RE: You What Mate?!
Friday 16th April 2004

You What Mate?!

Loud, fast music makes you drive like a nob


This week the RAC Foundation brought media attention to focus on music being played in cars.

They've highlighted new research by Canadian scientists, which showed that loud music can be a potential hazard to motorists, as it can cause significant reductions in reaction time on the roads. The study found that reaction times diminished by up to 20% when a person was subject to loud volumes – this is enough to cause a potentially fatal delay even for a motorist driving in good weather and at moderate speed.

In the study, people performed physical and mental tasks while listening to levels of noise varying from 53 decibels (about the level of an office environment) to 95 decibels (the equivalent of an oil rig). The results show that reaction times decreased significantly at higher noise levels for both physical and mental tasks. At the highest level, reaction times to tasks that involve decision making, decreased by 20%.

Previous research by the RAC Foundation also shows that as well as listening to music quietly, motorists should be careful to pick slower tempo music if they want to avoid an accident. The research found that drivers who were listening to music with a fast beat were twice as likely to go through a red light and have twice as many accidents.

The RAC Foundation has compiled a list of music to play while driving, albeit quietly. The following sounds will ensure you drive in a mellowed out and considerate manner:

  1. Gary Jules – "Mad World"
  2. Lemar – "Another Day"
  3. Sugababes – "Too lost in You"
  4. Blue – "Breathe Easy"
  5. Norah Jones – "Come away with me"

Tracks that will have you driving like a loon and taking off over humped back bridges include:

  1. Wagner "The ride of the Valkyries"
  2. Prodigy – "Firestarter"
  3. Basement Jaxx – "Red Alert"
  4. Faithless – "Insomnia"
  5. Verdi – "Dies Irae (Requiem)"

Edmund King, Executive Director of the RAC Foundation said: "THE FINDINGS OF THE CANADIAN STUDY ARE BAD NEWS FOR DECIBEL LOVING DRIVERS, AS THEY PROVE THAT NOT ONLY IS LOUD MUSIC A NUISANCE TO OTHERS, IT COULD ALSO BE THE CAUSE OF ACCIDENTS ON THE ROADS".

Conrad King, Consultant Psychologist to the RAC Foundation, said "It is important that drivers choose their music carefully when driving, as uptempo music has been shown to cause drivers to have double the amount of accidents as those listening to slower music. In general, if music is above 60 beats per minute, listeners experience a faster heart rate and increased blood pressure. It doesn’t matter if you listen to opera, classical or the latest rave music. It’s the speed of the beat that counts."

An independent survey carried out by Ted walking along the road yesterday concluded that the loudest music comes from the smallest cars.

Author
Discussion

RB Will

Original Poster:

10,604 posts

261 months

Friday 16th April 2004
quotequote all
I agree with the bit about the higher the bpm the faster your heart may go, surely this makes you more alert (thats what you get taught in A-Level Biology anyway) . I listen to hardcore while driving and that generally plays at over 150bpm. I dont play it too loud though I prefer to be able to har the engine aswell. No accidents though. I think it may be more to do with what people think of the music rather than the speed or another factor, with my hardcore playing im happy and awake it makes me feel good. I had a friend in the car the other day and to be nice I let them have one of their cds on,RnB bad idea. The slow beat really slowed me up. Its a serious distraction.

gjohnsto

972 posts

278 months

Friday 16th April 2004
quotequote all
Gary Jules – "Mad World"
Lemar – "Another Day"
Sugababes – "Too lost in You"
Blue – "Breathe Easy"
Norah Jones – "Come away with me"

If this was all there was to listen to when you were in your car, you would be safer, as you would never want to get in the car again.

pdV6

16,442 posts

282 months

Friday 16th April 2004
quotequote all
RAC said:

Norah Jones – "Come away with me"

Think again guys. MrsV6 has a habit of popping this on whilst I'm driving (separate issue, who controls the music...) and its so bl00dy soporific that I'm fairly sure it would have the same kind of effect that we're apparently trying to avoid!

pdV6

16,442 posts

282 months

Friday 16th April 2004
quotequote all
gjohnsto said:

If this was all there was to listen to when you were in your car, you would be safer, as you would never want to get in the car again.

