rear pads are 70% worn sir, best change them...scam or real?
rear pads are 70% worn sir, best change them...scam or real?
Author
Discussion

remoh

Original Poster:

147 posts

295 months

Wednesday 1st December 2010
quotequote all
Hi,

Had my car in at a main dealer that is part of a well known automotive chain and was told as part of the free check that my rear pads were 70% worn and should be changed.

Surely if they are 70% worn, this would mean theres another 30% available for use surely? I cant imagine our german friends accepting a 30% inefficiency?

Should I change or should I wait? Its on a 3.0 Le Mans A6 Saloon if that makes any difference..

Interested in peoples thoughts....

cuprabob

19,971 posts

245 months

Wednesday 1st December 2010
quotequote all
Dealers tend to be conservative as they may not see the car again until the next service which can be upto 2 yeats away by which time they may have worn completely. If it was me I would not change them just yet but keep an eye on them when they get down to about 1mm

Tame Technician

2,467 posts

235 months

Wednesday 1st December 2010
quotequote all
If your car was a mistery shop, and the tech didnt "advise" rear pads were getting low, the dealer would fail.

If they said, they are completely worn out and require replacement and were found to have 30% left, that would be a scam.



remoh

Original Poster:

147 posts

295 months

Wednesday 1st December 2010
quotequote all
cuprabob said:
Dealers tend to be conservative as they may not see the car again until the next service which can be upto 2 yeats away by which time they may have worn completely. If it was me I would not change them just yet but keep an eye on them when they get down to about 1mm
2 years between services is unlikely for me, more like 8-9 months....I just wonder if I should take it back to a main dealer for the pads or an independant....



M

cuprabob

19,971 posts

245 months

Wednesday 1st December 2010
quotequote all
It's your call whether you go back to the main dealer or go to a local VAG independant.

Iain328

15,126 posts

237 months

Wednesday 1st December 2010
quotequote all
Ask them how many mm of pad material are left - if its under 3 then I'd change them.

For reference, the pads (and discs) that are currently in my VW Passat have done about 40K miles now - there is life left in them yet.

cuprabob

19,971 posts

245 months

Wednesday 1st December 2010
quotequote all
Iain328 said:
Ask them how many mm of pad material are left - if its under 3 then I'd change them.

For reference, the pads (and discs) that are currently in my VW Passat have done about 40K miles now - there is life left in them yet.
IMO 3mm is too early to change the rear pads. Fronts yes, but rears have less material from new.

Disk and Pad life is totally down to driving style. My R32 is still on the original pads and discs after 75k miles and here is plenty of life in them yet.

remoh

Original Poster:

147 posts

295 months

Wednesday 1st December 2010
quotequote all
Tame Technician said:
If your car was a mistery shop, and the tech didnt "advise" rear pads were getting low, the dealer would fail.

If they said, they are completely worn out and require replacement and were found to have 30% left, that would be a scam.
nope not a deliberatly broken car supplied by mk and no camera in my tie ;-> I've heard what they do on these, have to say its good the industry is taking these steps to weed out those that sail close to the wind..


In this case it was the advise and best book you in thing......Well done in a way as most people probably wouldnt query it and I'm guessing it gets up the workshop hours etc....Its booked in for next week, lets see...I think they wanted a fair sum of this as well....anyone got any comparative costs?


Pads is a fairly muppet job isnt it?




blueg33

47,025 posts

255 months

Wednesday 1st December 2010
quotequote all
Rear pads on my A6 3.0 le mans are on 75k miles. I expect they will need doing at the next service but I haven't looked at them yet.

I did front pads and discs myself when the dealer said they were low. I reckon there was life in both but not enough to get the car to the next service, rears are a pain because you need VAGCOM to wind back the electromechanical parking brake (I think)

fatboy b

9,666 posts

247 months

Thursday 2nd December 2010
quotequote all

It's a typical Audi scam I'm afraid. I did 30K miles on pads that I was told were 70% worn and needed replacing. I otherwise get good service from them, but this really pisses me off!

Edited by fatboy b on Thursday 2nd December 08:09

Boshly

2,776 posts

267 months

Thursday 2nd December 2010
quotequote all
It's not just Audi, I've had it many times, and my wife even more often (dare I suggest sexism!). One main dealer even suggested they needed changing, then when politely told not to bother, suggested again at the next service that they only had x% remaining. I had to point out that my wife had obviously not used her brakes in a year because they suggested the same % remaining 12months previously and we had not had them changed.

I think they are a bit more careful how they present it nowadays but it definitely used to be a 'scam' using the easiest close for a sale, the 'scare' close.

