a small salary and pay the reset as dividends end up with very small "judgements" from the CSA, my ex tried it on and ended up being told £27 a week was all she could expect!

I obviously pay a lot more than that but it's a fair amount rather than the grand or so a month she had in mind in the first place.

As has already been said, consult your accountant, he will know what to do! (mine did)

Greeny

Original Poster:

1,423 posts

290 months

Monday 22nd November 2010
quotequote all
davido140 said:
Kaelic said:
Mine has done the same

was getting 550 a month for my child in an agreement

Some asshat convinced her that she would get more if she went down the CSA route....


Sadly she now sees quite a bit less and the rest I am banking for my daughters use when she is old enough. And that is before I start having my daughter 3 nights a week biggrin




CSA are a bunch of incompetent pricks who even when they had my full details still denied having them and denied taking money from my bank account even when I sent them a copy of my statement to show they had begun taking payments from me.
Similar story here, it's a bit of a loophole, self employed, particularly company directors who take a small salary and pay the reset as dividends end up with very small "judgements" from the CSA, my ex tried it on and ended up being told £27 a week was all she could expect!

I obviously pay a lot more than that but it's a fair amount rather than the grand or so a month she had in mind in the first place.

As has already been said, consult your accountant, he will know what to do! (mine did)
Made the call to my accountant this morning, in the meantime, I do not want to have any comunication with the CSA that might predjudice further negotiations.

Justayellowbadge

37,057 posts

273 months

Monday 22nd November 2010
quotequote all
You don't negotiate with the CSA.

Unusually, it seems, I've found them decent and reasonable. I just regret that I found myself in the situation where they come into play.