CarZee

13,382 posts

288 months

Friday 16th April 2004
quotequote all
gjohnsto said:
If this was all there was to listen to when you were in your car, you would be safer, as you would never want to get in the car again.
Falling asleep at the wheel or simply piling yourself into the armco out of manic depression become significantly more likely outcomes too...

chris_crossley

1,164 posts

304 months

Friday 16th April 2004
quotequote all
Can i assume from this that we will have BPM Scamera s with the justicifaction that by playing the music you where commiting an "INCITMENT TO SPEED". Obviousley there will be a £60 fine . They may even cosider charging you for how many BPM over the 60 you where going.


rude girl

6,937 posts

280 months

Friday 16th April 2004
quotequote all
Research

A tenner says this is the outcome of some PhD student fannying around for a couple of years instead of doing a proper job.

Conclusion: Don't whatever you do, do anything that might give you any enthusiasm for life. FFS.

and since half my friends have PhDs, I'm now expecting to have to throw away a lot fewer Christmas cards next January

hornet

6,333 posts

271 months

Friday 16th April 2004
quotequote all
The conspiracy theorist in me would like to know if all the suggested tracks and artists are on the same record label....

FunkyNige

9,682 posts

296 months

Friday 16th April 2004
quotequote all
hornet said:
The conspiracy theorist in me would like to know if all the suggested tracks and artists are on the same record label....



Two of the bad ones - Faithless (cheeky) and The Prodigy (XL) aren't.

Besides, Insomnia isn't an up-tempo track and is quite relaxing I find, what's the problem with it?

hornet

6,333 posts

271 months

Friday 16th April 2004
quotequote all
How long before we see someone injured in an accident trying to sue a record company for failing to warn them that listening to the CD in their car was likely to increase their chances of having an accident?

Munter

31,330 posts

262 months

Friday 16th April 2004
quotequote all
The thing is I tend to put on something I like to listen to loud when I intend to drive like a loon! (within the rules of the land obviously ) So yes the 2 are linked in my case...but not in the way they think!...

Xm5eR

5,094 posts

269 months

Friday 16th April 2004
quotequote all
When anything by Blue or Sugarbabes comes on the radio I am most likely to be found swerving across the road as I desperately try to smash the facia off my radio.

burriana500

16,556 posts

275 months

Friday 16th April 2004
quotequote all
Bang goes Gabby's Twinkle Twinkle Little Star CD then

dodge

87 posts

287 months

Friday 16th April 2004
quotequote all
I love the idea of driving round with "The ride of the Valkyries" booming out... surely nobody actually does that? Brings up memories of the Blues Brothers!

Also, Ted is spot on about the big noise/small car thing! Good stuff.

RB Will

Original Poster:

10,604 posts

261 months

Friday 16th April 2004
quotequote all
i dunno about what ted says I never heard loud music coming from a Smart car or a Caterfield

Xm5eR

5,094 posts

269 months

Friday 16th April 2004
quotequote all
dodge said:
I love the idea of driving round with "The ride of the Valkyries" booming out... surely nobody actually does that? .


I did this last week, great fun. Strangely I killed noone at the time. I couldn't help thinking that Charlie dont surf, mind

v8thunder

27,647 posts

279 months

Friday 16th April 2004
quotequote all
Never mind fast and slow music - what about cool music?

Seriously - when I'm listening to some Lalo Schifrin or Duane Eddy, or even a John Barry score, I am suddenly inclined to drive like I'm being followed/following someone/about to burst down a side street in a haze of tortured rubber, no matter what speed it's at.

I must admit, heavy metal seems to extend a foot out of the stereo and plant it firmly on the loud pedal, chilled-out indie/pop makes me wind down the window, stick some shades on and steer with my little finger, and dance music has me using my clutch foot to kick in the stereo.

Ever noticed how anything with a catchy rhythm or beat has you changing gear to it?

Fatboy

8,248 posts

293 months

Friday 16th April 2004
quotequote all
dodge said:
I love the idea of driving round with "The ride of the Valkyries" booming out... surely nobody actually does that?

Er, my dad used to - and then promptly drive like a total lunatic Never hit anything apart from pheasants (which he was aiming at) though...

cortinaman

3,230 posts

274 months

Saturday 17th April 2004
quotequote all
Gary Jules – "Mad World"
Lemar – "Another Day"
Sugababes – "Too lost in You"
Blue – "Breathe Easy"
Norah Jones – "Come away with me"

if anyone put these on in my car i'd get INSTANT roadrage and no doubt start to call them a "tone deaf ct".

now where is my copy of 'straight outta compton'.......

Andrew P

25 posts

287 months

Sunday 18th April 2004
quotequote all
I seem to remember seeing a bit of research in the media a few years ago that found loud heavy rock improved reaction time but made people drive faster. I think loud and heavy can wake you up and that's pretty much all I can hear in my Chimera at speed, not that I generally need waking up, driving it is so much fun.