Cost Captain

3,920 posts

211 months

Thursday 2nd December 2010
quotequote all
fatboy b said:
It's a typical Audi scam I'm afraid. I did 30K miles on pads that I was told were 70% worn and needed replacing. I otherwise get good service from them, but this really pisses me off!

Edited by fatboy b on Thursday 2nd December 08:09
how is it a scam?

they say the brakes are 70% worn, any point after this its advisable to change them.

how much of a rant would the OP be having if the car had been serviced and between services the pads ground on the discs meaning they needed changing too, but the dealer hadn't advised them of the pads being 70% worn?

Surely any parts that are 'required' on a service should have been advised on the previous one assume constant wear and tear?

fatboy b

9,666 posts

247 months

Thursday 2nd December 2010
quotequote all
Cost Captain said:
fatboy b said:
It's a typical Audi scam I'm afraid. I did 30K miles on pads that I was told were 70% worn and needed replacing. I otherwise get good service from them, but this really pisses me off!

Edited by fatboy b on Thursday 2nd December 08:09
how is it a scam?

they say the brakes are 70% worn, any point after this its advisable to change them.

how much of a rant would the OP be having if the car had been serviced and between services the pads ground on the discs meaning they needed changing too, but the dealer hadn't advised them of the pads being 70% worn?

Surely any parts that are 'required' on a service should have been advised on the previous one assume constant wear and tear?
The scam is that they report them as 70% worn when often they're not. In my case the car had 23K on the clock when they advised replacement "due to being 70% worn". I knew they weren't. 30K miles later, I knew they were 70-75% worn. So that'd mean they were about 30% worn at 23K miles.

alolympic

700 posts

228 months

Thursday 2nd December 2010
quotequote all
Why don't you just whip the wheel off and check the depth left on the pad yourself? Crazy concept I know.....

remoh

Original Poster:

147 posts

295 months

Thursday 2nd December 2010
quotequote all
alolympic said:
Why don't you just whip the wheel off and check the depth left on the pad yourself? Crazy concept I know.....
I should be able to trust what a approved dealer is telling me.......

<rose coloured glasses off> ;->

siwil1

1,022 posts

262 months

Thursday 2nd December 2010
quotequote all
The Rear pads on an A6 are considerabley thinner than the fronts, To balance the dealer bashing I asked if ours were low on the last service and was advised the above and that their was nothing to worry about, they had done 36k miles.

It is a pain that the rears need to use computer magic to replace the pads as I would normally do these myself, Bloody hate the electronic parking brake aswell!

With these feet

5,733 posts

246 months

Thursday 2nd December 2010
quotequote all
Tech might not want to second guess what you do with the car after the service.
I was a tech for quite a few years, the call to change or not is down to the owner, not the dealer. So regardless of what advised, the customer makes the decision.
If you want to do another 20k on a set of pads that have done say, 30k, then thats your call.
I remember advising many owners about stuff and them not doing anything about it.
Plus we used to get 0.6 of an hour to fit pads. Ok so the car might be on the ramp but on its own 36 minutes is not long so in some cases the techs just advise.

Something else that is often ignored or not checked, is condition of inner disc. Many FW drive cars destroy rear discs as they get little use and corrode. Only time it comes up is MOT time.

NBirkitt

252 posts

222 months

Friday 3rd December 2010
quotequote all
Again, it all depends on driving style, but an added perspective relating to pad wear (especially rears, which aren't normally expected to wear very much) is that ESP has quite an effect – independently and automatically using light applications of the brakes to modulate the handling, when the driver may not think that his driving style makes heavy use of the brakes. I've come across several cases of traditionally 'careful braking' drivers who've upgraded to modern ESP cars, then complaining that the rear brakes wear much faster than they're used to...

remoh

Original Poster:

147 posts

295 months

Monday 27th December 2010
quotequote all
NBirkitt said:
Again, it all depends on driving style, but an added perspective relating to pad wear (especially rears, which aren't normally expected to wear very much) is that ESP has quite an effect – independently and automatically using light applications of the brakes to modulate the handling, when the driver may not think that his driving style makes heavy use of the brakes. I've come across several cases of traditionally 'careful braking' drivers who've upgraded to modern ESP cars, then complaining that the rear brakes wear much faster than they're used to...
Delayed reply, apologies...

Some interesting points, I do have a comparison to my last car....a 57 S6 and didnt have this issue on that....Although I do think you raise some interesting points....ta

M

Deva Link

26,934 posts

276 months

Monday 27th December 2010
quotequote all
The SEAT dealer which services my daughter's Ibiza called out the blue the other day asking when we'd like to bring the car in to have the front pads changed.

I asked why, and the girl said they noted they were 55% worn at the last service, a few months ago. I tried to tie her up in knots but she was so thick it didn't work and I ended up feeling sorry for her. rolleyes